When the Spice Girls first dropped their debut album, Geri “Ginger Spice” Halliwell claimed she was 21. But her fans weren’t exactly buying it and she was dubbed Old Spice. Halliwell continued to keep up the charade and even celebrated her 29th birthday several years in a row. That is until fellow bandmate Victoria Beckham outted her. It turns out she was four years older than she actually had people believing.