All Articles Tagged "Bloomberg the nanny"

Is Withholding Formula From New Moms The Best Way To Make Them Breastfeed?

August 2nd, 2012 - By Victoria Uwumarogie
Share to Twitter Email This

When it comes to feeding newborn babies, breastfeeding is embraced for the benefits it has towards a child’s health and is seen as the healthiest form of nourishment for babies. In fact, in an article featured on TIME‘s website, it says “The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) advises moms to breast-feed exclusively for about six months, then continue breast-feeding while offering new foods.” On the other hand, giving formula to a child straight out the womb isn’t embraced so much. Though there are sometimes reason for going the bottle route first, including the inability to breastfeed (and that includes if the mother has a certain disease too–HIV, tuberculosis, etc.), it’s tied to diarrhea and a higher risk of infection. But it’s important to note that many efforts have been made to improve the quality of formula over the years. With all the information saying breastfeeding is the best way to go, it’s surprising to hear that so many women are being somewhat pushed to use formula for their newborn by hospitals handing out promotional formula from companies as a form of marketing. As Bonnie Rochman, the author of the piece in TIME put it, hospital staff can be a bit pushy during a time when mothers are vulnerable, and rightfully stressed:

“As for my sister-in-law, Rachel, who recently gave birth in a Manhattan hospital to her first child, she knows firsthand how nurses pushing formula can impact an inexperienced mother. After her C-section, a nurse offered to give her newborn a bottle “to make it easier on you.” Exhausted and uncertain, she agreed — even though she’d intended to breast-feed. ‘I was a new mom,” she said. “I didn’t know what I was doing.’”

For reasons like this, Mayor Michael Bloomberg wants to make free formula not so easy to get to encourage new moms to breastfeed. According to the AP, 27 out of 40 hospitals in NYC have agreed to stop handing out promotional formula under the campaign, “Latch On NYC.” They’ll replace the formula with in-depth conversations on the benefits of breastfeeding, but will provide new moms with formula if that’s what they prefer. That way, new moms in a confusing position won’t immediately jump for breast milk if their child isn’t latching on immediately and it’s offered by a nurse–like an easy alternative. The mayor says that many see this as an important step in the right direction, and reports say that this initiative is taking place all around the country with more than 600 hospitals. “Most public health officials around the country think this is a great idea. The immunities that a mother has built up get passed on to the child, so the child is healthier.”
But while this whole initiative sounds like a good idea, many critics are stepping forward saying that the government shouldn’t get to interfere with the choices a mother makes for herself and her child. As one commentator put it, “What the hell does a mayor have to do with me breast feeding??????  What the hell?  Is this in his job description? Did you hire this man to tell you how to feed your kid?  Wake up people.” Mardi Mountford of the International Formula Council isn’t a fan either. She told the folks at TIME: “A way to help mothers is to be supportive of the feeding choice they make for their infants regardless if they choose breast-feeding, formula feeding or a combination of both. For infants who are not breast-fed, infant formula is the only safe, nutritious and recommended feeding option.”

Seeing as Mayor Bloomberg has been pushing to ban super-size soft drinks in the city, he’s slowly but surely being labeled as being too pushy and even gets called the “nanny” by many New Yorkers. But in his eyes, he’s pushing for people to make better decisions for their health, and as we can see now, for the health of their children. But is this new initiative for breastfeeding and somewhat hiding formula from new moms in the process a good idea to you? Or is it interfering with a mother’s choices? 

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]