'Cookie Jarring' Has Made A Comeback And It Isn't Sweet

African american woman holding jar of chocolate chips cookies over pink isolated background with angry face, negative sign showing dislike with thumbs down, rejection concept — Source: AaronAmat

Daters beware! “Cookie jarring” is on the rise, and while it may sound sweet, it’s anything but. This toxic dating trend, which originally surfaced in 2019, according to the Daily Mail, has made a comeback, and it occurs when someone dates multiple people at the same time to find the right match. However, in their pursuit of love, they may have no genuine intention of building a long-term relationship with some of the people they date.

Relationship expert Arrezzo Azim says that this strategy can be particularly dangerous for the person who is being cookie jarred because oftentimes they are being strung along, kept on the back burner until their indecisive date finally decides whether they want to progress the relationship. This could lead to heartbreak for some.

“Let’s be honest, you’re keeping them on the side because you want to have somebody else as [a] back-up in case this doesn’t work out,” Azim, a Positive Psychology Coach, told the Daily Mail on July 4. “The attention’s amazing — but the long-term effects are a lot worse if you do it that way.”

Exhausted black couple with kitchen utensils having hard time baking on color background — Source: Prostock-Studio

Finding love and building a committed relationship with someone can feel scary, and if that feeling isn’t mutual, it can lead to heartbreaking rejection. People who cookie jar typically have their defense guard up when dating, so to prevent the “sting” of rejection from surfacing, they may string someone along to have them as a “back up plan” even though there may not be a romantic spark, explained Azim in a TikTok video posted in 2021. Bottom line: they are insecure.

But this toxic dating habit benefits no one, says Theresa Herring, a licensed marriage and family therapist. Herring, founder of Centered Connections in Illinois, explained that this approach often leaves the person on the receiving end feeling confused and emotionally dependent if a romantic connection develops.

“And it prevents the person you’ve cookie jarred from meeting someone who actually likes them enough to date them,” Herring told NBC News in 2019.

Additionally, it can backfire if the person that the cookie jarrer is genuinely interested in finds out.

How do you protect yourself?

So, how do you protect yourself from cooking jarring? According to psychologist and author Tina B. Tessina, there are a few tell-tale signs of cooking jarring that you should be on high alert for when dating.

“â€‹â€‹If your date never wants to make a definite plan (would you like to go out Friday night?) and just wants to come over to your house on the spur of the moment, he/she doesn’t make an effort to keep in touch (you should not be making all the effort) and doesn’t seem to think about the future, they’re probably just using you as ‘reserve,” she revealed to NBC News.

If you notice those signs, it’s time to have an honest conversation. Before doing so, make sure you’re clear about what you want from the relationship. That way, you can decide whether to move forward based on how the other person responds.

If you’re reading this and identify as a cookie jarrer, dating trend expert Eugénie Legendre says you should give yourself time to date someone “without the influence of anyone else,” to see if there is truly a connection worth building before you move on to the next person. Give it some time to see if something truly special develops.

Have you ever been the victim of cookie jarring, or found yourself doing it to someone else? Share your experience in the comments below.