50/50: Is Hip-Hop Bad for Black America?

July 2nd, 2010 - By TheEditor

by China Okasi

Is Hip Hop Holding Back African-Americans? That’s what we asked Thomas Chatterton Williams, author of “Losing My Cool: How a Father’s Love and 15,000 Books Beat Hip-Hop Culture” and Dr. Lester Spence, associate professor of political science at John Hopkins University and author of the forthcoming book “Stare in the Darkness: Rap, Hip-hop, and Black Politics.” It’s a vague question, we know, but one that Williams recently evoked with the publication of his book. It is certainly a question that will continue to echo through discussions on African-American political and social topics for quite some time.

Part I

Part II

Part III

Part IV

Madame Noire Video

  • Antonio L Merrick

    The next black leader would have to be from the streets and worked his or her way up the latter and came back to the streets to help everyone else out. Also, it would not hurt if that person is a Hip Hop artist. http://www.2012mediagroup.com

  • Robbin

    I so agree with you Dott. Hip hop has brought a lot of violence to our Communities. It's not about unity. It's about "wilding".

    So many kids have been killed. It's just heartbreaking.

  • Dott

    This brand of hip today is so harmful to black america. I am from the old school rap and there was a time when there were different forms of rap but all were positive. Rap was about having a good time in the park. Battling each other on the mic to show your skills. Mothers didn't worry about their kids at the park. Public Enemy, The Ex Clan, The Furious Five all sent messages of black power, respecting each other and lessons to be learned form the streets. Women were praised for being "Around the way girls". There were rap songs about love. Great stories of all kind were introduced. There were concerts and gatherings of pure fun. You weren't embarrassed when your parents heard what you were listening to. Black people were proud and uniting. They were wearing their medallions and african neclaces. Were the "entertainment powers that be" sitting in the wings saying wait a minute these people are uniting, we can't have this… Then gangster rap reared it's ugly head, it took all of that away and was the beginning of the end of what rap/hip hop was truly about. Now instead of unity we have violence, no respect for each other and murder. We speak ill of ourselves and for the mighty dollar we sell our souls, make excuses for calling each other dispicable names and lead our younger black race to the road to nowhere. Everything Martin Luther King and Malcolm X fought for is a distant memory. It is truly sad.

  • http://www.essenceofsilk.com Yvonne

    Hip hop has done good things & bad things for the black community. It could try to do a little bit more good though but we will always have love for it :>

    Stay beautiful… "EssenceofSilk.com" 100% washable silk & satin pillowcases, hair wraps & more.

  • wahoowauvasnitches

    At any point is Thomas Chatterton Williams acknowledging who actually owns and controls hip hop? And how these issues of snitching and other things are not brand new to black culture? Is he an anthropologist, or someone trying to make a quick buck off of making black culture negative while not criticizing the mainstream.

    The moderator should have debated him.

  • Intellione

    Music in all forms can be very powerful; however, when there are factors such as poverty and loss of faith in one's environment, then lyrics can chime as an anthem to life whether good or bad. Its important to get involved in your childs life and listen WITH them sometimes and ask how they feel about hiphop and its influence then u can help them understand whats REAL vs ENTERTAINMENT.

  • Intellione

    hip hop has weighed heavily on black america but by no means has it been a main factor in the violence that All of America presents. It has been a Diamond to some but Diamonds have sharp edges and can cut you from all angles so its a double edged sword. It all boils down to HOME teaching and EDucation…Don't let entertainment Raise your children and no form of music will influence them to do stray from what u have taught them from birth.

  • Pingback: 50/50: Is Hip-Hop Bad for Black America? — theFreshXpress.com — The PULSE of Young Black America

  • thelight

    thats like saying dont blame crack for me being a crackhead. its a proven fact that music has an enormous affect on ones mental psyche. Lil Wayne says shorty want a thug and every young man thinks he has to be a thug to get a girl and every young girl wants a thug or he aint a real man. And yes some rock is bad for white people too. Thats why drugs are rampant in their race as well. Not all rap is bad. There are a few artists that have great messages, they just rarely get heard.

  • Wow This Is Sad………….Is Rock And Roll Bad For White America? No It's Music Stop Looking For Something To Blame All The Time Black people Don't Wanna See Each other With nothing And That's Sad It's Young Black men That Could Be On The Corner But Now There Jay-z,50 cents,Kanye Wests,And Lil Waynes Why Try And Ruin It For Them

  • MADDOX

    IT'S BAD WHEN IT CONSIST OF VIOLENCE, CRIME, MURDER, AND DRUGS. ITS GOOD WHEN YOU HAVE YOUNG BLACK BUSINESSMEN WHO ARE MAKING SOMETHING OF THEMSELVES IN CORPORATE AMERICA AS BUSINESSMEN. THEY COULD STILL BE ON THE CORNER SELLING DOPE.

  • satch

    ok how come if a big name rapper wear a item or gives props to a car a brand of drink etc. young black males go out and buy it.during the superfly days the everyday bros did not wear pimp clothes to work,they wore them but only at social events.but you see young black males trying to look like rappers 24/7.they told us about carjacking in L.A. then every thug across the us statred jacking folks.too many young black men really think it is a lifestyle

  • http://minusthebars.blogspot.com Don

    The question that should have been asked: Is Hip Hop any more good/bad than all things in this capitalistic society? The problems which exist in Black America were present long before the first rap song, and will be prominent long after the music has ended.

    Either that, or why has Hip Hop become the scapegoat?