Homemaker, Inc: Why Don’t More Black Moms Stay Home?

November 18th, 2011 - By LaShaun Williams

"black woman and child"

For as long as many of us can remember, we have seen the black women in our families work. Some scrubbing the toilets of other families, while others labored long, stressful office hours. Before it was the only way; most women had no choice. Becoming a homemaker-breadwinner hybrid, or superwoman, was the only option.

Thank God for giving us the strength and endurance to be more than we could ever imagine.

While white women used the feminist movement and education to get out of the home, black women have been searching for ways to stay inside. In our community it is a luxury to stay at home, an opportunity few black families can afford—whether it’s for lack of finances or a second parent.

Furthermore, there is also an underlying notion that being a housewife somehow diminishes one’s value, a belief that modern homemakers (particularly suburbanistas) are lazily wasting away their talents and academic achievements. It’s the place where traditional (or white) feminism and black womanhood conflict. But the rise of “mommy bloggers” and mompreneurs, such as Carol’s Daughter founder Lisa Price (who scheduled business hours around her family), are proof that there are benefits to being “kept,” and stay-at-homes moms are indeed utilizing their assets. Oftentimes, in more ways than they once did in the workplace.

Still, the decision to stay home is an internal struggle, as our hearts and minds pull us in different directions. Naturally, we want to be there for our children; we want to be present for every first and “complain” about the perils of carpooling. But, in the back of our minds, we also feel as if we will lose our independence in doing so.

I’ve been a stay-at-home mother for nearly three years and, in the beginning, my journey was one of isolation and confusion. Although most would attribute that to the percentage of unmarried black women, that was not the case at all, having the benefit of growing up with a stay-at-home mom, for me, this sort of self-sacrifice is normal if not ideal. Nevertheless, I also pride myself in being a smart, ambitious woman. So, when other women would give me that look in conversations or say things like, “But, you’re so smart,” I questioned my decision. In fact, at one point, I started interviewing again—thinking that was the way to be all-woman.  And, during those interviews I realized I could never leave my children to help make someone else rich. It was also during that time I began to understand the window of opportunity I had. My decision to stay at home ultimately gave way for me to pursue my dreams; it was liberating. Now, as an entrepreneur, I have the best of both worlds. My three-year-old is reading and work revolves around my schedule.

So, if you’ve been considering trading in your corner office for a cozy place in the kitchen, remember there is great freedom in being the Mommy-in-Chief, and you may actually find yourself in a place of greater independence.

LaShaun Williams is a Madame Noire contributor and columnist whose work has appeared in the New York Times and across several popular sites, such as HuffPost Black Voices and the Grio.  Follow her on Twitter @itsmelashaun and Facebook.

 

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Pingback: Mythbusters... Black Mom Edition - 3 Myths About Black Mothers

  • Pingback: Merchant Services

  • Amija

    I live in California.  Most of us need both incomes to survive.  I was able to stay at home for 3 years with both children, but I was itching to get out of the house after that.  I think it’s great if you can do it for the beginning of their life.  That 6 week thing is some bs!

  • chanela

    is this article serious!?!?! how do you have one article about 72% of black women being single mothers, and then make another article asking why more black women don’t stay home…. LOL then people complain and make statistics on black women being on government support. i’m confused

  • Getit!

    More black moms will stay home when more black men go to work without making her keep up her end of the bargain. Brothers tend to ask sisters “what they’re bringing to the table.” When he dates Ashley, he supports her, her mom, and a host of extendeds. Remember when Nicole Brown Simpson’s family was all upset with OJ? It had as much to do with them not receiving the money they used to as it did with her murder.

  • Carla681

    You guys are funny!!!!  I have been a stay at home mom for 10 years and believe me it is work.  I am exhausted, when I had a job I was not nearly this tired.  I love my 2 boys more than anything in this world and I truly enjoy the time that I get to spend with them.  I am able to drop them off and pick them up from school and get them to all of their activities without any issue.  I also have a cleaning service that comes twice a month.  Having said all of that, it in my opinion staying at home is in no way fulfilling and I do feel like I am wasting my degree.  To those who have commented that we have to much time on their hands and the like stop watching too much TV.  
     

    • deedee

      Hey all!  Like Carla, I’m also a stay at home Mom, to one elementary age child, for 6 years now.  I’m African American, my husband is too, and we’ve managed to make it work.  My husband has been a business owner for the past 10 years, and we decided after having BOTH lost our jobs within 4 months of each other a decade ago, that we would NOT depend on another job ever again.  We wanted to make sure we directed our own destiny from that point on. 

      Now, don’t get me wrong-it’s not easy-there’s little room for luxuries or extras, but none of that compares to taking our child to school, being there when school’s out, and caring for the home WE built together and having that to share with our child.

      And, no, I’m not a Stepford wife, I’m college educated and had a career in Marketing for 15 years before I became a stay at home Mom & wife.

      Sisters, it’s worth the sacrifice-but you have to be willing to shoulder the sacrifice with a good, Godsent man.

      • Guess

        I think it’s a very smart approach to not depend on a job/ employment.  My husband and I have decided that I will stay at home until the kids are school age. And then I will find a job that will allow me to be home when they arrive home from school.

        Before having kids we lived off of one salary (this gave us practice for now living on only my husband’s police salary). When we both worked we banked my teaching salary (the lower salary of the two). Now we have a nice nest egg.  I frequently recommend other married couples to do the same.  It’s great for purchasing a house, saving for retirement, etc.
        Anyway… 
        I’ve always wanted to be a stay at home mom since growing up with a single mom who didnt have time for the “extras.”
        We know it is a financial sacrifice, but for us it’s the right decision.
         

  • ElvisWasAHero2Most

    Um, unsure if you’re aware… but the economy is in a dire state.  To put down your day job for your family is admirable, but it isn’t practical in modern times.  Unless of course you’re married to a Wall St. exec, shout outs to all the top 1%-ers

    • LaLaLaMeansILoveYou

      lol shout out indeed :) help a sista out! I wanna stay home wit my chilluns too! lol

  • Giselle

    Umm…because maybe a large percentage of black mothers are single and can’t afford to stay at home because they are raising their child alone.  My parents divorced when I was a baby and he stopped coming to get me for visitation after a while and didn’t support my mother for any of my childhood expenses, not even a damn birthday gift or call since eternity  So if my mother stayed home we’d end up out on the streets.  Just because a mother isn’t a stay at home mom doesn’t mean her life doesn’t revolve around her child/children.  My mother was very proactive in my education and after school activities, trips to museums, etc. I got a bedtime story and a kiss every night and I am grateful for the childhood that my mother gave me.  If a woman has the option and feels that’s what works best than that’s good and if she wants to work that’s fine as well.  You just have to have a healthy work life balance.  I’m grateful that my mother did have a good job and didn’t have to work inhumane hours, b/c some of my friends growing up never got to spend as much time with their moms because they were always working night and day to pay the bills. And I also had friends that had moms that stayed at home and they had a horrible relationship or were always fighting, so that does not attest at all to being a good mother. 

  • Hrdblkman

    Because I anti given my hard earned money to no hoodrat/blk woman

  • IllyPhilly

    It’s something you have to be able to afford.

    • ShannaBennet

      I love it when people say “we can’t afford for one of us to stay home.” These are the same people you see driving brand new leased cars for several hundred dollars a month. You go to their home and they have 50″ screen televisions, Playstations and designer sneakers. You have to decide what is more a priority to you—keeping up with the Joneses or caring for you own children. Too many women want to be able to have fancy clothes, trips and luxuries at the expense of their childrens’ happiness. I am a stay at home mom, and believe me, it’s no picinic. We run a cottage industry in our home. My husband works full time and does odd jobs on the side. I work as a freelancer from home, make Halloween costumes and sell them online, bake cakes and create wedding bouquets. It’s FAR less than we would have if I worked, but we are all happy. Kids don’t need “stuff.” They need their parents.

  • cutily

    When I hear about stay at home mom I start to feel pressured and stressed!

    I have worked really hard to be a good student, to choose the career in which I wanted to practice and to have a social recognition because of that. I do want to have kids and be a wonderful mother, but I will keep working and it’s non negotiable. Kids grow fast and start ignoring you rapidly so you have to keep something to fall back on.

    My mom was a single mom, she is a doctor so she was working a lot, but my sisters and I had a great education and a happy life. We love our mom more than anything and do think we were lucky to have this mother who was working and who made us proud and willing to be just like her.

    But to each their own…

    • Sdennis334

      I agree. My mom is a single mom, and an educator at a private school, so she worked a long school year and then summer school. As tired as she was, she always made a way to come see my concerts and award ceremonies, etc.  Although it would have been nice to have her around more often, or go on a vacation, it was ok. She worked hard and raised us to be good people. She is well-educated and I am so happy that I have followed in her footsteps and obtained an advanced degree.

      Ideally, I’d like to be home or at the very least, work part time when my kids are young. But once they’re off to school, there’s no reason I can’t work. I went through so much to finish school and I enjoy what I do. There are plenty of moms who work and are there for their kids.

  • Kelly

    Because white men will not accept that and black men are not working

    • guest

      how do white men play into this? not everything is the white man’s fault.

  • Mecia

    Staying at home with small children is a JOB!  From my experience, my children’s father felt that since I stayed at home and he worked, that I should be more than happy to do his list of things he wanted.  Because my children were toddlers, they were messy.  I was chasing after them with a vacuum and a sponge while keeping them from getting into stuff.  THe house had to be spotless at all times.  Dinner had to be ready by the time he came home.  I was constantly doing laundry.  I never got any sleep.  Plus, I was going to school full-time to finish my Bachelor’s.  As soon as I had the opportunity to begin my career, I jumped on it.  Honestly, it is easier to go to work then be a housewife.  Unless your man is filthy rich and you have nannies and maids, it’s a demanding, yet fulfilling job.  Not every woman’s experience is the same, and the reality TV stars are not a representation of REAL HOUSEWIVES.

    • cutily

      And you think women who work have live-in maid and babysitters to do that?

  • Pagewriter1

    Haven’t you heard that 72% of our black children are being raised in single parent homes-the vast majority are female led homes?  How can we stay home?  Until the economy and many other factures change this topic/article is only for those who are privileged. Not hating just stating facts.

    • Br911af

      Maybe women can stay home if they stop getting pregnant and handle their damn business.

      • reese

        Even so most men of all races aren’t in a position to take care of families alone.  Most women have to work now to help support a family.

    • MsIndependent

      Thank you! Let address the first issue, do black women even have the OPTION to choose whether or not to be housewife compared to white women. You are one of the fortune FEW. Statistically that’s not the case for the black communities. I earn a high income , single and no kids, i have absolutely no problem with being a housewife when i’m married, but i probably will have to work part time to maintain my sanity. Either way can’t  make decision to become a housewife, without have a good husband at home. You make it sound as if you can just be a housewife independently of a good stable  husband in the home.If that’s your position, then this opens a whole new discussion on the detrimental effects of independent sistas with the i-don’t-need-a-man-to-do-anything-for-me mentality, to the black community. This a decision for both partners. You should probably mention the fact that you are married to a good black men who brings home income to cover housing expenses and that’s why you opt to stay at home..and have the time to pursue your entrepreneurial goals. Notice how you conveniently left all that out.  Once again you are fortunate to have the CHOICE to stay at home or not.  You should have started this article with the following- In  a hypothetical situation where we have enough good black men for the good black women,a home of  where both partners are highly educated and earn high incomes, successfully married and have children… will the wife be willing to become a house wife?

  • http://decadentindustries.net/ xDecadent

    I disagree with the commenters above me. I dont have kids yet but when I do I plan to stay at home until the kids are school age. I have 2 businesses and hopefully I wont have to return anywhere full time unless I really want to. Historically, black women have not been stay at home moms because they couldn’t afford to. My mom worked, her mom worked and her moms mom worked. However, my grandmother and her bestfriend made a pact that one of them would work and one of them would stay home with the kids. Honestly, I would not feel comfortable returning to work full time and leaving my baby with a stranger. I’d rather be home with them myself and work from home.
     
    Just because you’re home does not mean you’re some lazy bum. Work still needs to get done whether you work outside the home or not. My mom worked 2 jobs – one outside the home and when she came in she started her 2nd shift of helping with homework, cooking, cleaning and doing god knows what else it took to keep the house from falling apart.

  • Prissy

    For what?? My mother and all the women in my family and the MEN have always worked and had time to take us kids to our respective activities, school, pay the bills, cook and had time to chill with us and their partners AND time to do their own thing (knit, book clubs etc etc). There is NOTHING fulfilling about sitting at home looking at the paint dry. It can be done. 

  • adobedoo

    staying at home isn’t  job and neither fufilling
    what it does is gives women more time on thier hands to cause trouble i.e desperate housewive, real housewifes of atalanta, basketball wives etc.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Christina-Nicole/1545790639 Christina Nicole

      I somewhat agree, but don’t forget that many women have just as much drama in the workplace as at home. Also, many of those housewives on the shows have careers on the side. One or two owned boutiques, started clothing lines and were CEO’s of their own companies.

    • AKAPAM

      YOU WATCH TO MUCH TV. GET A LIFE. MOST WOMENS LIVES ARE NOT HARDLY LIKE THAT.