Donald Faison and Minka Kelly
Before our crush from Clueless and “Scrubs” got engaged to girlfriend Cacee Cobb, and before Kelly was linked to Derek Jeter for years, these two were an item. And not just a temporary one-date-and-it’s-not-happening item, but an item that lasted about a year and ended in 2004. They tried to keep things on and popping, but eventually, the thrill was gone. If things don’t work out with Cacee, you know I still got love for you Donald!