What's At the Root of White Oppression?

May 31, 2011  |  

Not too long ago, I wrote a column hoping to dissect and dispel the myths circulating in the media about this new trend of white male oppression. However, I’ve been thinking about the topic more lately, thanks in part to continuous news stories about this alleged pessimistic and alienated group. I felt that an amendment of sorts would be needed to fully explain the peculiar nature of this white discontentment.

First and foremost, it’s the economy. Simply put, we wouldn’t be having this conversation if it wasn’t for the stagnated economy, which has left many people, particularly white folks, wondering what happened to the American dream. Historically speaking, when times are bad, folks tend to resort to ethnocentrism as a scapegoat to explain why domestic jobs decrease while defense and foreign aid increase. This sort of cultural clinging is what gave rise to the Tea Party, which, prior to the economic collapse, had as much political appeal as the Lyndon LaRouche movement.

Recently, the Atlantic ran an article about how working class whites are the most pessimistic group in America. The aricle cites a Pew Charitable Trusts’ Economic Mobility Project survey, which suggest that 43 percent of blue-collar whites don’t expect to be better off economically in 10 years. Furthermore, these blue-collar whites see opportunities for people like them shrinking in favor of the “others” in society—although whites without a four-year college degree still remain the largest demographic in the workforce.

Politicians and other political mongers have used this scare tactic since the 60s to exploit fear of affirmative action, welfare, illegal immigration and other irrational suspicions in order to win over rural white votes. By using these tactics, the rich and powerful—many of whom are white males—trick their poor and working-class white counterparts into believing that their interests were mutually aligned. It’s how poor whites, particularly in the antebellum South, were able to accept, if not fight for, the institution of slavery, even though slavery was the reason why they lived in destitute poverty and in some cases, were indentured themselves.

Unbeknownst to poor white folks who continue to fall hard for the rhetoric of the anonymous black and brown bogeyman, and search for answers politically by voting for folks who screw them over legislatively, the ivory tower may be laying the groundwork to usher in a new way of thinking, which will ultimately use poor white folks as a scapegoat for society’s ills.

In a recent lecture titled “The State of White America,” libertarian scholar Charles Murray, co-author of “The Bell Curve,” highlighted what he calls a series of self-destructive behaviors occurring in working-class white communities, such as high out-of-wedlock birth rates, and a decline in marriage and poor work ethics. His conclusion was simple and straightforward—that conditions in working-class white communities are the result of “a different attitude towards work, a fundamental change in the norm…” Now where have I heard this lazy, shiftless line before?

White working-class folks need to be better informed about who or what they place the blame on for their shrinking opportunities in society. Despite all the hyperbole, it ain’t the blacks, browns, or any other minorities that are keeping you down, but rather the more affluent, blue-eyed white folks at the top, who are really your oppressors.

Charing Ball is the author of the blog People, Places & Things.

Trending on MadameNoire

View Comments
Comment Disclaimer: Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN
  • "Whitey"

    Its kind of ironic how you say that white people are blaming minorities for job displacement etc and they have no right but the entire black equality movement is found upon claims of another ethnic groups oppression. I think that both sides should just man up and do right, quit living into stereotypes. There is white male oppression just like there is black male oppression. Maybe since youre not a white male you cant see it, just like white males cannot understand the entirety of black male oppression. We are subject to racism nowadays, maybe not back when the civil rights movement started but there is still a lot of anger towards whites and its silly to think that disappeared. Those attitudes of hate have been passed down through generations but now there is more power on the opposing side. Cry racism and see how much attention you get as a black and me as a white…by the way this whole racism thing is pretty dumb to begin with and seeded by lack of education. Cant we just get along?

  • Karen

    not only is it the economy. white women are pushing marrying black men all in the media. On just about every show on primetime and realitytv there isa black man/white woman couple. In just about every commercial there is a black man/white woman couple. Dont just blame it on the economy. Blame it on your women. They have uplifted the black man’s status and knocked your status down.

  • EMC2

    I shouldn’t even comment, but, do you really think that white blue collar workers are in the “4 year college demographic” you cite?

    I love how you start your racist diatribe, with the prefix, “Historially Speaking”, ethnocentrism……. and then attribute some real or otherwise imagined behavior to “folks”…..

    What a poorly written piece. The only thing worse than your writing, is your research, and your lack of substaniating facts. The facts that would support your opinions, weren’t inclued because they don’t exist.

    Oh, and for the record, reverse discrimination is very real, and “black folks” can be racists too. You’ve proved that point, by writing about “your blue eyed bogey man” LOL

  • natasha

    Good article …. very informative. Id just forward it to my white coworker who wants to blame everything on spanish people

  • Nellie

    Instead of White Oppression I want our people to consider our potential, we need to stop looking at Whites as the end all cure all or cause of all our ills. We come from strong stock, that survived the trips from Africa, two-hundred years of slavery, Jim Crow institutional segregration. And We Are Still Here. Our strength and faith can carry us further than any oppression.

  • Dina

    Yeah.. The author of this column Is quite passionate when it comes down to “the man”.
    I appreciate her passion but I believe that she would be much more effective directing her energy towards more meaningful subjects as she is obviously well educated. Good day!

  • Kendall

    yea i know, it's white people being white!

  • clarissa

    Money and bullying. It’s simple no need to write a thesis ..ok!