Need To Know Basis: Are You Morally Obligated To Tell Your Partner If You’re Considering Abortion?

August 29th, 2012 - By Toya Sharee

 

GoodToKnow.co.uk

There are some things that most men should just not have a say in: the flower arrangements at your wedding (unless he’s David Tutera), wings vs. no wings and choosing good china.  Unfortunately, when it comes to pregnancy, a man’s opinion doesn’t get taken into much consideration past conception. Even under the most ideal circumstances much of the fuss is made over the mother-to-be.  Her skin’s glowing, everyone within a 10-foot radius wants to rub her belly and make it rain Baby Gap on her and the growing fetus. But dad…well, he just gets left on the sidelines until it’s time to head to the delivery room where he gets a pat on the back, a cigar, and in some cases, lowered expectations to play his part.

But what about when a pregnancy occurs under less than favored circumstances?  As much as some politicians want to limit or completely eliminate the options women have when it comes to their bodies and pregnancy, the options that are available to choose from are never easy to navigate when a woman faces an unintended pregnancy.  Ideally, we all would like to face that kind of situation with a partner who is committed to the relationship and truly cares about a woman’s well-being, but the fact is, babies are made every day between people who don’t care about each other, let alone want to co-parent together.  And when an unplanned pregnancy occurs some women may find that including their partner in the decision-making process is unnecessary and more trouble than it’s worth.

In most states, legally, the father has no say in whether a woman chooses to have an abortion, but if it’s possible, the father should at least be a part of the conversation.  The fact is, no woman should have to deal with the idea of an abortion alone.  When it comes to revealing a pregnancy to a partner, it’s easy for our minds to go into overdrive imagining a far worse reaction than what actually occurs.  I’d like to believe in most cases that there are responsible men who may be terrified at the idea of becoming a father, but can at least to step up to the plate as a source of support.

After Tom Akin’s comments on “legitimate rape,” President Obama quickly responded, “What I think these comments do underscore is why we shouldn’t have a bunch of politicians, a majority of whom are men, making health care decisions on behalf of women.”  While this may be true when we’re discussing women’s healthcare as a nation, there’s a big difference between a politician telling you how to handle your pregnancy and leaving the man who could potentially be your child’s father in the dark.  You know your partner best and if you’ve both talked about not wanting kids in the near future, there’s a good chance he’ll support your decision.  You also have to consider how much of a toll keeping inside information will have on the trust in your relationship if this is someone you intend on being with for a long time.  If you can’t trust him to support you in your decision or discuss something so serious rationally, you may have to question your investment into the relationship in the first place.

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • A. Cato

    I think a woman should have the final say on whether or not she carries a pregnancy to the end. No woman should have to have a baby she does not want – even if the man does not agree. Most child rearing duties are done by women. Also if a woman does not want the baby, even if she agrees that the father should raise the child, if she live ln NYC, she will be legally obligated to pay child support for a child she never wanted.

  • Pivyque

    I noticed a lot of arguing people saying that if a woman can decide to have an abortion without telling him then she needs to support the child alone once it is born. That is crazy. How can you not understand that the woman is more affected by being pregnant than the man? It is HER body. Therefore, it is her choice. ONCE THE CHILD IS BORN, it is no longer the woman’s body. It is a child that the two of them created, so BOTH parents need to be involved. When you choose to keep the baby, that is when it needs to be discussed because that is when his life is going to be affected. Some women do not want kids with that person or at that time in their lives and make that choice for themselves.

  • chanela

    tell it girl!!!

  • Candacey Doris

    I believe that in most cases it is the woman’s choice. But to be fair, he might be the type of man that wants a child. Hopefully you are with that type of man. Hopefully you’re not sleeping with a jerk that just wants to be rid of the evidence.

    • Pivyque

      Some people don’t want kids. A man is not a jerk if he doesn’t want kids.

      • Candacey Doris

        Never said he was. Men that don’t want kids or don’t want them right then can be very nice people. But the way that you handle the news that your girl is unexpectedly pregnant can make you a jerk.

        • Pivyque

          That’s true. There are ways to politely ask for an abortion.

  • Ms_Sunshine9898

    Are we really asking this? It may be a woman’s body but it is not her child alone. . .

  • RJA

    I got pregnant last year by my boyfriend and as soon as I found out, I knew I didn’t wanna keep it. I immediately made an appointment at the clinic, then I went to my bf and let him know my plans and we disagreed. He wanted me to keep it but he wasn’t ready for marriage and I wasn’t ready to become an unwed mother. We argued for days about it. Right up until my scheduled appointment. I kept my appointment but I told him that I had a miscarriage. Now we are happy, I have an IUD so I can’t get pregnant for 5 years and if we don’t get married, I’m not stuck with a kid on my own! Everything is roses :)

    • Ms_Sunshine9898

      you are a disgusting piece of work, how despicable can you be?

      • RJA

        Despicable would be having a kid I didn’t want just to please a man. Thanks for ur opinion though, Ms_Thunderclouds9898

      • RJA

        I also wanted to add that I made a decision that was right for ME! I’m enjoying my child free life. Your face is pretty “despicable” too. Like ur really ugly and I can’t quite put my finger on what type of animal u look like

        • Ms_Sunshine9898

          “ugly and animal looking” with a sense of morals and responsibility > disgusting, lying piece of work, with no idea of of contraceptive methods until it’s too late. yeah i’ll take ugly and animal looking over what you have to offer as far as being a woman and a human being. . .

          • RJA

            You are delusional as well, wth did I lie about? Anywho, u don’t know me to say anything you’re saying. I can clearly see you’re ugly though. Go fix ur face somewhere. Morals are person by person. Your morals aren’t going to be the same as the next persons. Degenerate bish

            • Ms_Sunshine9898

              yeah. . . .you’re still moral less. . .

    • Pivyque

      Make sure you are using condoms and are getting tested every 6-8 months. I see you are preventing pregnancy, but I want to remind you that STD’s are out there as well.

  • Lurker

    I do agree that IF you are in a committed relationship and see a future with your partner that you should involve him in the process. This can be a real test of whether the relationship is real or not, he should be there for you no matter what decision you decide to make. But if the pregnancy is from a fling or one night stand or between people that do not want to be together then the decision should be left to the woman. Great article!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=8210721 Joy Kamille

    Stop sleeping with rachet men. If you question whether or not he will be responsible or supportive of his child, your health and the livelyhood of you both, you shouldn’t be cutting period. Chances are you saw the signs before you got pregnant. It would crush my husband if I had considered an abortion without telling him. I wouldn’t deal with anyone of lesser character than that.

    • chanela

      THANK YOU! i said that in the “dickmatized” article and people threw me under a bus because apparently it’s a crime and “holier than thou” to have sense enough to not have sex with men that aren’t worth my time. SMH

  • Nikki

    I was raped by a friend of a friend. When I told him I was pregnant, I offered him several times to come with to the pregnancy test to see I wasn’t scamming him and for him to do the right thing.He refused. I decided to have an abortion so I could stay in school. My best friend flew down n help me find an abortion clinic. I felt so alone and isolated. A woman should do what’s best for her

    • Anon

      I certainly don’t mean to be insensitive about your situation at all. But I have never heard of a woman communicating with and trying to reason with someone who raped her.

      • NiceNasty

        Sorry but I agree.

  • Nope

    If you decide to birth or abort on your own, then you should pay for and provide on your own. Men have grown tired of the a la carte/convenient independence a lot of women put out there.

    • sam

      I have to agree. I don’t think women can complain and moan about men not being in their children’s lives and abandoning them, and then want to make unilateral decisions about murdering the child. There is a life involved, that 2 PEOPLE made, and unless there was rape or a crime involved, 2 PEOPLE should make the decision. Otherwise, provide on your own.

      • http://www.facebook.com/nikia.dshiznit Nikia D-Shiznit

        It’s not murder. The law has decided that women have a right to abortion. Murder is illegal. It should be unilateral since it’s her body, no matter how many people made the child. Women can complain about men being in their child’s life, because to be in a child’s life would mean a birth occurred. Pre birth, you have no say or right. Post birth, you have a duty, right AND responsibility to that child.

        • Nope

          I think a lot of women are all about rights, until consequences are involved or ish hits the fan. The fact is when it comes to parenting and the decisions that come with it, men are treated as second class parent or the less important one…. until $$$ is required.

          • Ms_Sunshine9898

            You hit the nail on the head! So the question is : True or False: If women are given total and complete control of their reproductive rights, then women should be 100% responsible for the financial and parental upbringing of their children.

        • sam

          So politicians and the Supreme Court are the final say in what is moral and right??? So that was what White people said to justify lynching because the CONSTITUTION used to say that Black people were property. But it was the LAW, so it was cool??? A HEARTBEAT is detected in a fetus at 6 WEEKS. So a baby with a heartbeat is not a life??? There are other options if you don’t want to be a mother that don’t involve abortion (and i’m not talking about women or kids who are raped so don’t start on that).

          • http://www.facebook.com/nikia.dshiznit Nikia D-Shiznit

            The fact is that too many men want say and control over something that is not theirs- you watch politics, I’m sure. Women should have the last say with their bodies. Period. A fetus cannot sustain life. If it is not viable outside the womb then it is not life. Women should be granted the same freedoms as men- the ability to walk away from parenthood when it is not suitable for us. You cannot make someone carry your seed. The only thing you are entitled to is your opinion.

            • Nope


              Women should be granted the same freedoms as men”

              Women made the same argument about serving on the front lines of the military… until war broke out in the early 90s, and those advocates haven’t been heard from since. Like I said, a lot of women want the choice that comes with rights, but not the consequences.

            • sam

              You can walk away from parenthood by placing the child for adoption. And there is a SERIOUS flaw in your “a fetus cannot sustain life” argument. 50 years ago, a baby born at 5 months had a 100% mortality because there was not enough medical knowledge to keep preemies alive. So by your argument, that child wasn’t a life because it couldn’t live on it’s own. But in 2012, most babies born premature, even at 5 months, live and do well. So, it wasn’t a life in 1960, but it’s a life now??? That’s pretty arbitrary don’t you think? We should protect humans that can’t protect themselves. And sometimes you have to protect them from the mother….

              • http://www.facebook.com/nikia.dshiznit Nikia D-Shiznit

                It’s funny how people like you dip into business that’s not yours, but in the same light, have no intention of helping to support that lives you so called are concerned about. Put your money where your mouth is. Fact of the matter is this: Roe v Wade decided this a long time ago. Kids being tossed around in the adoption system is not better, either. They may or may not have a decent home to go to. Most of the time, it’s the latter. A lot of women bear the brunt of the responsibility, but men want a say. Funny. I dont get why it’s a blow to men to let women decide. It should Never be used as BC, but women should not be ashamed of a decision that is as private as that. Marriage is exempt. I’ll be damned if I consult anyone over decisions i make about my body. Think about that.

                • sam

                  You don’t know where my money is. And kids in adoption “MAY or MAY NOT” have a decent home, but at least they have a chance. But a DEAD BABY DEFINITELY HAS NO CHANCE! And when the Constitution said Black people were 3/5ths of a person, did that make it RIGHT? Or would you have been saying that it must be true because a group of 9 white men said it was true?! It’s good you are thinking about YOUR body and YOUR life. Someone should think about the BABY’S BODY and the BABY’S life.
                  Peace out. You can’t handle the truth…

            • Ms_Sunshine9898

              So basically a mother’s paternal rights are far more important that that of the father’s? Yet we expect men to step up and play the role of the piggy bank when we do choose to have these children that we had no business conceiving to begin with. if it’s her body then in that case women should be solely responsible for the financial and parental responsibilities of their babies. . .

            • Pivyque

              You are so right :-) Women should be granted the same freedoms as men-the ability to walk away from parenthood when it is not suitable for us. I just had to type that again…lol

      • Nope

        I honestly think there should even be a statue of limitations for child support. In some states (most?) the mother can file for support anytime up to the child’s 18th birthday, and the father owes every penny of that ‘back’ balance. Some women confuse a man deciding to HAVE SEX WITH THEM, with actually wanting to have a child with them.

