15 Celebrities Who Kept Their Baby Daddies A Secret

October 21, 2014  |  
1 of 15

These stars have been hiding a major secret: the identity of their baby daddies. You might think you know the reasons why, but you might be surprised.

(function(d, s, id) {
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
var js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
js.src = ‘//cdn4.wibbitz.com/static.js’;
}(document, ‘script’, ‘wibbitz-static-embed’));
January Jones is almost as famous for keeping her baby daddy a secret as she is for starring in Mad Men. Since January got pregnant with Xander in 2011, she’s kept her lips tightly sealed about the identity of his father. Why? Because she doesn’t want him involved. January told The Edit:

“I don’t have room for anything else, so I don’t know how I would have done it with a partner…. I knew I would be raising my son alone. It was something I went in to knowingly, I was prepared mentally – and I was excited about it.”

January still hasn’t spilled the beans and now we’re starting to wonder if little Xander’s father even knows who his father is.

Lil Kim

When Lil Kim first revealed her pregnancy, she kept her child’s father a secret too. Everyone’s fingers immediately pointed to her “BFF” Floyd Mayweather. But before rumors could get too out of hand, rapper “Mr. Papers” fessed up on his Instagram account with the caption “I heard everybody looking for me?”.

Mia Farrow

The star of Rosemary’s Baby stirred up some old school drama when she revealed that Woody Allen might not be her son Ronan Allen’s father. Turns out that even though Mia married Woody, she and her lover Frank Sinatra “never really broke up.”

Mia never publicly confirmed that Ol’ Blue Eyes is Ronan’s father, but it’s hard to ignore his big, blue peepers…

Karlie Redd

When rapper Karlie Redd premiered on Love & Hip Hop: Atlanta, there were a lot of questions about her mysterious past. And the biggest of all was the identity of her secret baby daddy, rumored to be famous fugitive and drug king pen Nathan ‘Nate’ Hill.

In 2012, Karlie finally confessed that he was the father of her 18-year-old daughter Jazmin and finally gave the rumor mill some rest.

Minnie Driver

When the I Give It A Year star gave birth to her son Henry back in 2008, she insisted on keeping the identity of his father to herself. At the time, everyone assumed it was her Riches co-star Eddie Izzard. But then in 2012, Minnie revealed that it was actually a writer from the show adding “He’s not famous. There’s no big story.”

The Game

Celebrity fathers keep secrets too. Back in June, The Game suddenly started posting pictures of a girl named Madison (second from the left) on his Instagram page, he said that she was his fourth daughter — and things got awkward fast. First his ex-fiancee revealed that The Game wasn’t her father, just her mentor. Then The Game said that he was her dad because her real one wasn’t around.

Then right around Father’s Day, Madison’s real father started Instagramming shots of himself with Madison to let the world know he really was around… and we still don’t know what’s really going on.

Camryn Manheim

The Practice star Camryn Manheim says that if she doesn’t need a man to raise her son Milo, you don’t even need to know who that man is. When model Jeffrey Brezova told Out magazine that he provided the sperm for “a celebrity mom,” a lot of people speculated that Camryn might have been the one. But neither one of them has revealed the truth.


Ghanian musician Mzbel hasn’t revealed the father of her baby Aaron and fans has assumed that she has to keep him a secret because of his high-profile image.

And Mzbel has been stoking the rumor fires herself by posting pictures of Prince Kofi Amoabeng, CEO of Ghana’s UT Bank, and letting fans know that they’re very close

Kourtney Kardashian

Model Michael Girgenti says that Kourtney Kardashian has been keeping Mason’s daddy a secret — and it’s him. Michael says he had a fling with Khloe in ’09 and nine months later, Mason popped out.

But after Michael stirred up trouble in the tabloids, Kourtney’s partner Scott Disick ordered a paternity test that revealed that Mason really was his.

Geri Halliwell

Former Spice Girl Geri Halliwell has never actually revealed who fathered her daughter Bluebell. But rumor has it that it’s screenwriter Sacha Gervasi. The two had a six week fling in 2005 — right around the time that Bluebell was conceived.

Monica Cruz

Penelope Cruz’s sister isn’t telling who her baby daddy is — because she doesn’t know either. The actress “resorted” to artificial insemination when she decided that she was ready for a baby even though there was no romance in sight.

Hilarie Burton

The One Tree Hill star had one of the most secretive pregnancies in Hollywood history. Not only did fans not know who her baby daddy was, they didn’t even know she was pregnant! Hilarie managed to stay out of the spotlight for nine months.

Then in 2009, she announced that she had a secret baby boy and a secret relationship with Grey’s Anatomy star Jeffrey Dean Morgan.

Kyla Pratt

Hilarie Burton isn’t the only star who’s good at keeping secrets. After her One on One days were over, Kyla was famous for hiding her pregnancy. She kept her baby daddy a secret by not letting fans know that she was even dating, much less pregnant.

And Kyla says that after she finally revealed that she had a baby and baby daddy Danny Kilpatrick, the backlash was so bad that she went back to keeping her pregnancies a secret.

Mildred Baena

Mildred Baena let Mr. Baena think he was the father of her son Patrick — while she was working for Arnold Schwarzenegger and his wife Maria Shriver. Mildred publicly revealed that Arnold was the father, after he left office (and his wife Maria).

Bebe Buell

Liv Tyler’s mother tried to keep her baby daddy a secret, telling her daughter that rocker Todd Rundgren was her father. But when Liv noticed that she looked just like Mia Tyler — Steven Tyler’s daughter — she started to suspect that this rocker was her dad. Liv pressed the issue and Bebe finally told her the truth.

Trending on MadameNoire

Comment Disclaimer: Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN