U.S. Soldier Jailed in South Korea for Alleged Theft

July 16, 2011 ‐ By nativenotes


A Pennsylvania family is seeking answers for why their son is being held in a prison in South Korea for an alleged theft. Sandy and Bob Fisher are the parents of Private First Class Andre Fisher, an African American soldier stationed in Camp Casey, South Korea who was arrested in February for allegedly stealing $88 from a taxi driver. Fisher maintains is innocence and states that the only evidence against him is a grainy surveillance video that showed a hooded man; no face can be seen from the video. Despite his non-guilty plea, Private Fisher was convicted by the courts in South Korea and is now serving a two-year prison sentence.

The family is outraged and is demanding some form of communication from the U.S. government and or military officials. Their attempts at reaching officials at Camp Casey have been unsuccessful.

If South Korean jails are anything like the movie Midnight Express then we need to get Andre Fisher out of there as soon as possible. Many of the blog/forum boards that I’ve read regarding this story are focused on race and how this is another example of America turning its back on young black men. Interestingly enough, Fisher’s family and friends who are advocating his release are white. But it does beg the question – would this story be more newsworthy if Fisher was the Hollywood prototype – a blonde haired, blue eyed patriot?

As concerned citizens we have a right to know why one of our soldiers is sitting in a foreign prison for two years for allegedly stealing $88. We also have the right to know if Fisher was afforded proper representation. Bob Fisher, states “My son told me the commander saw the video and told him you’re guilty– and handed him over to the South Koreans.”.

What’s also interesting is that South Korea has a record of being extremely lenient with their citizens offering up laughable sentences for more serious crimes. Korean men have received sentences as light at 10 months for rape yet Andre fisher was sentenced to 2 years for theft. Something isn’t right here.

I share in the outrage of the parents who are upset because their government and military officials are offering no information about the condition of their son and circumstances surrounding his conviction. The Fishers have started a public campaign, utilizing facebook, news outlets and reaching out to government officials in order to put pressure on the U.S. government and military officials to reveal more information about their imprisoned son’s case. While I don’t expect Bill Clinton to head over to South Korea and have the South Korean government pardon Private Fisher (he’s not a famous journalist or anything), I do think at bare minimum the family has a right to know what happened to their son.

What do you think about this case?

Follow nativenotes on Facebook/Twitter/Tumblr or check out some his writings over at Notes of This Native Son

MadameNoire Video

Comment Disclaimer: Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN
  • John in CA

    Turns out Andre scuffled with cops who were arresting him and rampaged once put into the cop car, causing property damage of about $500. Guilty or not, that's not a good way to interact with local cops.

    Check out rokdrop.com, a popular blog about USFK, re Andre Fisher.

    And we should all refrain from making statements assuming that somehow SK is some backward nation without rule of law etc. It's not true. First that doesn't help Andre's case. Second, it's backward way of thinking

    Lastly foreigners sentenced to jails in S Korea are housed in a rather decent prison. USFK inmates get food ingredients from USFK and cook on their own.

    From 2005 http://www.stripes.com/news/for-u-s-inmates-in-s-

    From 2010 http://www.correctionalnews.com/articles/2010/05/

  • nathan

    This article is extremely misleading. First, ANY soldier who commits a crime while in Korea is tried in the Korean justice system. There is no ambiguity to this rule. It doesn't matter if it's a DUI or a homicide, if it happens outside of official duties, the Korean courts handle it.

    Second, according to the Economist, South Korea is a full democracy that protects the civil liberties of everyone. On the Democracy Index Scale, the United States is 17 and South Korea is 20 – not much of a difference on a list of 167 countries. The insinuation that Korean prisons in 2011 are akin to Turkish prisons from a movie in the 1970s is insulting and racist.

    Third, Korea does NOT have a record of being extremely lenient with punishing it's own citizens – the world media has a record of publicizing the rare cases where that happens and that's all the world sees. If you actually lived in Korea and followed the news, you'd know that Korean justice can be and frequently is quite severe. Also, when a lenient sentence IS handed down, the entire country reacts with outrage and demands changes to the law that allowed such a heinous criminal to get off so lightly.

    Finally, the US military is NOT ALLOWED to release any information on this case UNLESS THE ACCUSED ALLOWS IT TO BE RELEASED. The military isn't telling the family anything because the accused isn't allowing it to.

    So in the end, we have a democratic justice system that arrested a foreign national for committing a crime in its jurisdiction. The track record of the system here tells me that he most likely was afforded legal representation and had a fair trial. He's in jail and won't let the evidence be released and now his friends and family are claiming a conspiracy and a miscarriage of justice when the truth is, he's probably guilty.

    • John in CA

      USFK hires local lawyer for criminal cases involving USFK personnel.

  • Nikki2k
  • Nikki2k

    I currently live in South Korea as an English teacher and we are working on a petition getting posted right now. I'm so glad Madame Noire picked this story up I sent out emails to various outlets!!

  • chanela

    Oh come on! dont act like they dont have slap on the wrist sentences in america too. why is it possible for us to go on the megan’s law website to search of child molesters in the neighborhood? why the hell arent they under a jail?? So so sad what happened to this man. i hate to make things about race but i agree with the other posters. if he was any other race then he would have been set free. asian countries are notorious for being extremely unfair and evil to black people who visit those countries. its so depressing how no matter what country black folks visit…nobody likes us :(

  • armymomx2

    I have two son's currently stationed in S. Korea, one is in Camp Humphrey's the other is at Camp Casey. This disturbs me greatly; my son's have not mentioned this and am not sure how much they will be able to discuss. I'm scheduled to visit in October for three weeks; how can I get a hold of the family before I leave? No, I'm not Bill Clinton but I may be able to hear/see/tell/share something.

  • Deeana

    I fully believe if he was white this would be a whole different story. Having footage of a hooded man robbing someone, but you can't even see his face, is not proof of anything except maybe banning hooded people from riding cabs in Korea.
    Something should be done.