        • http://www.facebook.com/nikia.dshiznit Nikia D-Shiznit

          And men confuse women by not strapping up and preventing this in the first place.

          • Nope

            “men confuse women”?? There’s no “confusing” involved, usually just a woman trying to live out the movie going on in her head.

            Lets be honest:

            1. Most men go raw because women let them. It’s rarely by force.
            2. Most women let the man go raw because she wants him to like her/he makes her feel a special certain little way, whether it’s just all in her head (usually the case) or it’s actually reality.
            3. Most people in long term relationships go raw.

      • Pivyque

        I think that women feel that way because the man’s life is generally not affected until after the child is born. Ours is affected beforehand. Once my husband convinced me not to have an abortion and I started showing, I lost out on 2 promotions because I was going to be out for 3 months on maternity leave and I wasn’t going to be able to meet the travel demands while pregnant based on my doctor’s orders. I lost a lot of money before the kid was even here. My husband? Not so much. He actually got promoted once his boss found out that he was having a kid! So, I think that the people involved should only have to agree on what to do once they decide to keep the baby. If the woman is 100% sure she wants an abortion, she should have one. If the man is 100% sure he wants her to have an abortion, she should do it..or heavily consider it and decide whether or not she is ready to be a single parent. As far as calling it murder? That’s a debate for another article lol To each its own.

    • http://www.facebook.com/nikia.dshiznit Nikia D-Shiznit

      If women birth on their own, they should provide on their own? Or if men don’t want to be “inconvenienced” they should strap up.

      • Nope

        Most pregnancies are not the result of rape, nor does the average man refuse sex because he’s told to strap up. It’s a two way street.

        • Pivyque

          You are right. Birth control should be the responsibility of everyone involved….

    • yeah…and?

      I have to agree with this. I’m a woman but this victimhood that women have with regards to their own bodies is unreal. Yeah he shouldve wore a condom…but did you require that? Chances are you did not. And what’s really good with your own contraception? All birth control makes you sick? You didn’t have $40-$50 for the morning after pill? True while everyone should be responsible at the end of the day they need to be responsible for themselves. This double standard of men not having a voice past conception but need to be ready to pay if the woman decides to keep it is not only unfair but no one is going take women seriously playing this bs double standard. If you made the decision alone then you need to expect to grind. It’s 2012 who gets pregnant on accident now outside of rape?

  • http://www.facebook.com/nikia.dshiznit Nikia D-Shiznit

    “Think about if the tables were turned: What if the choice was completely up to men? How would you feel if you were left out of a decision about what happens to your child or your body?”

    With the way things are going, that just might happen. 9/10, if you hook up with the bartender, they might not care anyways. The decision should be made SOLEY by the person who might end up taking care of this responsibility alone: woman. We are the ones who carry the burden, both pre, neo, and post natal. Our bodies, out decisions. We are not MORALLY obligated or otherwise to consult with anyone but the doctor

    • yeah…and?

      But I bet if you decided to keep the baby without discussing it with the would-be father you would exercise no hesitation in running to the white man filing for child support. Not to diminish the value of children but thats like being made to pay for an entree that you didn’t order. I think a mature person would have that conversation with their partner unless it really isnt a partner at all but just a “friend with benefits”. So contrary to the selfishly held belief that the decision is solely up to the mother I think that is a sadly held misconception that women have and why men feel like they don’t have to do anything because they aren’t valued in the process. While ultimately the choice is ours, where’s the harm in having the conversation with the person that you (assumedly)are in a relationship with?

      • chanela

        RIGHT! 100% true!

        funny how when women want a baby and a man doesn’t then the man HAS to pay child support…yet when w woman wants an abortion and the man doesn’t then suddenly it’s “mu body my decision” pick one! if you decide to keep a child by a man who deosn’t want it then take care of the munchkin yourself! SMH

        • guest

          understand what you’re saying even though i do agree that it’s “my body, my choice,” but you cant make such a generalization that all women seek help from the man. There are some single mothers out there that do support the children on their own.