There are important elements to a hit song like a beat that will bring you out of your seat and a bass line that will cause you to make a funky face. However one of the most important parts of a song is the vocals. Sometimes a song that should have been a hit will lose its thunder because of a singer who can’t match the flavor. The beat can be Hot as hell but paired with the wrong singer the whole track can become a dud. Take a look at these songs that would sound better if someone else recorded the vocals.
Source: thebestofblack.blogspot.com
Amerie “Touch”
In an attempt to ride off of Lil Jon’s s success, Amerie recruited the master of crunk to produce the title track of her sophomore album. “Touch” had all the makings of a club banger—a high energy beat, catchy chorus and seductive attitude—but it lacked one fundamental element: a voice to match it. Unfortunately Amerie is too adorable to convincingly sing Hot songs. She makes baby kittens look like mole rats. In the song, the R&B songstress coos, “I know you think I’m a good girl,” but that’s the thing, we know she’s a good girl: not only did she sing the cute hit “Why Don’t We Fall In Love,” she graduated from Georgetown University majoring in, of all things, English Literature. She’s the definition of the girl next door. The track needed someone less cupcake and more vixen like Teairra Mari.
Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN
Yooblue
Ciara’s voice is a mystery to me how can so many people not realize she is actually just talking she no vocal range at all she had to get her cousins to make youtube video claiming she can sing
Bahamianempress99
Wow….I’m at the point where I really want to hear all of these tracks redone with people you suggested…Can we work on that ASAP? like create some Battle of the Mics competition to see who does it better. Some people will be embarassed, but hey, the music world needs this kind of thing!
Jerzee81
Ciara has the worst voice. Period. She might as well talk the words out. No one would be able to tell the difference.
Yooblue
Ciara has the worst voice she always needs bass in her tracks and a featuring artist i.e. Ludacris that single Ride would be nothing without the bass or if Ciara had to use three octaves to sing she has to whisper when she sings and make use of the bass as singing too loudly will show the cracks in her voice. I am convinced Ciara is Trangender it explains her no ‘high notes’
Unico
You forgot “Anything sung by Rihanna” . Even amateurs on YouTube can out vocal her.
http://www.askaticket.com/concerts/madonna-tickets/ Cheap Madonna Tickets
ohh come on dude, there is no comparison between Ashanti to Kelly Rowland…..Kelly has amazing voice.
LOLAA
I like ur comment because Kelly has an AMAZINGLY WEAK voice..LMAO
nikole
compared to ashanti kelly is gold
TeamMe
I love Say I. I thought I was the only person who knew that song, lol
Ladykinchen
I would love to hear Fantasia sing Love on Top. Beyonce did good, but Fantasia would tear the end of that song up!
Dina
OMG… I could so see that! I liked Beyonce version – but more soul would have made it my jam!
luvin_me
uuuuummm I think not!
luvin_me
I think they missed a few songs so let me add one. The 1st that comes to my mind is Ray J’s “One Wish” LOVED the song…the vocals, hmmmm not so much. Sometimes I would just bust up laughing while listening to him try to belt out the lyrics.. Usher could have sang the hell outta that song!
Allie1234
When did Keyshia Cole become a good singer?
Ms_Sunshine9898
I heard Keyshia Cole live last year and the girl can blow. . . .
Allie1234
no she cant I heard her too. she is alright to sing on the street corner but she is far from a great vocalist
Caroneisha
She one the many that can jus belt any song and sound good. So yea that does make her a great vocalist.
Allie1234
It takes more than making any song sound good to be a great vocalist. I like her music but i dont think she is a strong singer.
KJ23
This kind of comes off kind of mean and judgmental.
DoinMe
Amerie is eye-candy and that’s it. I liked her One Thing….until she started singing. I’d also add Trey Songz Can’t Be Friends. It’s a good song, but he sounds like sheep when he sings.
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LKQE4UQRBBVNOIRAL4EB2SPCWI Jen
Waaaaaaaaaaaait! I just mentioned the same just last night about Trey Songz! Bleep bleep here come the sheep! LMAO right off!!!!
Dina
TREY SONGS LOOKS LIKE A CHICKEN… lil birdie chest and Sounds like a mess… CAN we please get a real man in the R&B world to do Over that boys career??!!
DoinMe
Bwwaaa!! I was trying to be nice, but you went ahead and went THERE!! LMAO!!
Caroneisha
I mean he’s okay, for me it all depends on the song.
mulan
Nick Minaj “Right Through Me” hahahaha her acting in the beginning of the video is funny as hell- i died laughing -
Ldyleo75
Everyone always want to hate on Chris brown like perfection is your blood people make mistakes and they come through them I know people who have done way more and still been forgiven grow up for God is love
Dina
Chris Brown deserves a second chance… but he needs to go away LONGER, and Grow up… no one likes a Girl beater – especially when you are so damn Tall and strong. Ugh… Gagging! He needs to go away and come back with some real growth. Not this mess about being mad and “forgiving all his enemies” What about asking for forgiveness??? Crying at the Micheal Jackson tribute is not the same thing…. NO! He needs to try again.
I am willing to give him another chance if he asks correctly.
Caroneisha
And what makes you so damn special to be asked for forgiveness? Only god can judge and if he has forgiven then to hell with everybody else.
LiiSH
This list was so spot on. I have to say kudos to the writer becasue the alternate singer isn’t necessarily someone who isn’t imaginable or even a bigger star than the original which mean consideration was given to actual vocal ability. Nicki does a great job writing the songs she calls herself singing on and Mya does need a hit so Right Thru Me makes sense. I think How to Love needed to be sung by a woman period. I have heard alot of covers and the girls were killing (plus I never think Chris Brown should sing anything). I agree with everything else except Sexual Seduction… it wouldn’t matter if t-pain sung it. It would have been as successful either way.
Guest88
I always thought Drake should’ve sung How to Love. He already has the whole “sensitive thug” vibe– plus a better voice. No way I would’ve taken Chris Brown serious. Maybe BEFORE his selfishness reared its head– not now.
Dina
Drake wrote it!! He should have sang it… BOOM!
Msmykimoto2u
He wrote that?
http://twitter.com/MzChittick Racquel Chittick
No he didn’t … lil wayne wrote it that’s why he sung it…. BOOM!
Caroneisha
Okay first off he IS NOT a thug in no shape, form or fashion okay. He is so phony and fake with that “I’m so hard,” but when he was a kid he was the biggest geek ever.
http://twitter.com/MissKillaGram Annie Oakley
its a reason y whoever wrote this is not an a&r or producer. when producers write song they usually awready have in their mind who want to sing the song and y isnt rihanna on this list cuz she cant sing at all her voice is on the same level as amerie ashanti and ciara jus wit more autotune
LiiSH
I would say becasue Rihanna sings songs that fit her voice. They aren’t lyrically complicated (sometimes they barely have lyrics… We found love anyone?) or intensely dynamic songs. They are written with the attitude she displays in mind so you don’t get that whole Amerie Touch vibe. She can talk through most of them without the song losing anything so why waste serious singing chops on something like Rude Boy?
Msmykimoto2u
Perfect point!
Dina
Yes, I think because the songs are written for Rhianna to fit her deadpan deliver! That is the only reason… notice that REALLY GOOD SINGERS Can’t sing her songs?
Caroneisha
LMAO so true!!
uh huh
Yes! A million times yes!!! I love Rihanna songs, just without her singing them. Unfaithful was a good song, but her nasally vocals killed it for me every time. She has sooooo many good songs under her belt, but with horrible vocals all over them. She needs to stick to the caribbean influenced songs. Her voice only works for those types of songs.
Just Sayin’
Say I was co-wrote by Jazmin Sullivan. She sounds way better than Christina Milian. She gives the song some much needed grit and soul. http://youtu.be/5qs48xRW5xo
DoinMe
Yes she does! I didn’t know she co-wrote that. Say I is a good song.
LaLaLaMeansILoveYou
I agree with most of these except Snoop’s. I honestly cannot imagine anyone but him doing that song and video, it was hilarious Sometimes it’s not just about the “powerhouse” vocal ability but who can convey the message of the song the best. Also love the way he broke from “singing” into his swexy rap voice then right back into the song.
Msmykimoto2u
Lol, I would sometimes love to read the comments as they were originally written before the moderators edited them. Seems like they would be hilarious
thegoodluckpig
you know i’d never really thought about it but chris brown’s rendition of how to love would’ve sounded way better. alot of these songs however are very good and i enjoy them sung by the original (im looking at you ashanti, ciara and c. milian)
AutotuneKellyR
JUST DEAD on how the writer thinks Kelly Rowland can TEAR UP anything regarding a vocal. Kelly Rowland and Ashanti are on the exact same level when it comes to vocal talent~ GROUND ZERO.
Msmykimoto2u
Woooah! I agree that sometimes Kelly sometimes sounds a mess live but you REALLY cannot compare Ashanti to Kelly Rowland of all people. When she in her zone Kelly can blow, Ashanti? Not so much…But then again, light, breathy, and whiney voices are whats in right now so Ashanti’s new album will probably be a success
LovelyDay
Kelly Rowlands zone is AUTOTUNE LANE. Chick can never and should never take the microphone and sing, straight with no track, no music because it would be apparent that she IS NOT A SINGER. She happens to be able to hit some, very very few notes but a singer she is NOT and NEVER will be as evidenced by her career.
Msmykimoto2u
Um…have you heard Ashanti live and raw??? Ugh….
thinkB4Uspeak
you a lie kelly has an AMAZiNG VOiCE , now ashanti on the other hand .
LovelyDay
IIf you think Kelly Rowland has an AMAZiNG VOiCE, then I am sure that you also believe: Tupac is still alive, Kim K’s butt is real, Bey used a surrogate and that you WILL Win the Lottery!!!
GIRL BYE
Nitty
Hey you..Bye
Dina
OOps I hit like instead of reply… PLEASE SUBTRACT ONE! LOL. Bey DID use a surrogate, there is no shame in that! The only Shame is she thinks the public is as dumb as she is… and that is impossible – she is Beautifully dumb. DEATH TO THAT TOPIC ANYHOW
Kelly Sings very well, though she is lazy and doesn’t work on her technical singing… She is just AMAZING
Dina
I disagree, though she is LAZY with her technique… Kelly sounds just like BEYONCE, only ate few octates lower. .. I would make the arguement about MYA, she is a very week singer and nothing special much like Ashanti.