The 15 Most Outrageous Catfish Episodes
Mike and Caroline
Mike was in love with Caroline, a beautiful redhead who couldn’t see him because she was battling colon cancer. Only, she wasn’t. “Caroline” was a perfectly healthy woman named Heather who’d been stalking Mike for months. What’s crazier is this was the second time she’d Catfished Mike. After she revealed her true identity the first time, Mike said he wasn’t interested. So Caroline pretended to be another woman just so she could “date” him again.