He Said, She Said: Stars Accused Of Lying About Sexual Trysts

November 12, 2015  |  
1 of 13

When one celebrity says it happened, and the other denies it, who do you believe? From Matt Barnes and Rihanna to Andy Cohen and Lance Bass, these are all of the celebrities who spilled too much tea about their sex lives and had people wondering which party was lying.

Tyga and Mia Isabella

Do you think Tyga and Mia Isabella actually slept together? Because there was a lot of back and forth in this story.

First, text messages between Mia and Tyga leaked online. Then Mia Isabella responded to the rumors, but wouldn’t say whether or not they were true.

Then Tyga’s lawyer piped up to say that the tweets were real, but he and Mia didn’t sleep together.

Confused yet? Now Mia Isabella has responded again. And while she still won’t say “yes” or “no” for sure, she really sounds mad at Tyga for not telling the truth from jump about their relationship.

Who do you believe?

Andy Cohen and Lance Bass

Why would Andy Cohen lie about sleeping with Lance Bass? We can’t figure it out either.

But after Andy Cohen confessed that Lance Bass was the most famous person he’d ever slept with on an episode of Watch What Happens Live, Bass quickly responded to deny that it ever happened.

Well, almost. While Bass denied that they had sex, he did admit that they made it to third base.

Floyd Mayweather and Tiny Harris

When Floyd Mayweather and rapper T.I. suddenly came to blows last year, we all wondered “What’s wrong with this two?”

Then Floyd Mayweather was caught on tape saying it was because he had sex with Tiny (in very NSFW language).

But after weeks of rumors, speculation and Instagram posts that insinuated a lot but didn’t say much, something or someone made Mayweather change his tune. He eventually said, “I’ve never been with Tiny sexually. I respect her situation and I think she’s a good person. I would never disrespect a marriage.”

Tori Spelling and Jason Priestley

This may be the only disputed case of celebrity he said, she said with a polygraph test involved.

On an episode of Lifetime’s new show Celebrity Lie Detector, Tori Spelling said that she slept with two of her famous costars: Brian Austin Green and Jason Priestley.

But despite Spelling’s Lie Detector-backed claims, Priestley still sounds like he’s trying to deny it.

Matt Barnes and Rihanna

TMZ caught Matt Barnes on camera claiming that he and Rihanna were in the “crush stage” of dating. But soon after the footage aired, Rihanna denied Barnes’s claim with a series of hilarious hashtags.

But that didn’t quiet Barnes, who got on camera with TMZ again to say “I’m too grown to lie” about courting Rihanna.

Talk about things that make you go hmmm…

Gucci Mane and Nicki Minaj

Twitter he said, she said can be the shadiest he said, she said of them all. Gucci Mane started this one by saying that he had relations with Nicki Minaj back when she was still a struggling yet-to-be star.

But Minaj was quick to deny it and tweeted back, “May God strike me dead if I ever had sex wit that man #ugliness. He’s sick and in dire need of rehab. #Love”

Not only did Gucci Mane not go to rehab like Nicki Minaj suggested, but he also spilled even more alleged tea on their “relationship” back in the day. Do you believe the deets?

James Franco and Lindsay Lohan

Actress Lindsay Lohan put James Franco on the list of the 36 celebrities she claimed to have slept with. But Franco told Howard Stern that it never happened.

But it’s not like he and Lyndsay weren’t close. Franco claimed that Lohan tried to sleep with him at one time, but he turned her down.


50 Cent and Mya

Have you seen this video clip? Singer Mya still sounds very sure that she didn’t sleep with 50 Cent, ever in life, despite the rapper claiming they had a sexual encounter.

And it sounds like she’ll stay mad at 50 until he takes back his claims because, as she snappily put it, “people don’t lie on their d–cks.”

Who do you believe?

O. J. Simpson and Kris Jenner

Sometimes celebrity sex rumors take a long time to clear up. But after years of speculation (and rumors that he is Khloe Kardashian’s dad), O.J. Simpson set the record straight in the newest book about him, Guarding the Juice.

In it, O.J. told his cellmate, Jeffrey Felix that the rumors about him messing around with Kris Jenner are without a doubt untrue:

“I would never do that to my friend Bob [Kardashian, who was Simpson’s lawyer]. I would never tap Kris.”

Kordell Stewart and Andrew Caldwell

When there are so many rumors floating around, it’s hard to know what to believe.

So when Andrew Caldwell claimed that he slept with Kordell Stewart — and gave details of how he met Stewart, had an affair, and “had everything that Porsha got” — the news made headlines.

But then Stewart vehemently denied ever meeting Caldwell and filed a lawsuit. Caldwell not only denied that they slept together, but he also confessed that he’d never even met the man or seen him in person.

That’s quite a lot of backpedaling.

View this post on Instagram

Fall back shit

A post shared by Yusaf Mack (@mackyusaf) on

Yusaf Mack and His Adult Film Co-Stars

First Yusaf Mack said that he was drugged and never intentionally engaged in sex with men on camera. But when the production company behind his film threatened to sue him for lying about the whole thing, Mack not only took back his accusations, but he also confessed that he was gay (after trying to say he was only bisexual). He even had a coming-out party!

Brandi Glanville and Gerard Butler

What’s more awkward than being denied publicly? What happened to Brandi Glanville after she said she had sex with Gerard Butler.

When Brandi Glanville revealed that she slept with Gerard Butler on Watch What Happens Live, Butler denied it at first — because he didn’t remember who she was:

“I said: ‘Who’s Brandi Glanville?’ Because one, I didn’t know her last name and two, I didn’t know she was a celebrity and I didn’t know she was going to f–king tell people about it!”


Trending on MadameNoire

Comment Disclaimer: Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN