Distinguished Gentlemen: Our Fine and Favorite Men Over Forty
Matthew McConahey, age 42
I know, I know – Matthew isn’t always as handsome as he should be. There are times when he looks like he hasn’t showered in days but instead has been on a week-long beer binge with some frat boys. I agree. But when he’s showered and shaved, there’s nothing you can say except, “Yep, I knew he had it in him.”