Our Marriage Meltdown & The Media’s New Attack on Black Women

September 29th, 2011 - By Alexis Garrett Stodghill

Is Marriage For White People?
Fox News. The Los Angeles Times. The New York Times. The Wall Street Journal. These are just a few of the publications that have jumped on the media bandwagon, singing all praises to the controversial new book: “Is Marriage for White People? How the African American Marriage Decline Affects Everyone.” Penned by an African-American professor of law at Stanford University, Ralph Richard Banks uses his book to recommend succinctly that successful black women look outside the black race to marry. He suggests that this is a far better road to take than “marrying down,” or remaining alone. Citing many personal observations and analyzes of relationship data, Banks makes the case that there is no reason for highly successful black women to remain dedicated to the black man. In fact, he argues that many of the social ills in African-American society can be ameliorated by high-earning black women “marrying out,” thereby creating more stable two-parent homes for black children.

Banks counters the arguments made by many black women who are highly educated but may prefer marrying a blue collar black fellow or remaining alone. Forget what they actually want — the law professor-turnt-love doctor wants these women to realize that most successful black men have no problem “dating out.” Negative historical associations with white men and positive political intentions towards black men mean nothing. We’ve got to face the stark reality that there are 50% fewer eligible black men on the market than African-American women seeking mates. Deal with it — but don’t go it alone.

After all, what is the point of the most accomplished women in our community forgoing the chance to reproduce and pass on their cultured social abilities to another generation? Why allow their wealth to be drained in an economically mismatched marriage? How is the black community being helped in the long run by 42% of black women remaining forever single? Why not run from all these problems and marry a man from another race?

I get it. I totally understand where Professor Banks is coming from. As a black woman who is college educated, and no spring chicken, the fear of remaining single forever is there. So is the fear of white men, and the concern that no matter how intelligent and accomplished you are, you will only be seen as an experimental fling. I have felt the deep concern for the brothers being left behind, even as I have been secretly terrified that the more unconscionable among them might take me down with them. But more than anything, I am concerned with the media circus surrounding the black woman and her love life yet again — and sickened that it is a black man who is the main ring leader doing the profiting.

Here’s why.

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Pingback: msn emoticons

  • http://www.crjpublishing.com Cicely

    What I want to know is how someone managed to steal my picture for this article and never mentioned me nor my book. I believe its called copyright infringement. I have written a similar book with a similar topic: black men v. White Men; the Black Woman's Choice, and while my picture was used to promote this book I was never called, emailed, texted, facebooked, twittered, or IM'd for my opinion nor my permission to use my pictures that I paid models to pose for. This is disheartening as I spent nearly 3 years researching and completing my work for my pictures to be passed off as someone elses work. My people, my people!!!

    Cicely J
    CRJ Publishing, LLC
    cicely@crjpublishing.com
    Author of: black me v. White Men; the Black Woman's Choice

  • http://twitter.com/Blk_M_S_Mom @Blk_M_S_Mom

    I personally encourage interracial dating, however, I find that I remain attracted to men of my ethnicity. My heritage is very important to me and whoever I date would have to share a similar cultural background or share a deep knowledge and appreciation for mine.

  • Shaka

    I am a black woman who is not red-boned, I am dark skinned and I get hollered at by white, spanish, and arab. So all of this "static" is to play with the psyche of black women. Black men will probably never show how they admire black women, but they will admire white women publicly! It is psychological, eveything, even this article! So my sistas, we are beautiful, we have the bodies and we must keep it up. Do not allow black, white, or any male talk you out of your confidence. One thing, black men are scared and they must learn to open up and be romantic! JayZ is 40 yrs. old and is still rapping! Who wants that!

  • asantewaaspeaks

    The book "Is Marriage For White People" specifically states that black women are not responsible for the sitaution that has caused them to be among the most unpartnered women on the planet. I certainly do not think that his book blames black women.

  • http://twitter.com/MyVintageSoul @MyVintageSoul

    Wow…with all due respect, as the daughter of a Black mother and White father, myself, people of mixed black and white ancestry spending time around other African-Americans is not going to make them think they are "special" because of their looks. Very often, it is quite the opposite–they get the chance to experience the diversity of Black America. I've been around Black family and friends of the family since birth and I have NEVER developed any superiority complex. I am just one shade out of many in the Black community and that goes for all other mixed-race people. Physical diversity has always been a part of the Black experience…there've been light-skinned blacks since the 1600's. I'm sorry, but I simply don't understand your point of view. ??

  • http://twitter.com/MyVintageSoul @MyVintageSoul

    This was a very well-written, valid article and point of view. When it comes to the marriage issue, there is always room for marriages amongst African-Americans and interracial marriages. I disagree that African-American women should feel compelled to make a CONSCIOUS effort to look specifically outside of their community for love. My own mother is Black and father was Italian-American, but it was a union based on LOVE and trust and nothing else–interracial relationships and marriages shouldn't be FORCED as I get the feeling some in society would like to insist upon. That attitude only causes resentment and rightfully so. The bottom line is that no matter who Black women marry–Black, White, or ESKIMO, the relationship should be based on her love for him and his love for her….and nothing else. I feel the tone and perspective of the book in question is something I would heartily disagree with.

  • Jane

    Amen.
    As a single educated black woman, I get frowns for dating a white male. The thing is he is not my "second" choice and some are angry that I am not looking for this black prince , or that I didn't wait for said prince . Why would I?. My white darling is MY choice. I did not set out looking for a black man, I was looking for the man that would love me as I love him .
    I do think it boils down to choices. Dating outside one's race is a great thing,it's a great choice. You learn, you grow ( get sick on Thai food) but it's Ok.
    The black man does not need to be made into a prize to be won. A partnership is the prize . The focus should not be on race, but how we can all make our relationships work.

  • Gwen

    See how brothers support each other in these relationships? Why dont sisters?
    http://hellobeautiful.com/gossip-news/hellobeauti

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]