MadameNoire Featured Video
1 of 9

Amanda Seales arrives at the Los Angeles Premiere Of Focus Features' 'Harriet' held at The Orpheum Theatre on October 29, 2019 in Los Angeles, California, United States.

Source: WENN/Avalon / WENN

Nowadays, it seems like comedian and actress (and now author) Amanda Seales is always in the news and can’t catch a break from criticism. Is it fair, though? Or is it more good than bad? Let’s take a look back on the most controversial moments of the star thus far. Remember, she told you guys that she’s not for everybody.


The Uh-Oh: The #RodneyReed Drama

A lot has happened so we’ll simplify it for you.

There has recently been a call to action to clear the name of a Black man named Rodney Reed. The Innocence Project has been working for quite some time to try and free him after they say he was wrongly convicted of rape and murder. While on Death Row with a date of execution approaching quickly, he was granted an indefinite stay recently, meaning he was told that he no longer has an execution date.

Before that happened, many celebrities took to the Internet to raise awareness in the hopes of saving Reed. One of those celebrities included Seales.

Recently though, she made a video, which went viral, withdrawing her support and saying she would do better in the future about “rushing to the aid” of causes without enough knowledge. She said she researched the case herself and found that Reed had allegedly sexually assaulted a number of women, including a 12-year-old. She said those who have rallied for Reed went out of their way to hide such information in their attempts to keep him from being executed.

“The campaign to stay the execution of Rodney Reed and exonerate him was launched by supporters of Rodney Reed who believe him to be innocent of the murder of Stacey Stites,” she said. “This, I’m going to call it propaganda though, was presented to people like you and me with a very decisive, clear-cut intention to not include the entire bigger picture of Rodney Reed as he presents as a criminal and danger to women.”

“It feels very duplicitous that those who were pushing for this, not just his family, but individuals who fancy themselves activists were doing so with the knowledge that this person, Rodney Reed, is not just accused of, but has been linked to previous rapes via his DNA being discovered within the victim,” she added. “He has been ID’d by a woman who escaped him.”

Her video, though, drew the criticism of many, including activist Shaun King, who publicly called her out and claimed she was spreading misinformation. King and the Reed family said that most of the things she brought up have been debunked or dismissed. Others said that despite his alleged past, he still had the right to justice in the particular case that landed him on Death Row.

In conclusion, this situation was all one big mess.

NBA Awards 2019 Arrivals

Source: Adriana M. Barraza/ / WENN

The Good: NoJulz

Julieanna Goddard, also known as @YesJulz, a notable clout chaser and pot-stirrer enthusiast started a fight online when she took the time to call out influencers Scottie Beam and Karen Civil on the Easily Offended podcast with Murda Mook, ItsBizKit and Movie Matt. Mook, in particular, not only allowed such foolishness to occur, but he also agreed with her claim to being Black (she’s not) even though she made a career off of ridiculing Black culture.

Enter Amanda Seales to shut this all down. She wrote a short but pointed Instagram post to share her opinion on the mess:

“There are too many white women who think a fat a– makes them superior to a black queen,” she wrote. “There are too many black men who agree.”

HBO's Official 2019 Emmy After Party - Arrivals

Source: FilmMagic / Getty

The Bad: The Emmy Party Fiasco

This one was a whole to-do. Seales was initially not formally invited to an Emmy after-party celebrating Black Hollywood. She was not invited because of a less than glowing relationship with the publicist of Insecure co-star and creator Issa Rae. However, Seales said that actor Jesse Williams invited her to the event so she decided to show up.

Well, she would not be allowed into the event, claiming a white woman barred her from entering the party and had security remove her from the premises when she found her way in. She would later find that she was treated this way because Rae’s publicist didn’t want her to be there. Many wondered why she wanted, or felt entitled to be in a space she wasn’t invited to, and one of her co-stars even gave his two cents, criticizing her.

Afterward, Twitter accounts popped up claiming that Seales is an overall unpleasant person to work with and they were not surprised her “true colors” were being exposed as her career flourishes. However, until a full call-out post complete with tea, scones, and receipts find its way onto my timeline, it may be nothing but gossip and haters.

2017 BET Awards

Source: FayesVision/ / WENN

The Good: The Time She Got Lyfe Jennings Together for “Slave” Song

Back in September, singer Lyfe Jennings released a song with some rather disturbing lyrics:

Got your a– hoppin’ like a frog / Got your legs shakin’ like two wet dogs / This ain’t the part we fall in love / This is the part we kiss and f–k.  … I’m gon’ beat it like a slave / So you don’t run away / Got the whips and chains / Call me master.

Seales posted an Instagram recording of herself responding to the song, sharing her disdain at the fact that he was comparing sex to the horrific acts of violence associated with centuries of human bondage.

Charlamagne the God reposted Seales video with the caption, “Some of ya’ll don’t have any friends. If you did you wouldn’t make mistakes like this record. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 @amandaseales.”

Jennings responded angrily, claiming that Seales and Charlamagne were using their platform to bash him and his new song. But, I mean, come on. It was ridiculous.



BET's 'Black Girls Rock!' - Arrivals

Source: Derrick Salters/ / WENN

The Bad: The Invest in a Passport Over Jordans Mess

In 2017, Seales sent this tweet out and started a whole new argument on Twitter :

While her message may be about investing in experiences rather than things, her words may have done more harm than good. Some people tweeted that she was being classist because she seemed to be talking down to poor people. The argument was that she was ridiculing poor folk for wanting nice things that they can attain easily, like a pair of Jordans, instead of striving for experiential goals and suffering quietly at home until their next trip.

While Seales had a point, she made a broad generalization, judging the whole Internet without knowing their life, budget, or needs. It wasn’t her finest hour.


Source: Derrick Salters/ / WENN

The Good: A Teaching Moment With Caitlyn Jenner 

During Katy Perry’s live streams she was doing in 2017, the singer had a dinner that Seales was invited to. During that conversation, Seales shut Caitlyn Jenner down during a discussion about the future of this country. 

She explained to Jenner that the phrase, “I believe in this country,” has a different meaning for a white person than it does for a Black woman, thoroughly checking Jenner’s privilege.

She later said in an interview that she felt like a “warrior of truth” at that moment. She said that Perry’s global following needed to hear the truth because they are not getting it from mainstream media.

This moment is also where her iconic, “I’m not hostile, I’m passionate” phrase was born.


Celebrity Sightings In New York City - October 03, 2019

Source: Raymond Hall / Getty


The Uh-Oh: The Child Support Debate

Seales started a fight on Twitter after she shared her opinion on women asking their exes to provide child support back in 2017. She wrote:

“Stop bringing the gvt in because you mad it didn’t work out. Stop using your children to further your petty agenda. Stop keeping fathers from their kids because they’re not interested in you. If he is physically and financially present to the best of his abilities, get out your feelings and get into co-parenting.”

Many people had various clashing opinions on the matter, mostly defending women and bashing men who refuse to care for the child they created. Many accused the star of being a proud member of the #PickMePatrol.

BET Awards 2019 - Portraits

Source: Bennett Raglin / Getty

The Good: Her Strong Stance on People Defending R. Kelly

Seales did not hold back when it came to people defending R. Kelly. When she was interviewed on The Breakfast Club in January of this year, she stood firmly for boycotting the crooner after Surviving R. Kelly aired. She said she does not give any comedian a pass to joke about R. Kelly without clearly renouncing him. She could not separate the art from the artist considering the art was inspired by violence against underaged Black girls. And she won’t look past anyone defending him, no matter who they are.

“What are you really defending?” she asked. “Are you defending your own villainy? Are you defending the denial of your own victimhood? Are you defending your own willful ignorance at this point?”

International Myeloma Foundation 13th Annual Comedy Celebration benefiting the Peter Boyle Research Fund & supporting the Black Swan Research Initiative

Source: Araya Diaz / Getty

The Uh-Oh: The Myron Rolle Controversy

Seales accused former NFL player and neurosurgeon Myron Rolle of the sexual harassment of other women. After she had to “take a step back” in her own correspondences with Rolle after some uncomfortable moments, a woman came forward to say that she met up with him for a date only to have him open the door for her butt naked and act as if she overreacted about his nudity. Others spoke out about Rolle, but he maintained that the accusations against him were “absolutely false and should be characterized as exactly what they are — acts of bullying, intimidation and retaliation.” Speaking out about the situation caused her to receive a lot of criticism, specifically from Black men who said she changed her story about her own interactions with Rolle. She actually received death threats from some people. Seales said the situation taught her to change the way she interacted with people on social media, including her penchant for clapping back, because “this is not healthy.”

Premiere Of NBC's "Bring The Funny"

Source: FayesVision/ / WENN

The Good: “Ni–as Got Me F–ked Up”

This is a song for one of those days. “Ni–as Got Me F–ked Up” is a super catchy song to bump to when you’re calmly ready to gather some edges. The music video features a hilarious set of characters that try Seales’s nerves until she finally lets them have it. Who hasn’t been there?


Comment Disclaimer: Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN