Why Your Long-Term Cohabitation is Not the Same as Marriage

March 3rd, 2011 - By LaShaun Williams

Studies show that individuals who make the effort to maintain quality, long-term relationships enjoy greater levels of overall happiness. Proving, the grass is greener where you water it.

However, according to Cristen Conger’s Huffington Post article, married couples tend to report being happier than singles. Since married individuals also drink and smoke less, statistics show they are healthier and live longer than unmarried people. Very interesting data considering we live in a divorce-happy society.

An escalating divorce rate has deterred many from marriage with a growing number of long-term cohabitants, who feel their relationships are just as substantial as legally-binding unions. But research from Nancy Wartik’s article “The Perils of Playing House” published in Psychology Today suggests these “trial periods” double the likelihood of divorce in a subsequent marriage. Researchers suggest people with more positive views on relationships simply go ahead and tie the knot before moving in together and discover greater happiness. Those with more risk factors (i.e. baggage) are more hesitant to take the plunge and often find themselves less satisfied after marriage.

Marriage is more than a piece of paper. Emotionally, it’s a sigh of relief. Marriage means you can’t just wash your hands after a big fight. It means you are completely vulnerable. It means you have given up the “I’s” for “we.” Unmarried couples are two “I’s” standing side by side, unwilling to sacrifice the freedoms of single life. If one person is suddenly unfulfilled and wants to leave, they can. In a marriage you can’t just go whenever things get rough. It is a character-building journey that forces husbands and wives to mature. There is a much higher level of commitment. Plus, break-ups don’t come with alimony, insurance policies and child support.

Among stability, openness and potential monetary compensation, married couples also experience a higher level of sexual freedom in their ability to reproduce. Unplanned pregnancies within marriage are much different than those outside. Often viewed more as surprises than life sentences, the abortion rate amongst married women is drastically lower than that of legally single women. According to 2005 statistics, single, never married women account for two-thirds of abortions in America. African-American women lead the way at 37 percent. Additionally, less drama surrounding paternity makes for less stressful pregnancies and healthier babies.

If you’re over 25 and you have been with the same guy for over two years and he’s still playing the we-don’t-need-a-piece-of-paper-to-validate-our-commitment card, move on. Unless you want to turn 30 just in time for him to tell you he’s leaving or eventually have a baby out-of-wedlock only for him to consider marrying you after the child turns 18.

Want to know more about LaShaun Williams? Follow her on Twitter @itsmelashaun.

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Pingback: Love & Hip-Hop…Not So Much « La La Land

  • Ruby

    Women who let men live with them for years without commitment and then have children with those men are DESPERATE. Their "man" knows it – his family talks about it, his friends tease him about it. And the woman deep down inside knows it. She's been played.

    • Simmone

      This is so true. I've witnessed this and experienced this myself. Men usually know within a few dates if they have intentions of marriage towards you, but they'll still "play house" with you as long as you're available. If you as a woman know what you want, don't back down from it, and don't settle!

  • Tiffany P

    I disagree with many parts of this article. The article states that an unwed union is not as substantial as a legal union. I beg to differ. The article is bias. First, if you are building a relationship on I's…you are wrong. First you must build the relationship on we to truly come to appreciate the union to move into a marriage. In addition, statistics show that married people are extremely quick and likely to get a divorce. Those statistics there proves that married people are quick to, "wash," their hands of a relationship. And so the article notes that unwed couples are not vulnerable. Any type of relationship is vulnerable. This is the type of information that you take lightly, as everyone's situation is different. As some unwed unions are stronger than married unions.

  • Eugenia

    There are legal protections afforded to marriage and even divorce that can benefit either party and your kids that are not available when you 'shack up'. I don't get why no one seems to see that.

  • Caramel Delight

    I don't understand why people don't see or realize that marriage has no guarantees either. Just because you're married doesn't mean that your husband/wife can't/won't just up and leave you. If that was the case, we wouldn't have divorces. That's life. They are no guarantees in life.

  • Tiffany

    I agree with this article 100% also. Shout out to all of my "conservative" women out there who still think marriage is better than being called a baby mama for the rest of your life

  • Keisha

    It seems a bit antiquated and conservative to me but so is everything else on this website………..

  • Kelly

    I agree with this article. I am totally that woman that has been with her man for 5 years and has nothing to show for it. I moved away from my friends and family to be with him. I found a great job and made some new friends but haven't made too many strides on the relationship front. Trying to get the guts to leave and be on my own in a place where I don't know too many people and don't have any family. Thanks for writing this!!!

    • Brown Beauty

      It sounds like you think marriage will fix your problems but they won't. Marrying your man won't guarantee that you will be happier having moved away from friends and family and it won't make him appreciate you any more. I think you're confusing being unhappy in your situation with being unmarried. Actually, not being married makes leaving him easier if that's what you decide to do. Your credit histories aren't tied together – try leaving and renting an apartment with busted credit. He can't empty out the bank account(s) and don't come home one day leaving you REALLY destitute. You still have control of your situation. You just have to get courageous and use it.

  • Queen

    Co-sign 100%

  • http://Madamenoire butterscotch

    @ sick and tired.you need to start planning for your future,seriously.i don’t get why you’d get pregnant for this man(just asking,no judging)what’s made you keep dealing with him on and off? didn’t that show you the ‘relationship’ was unstable? your mom sees your life’s getting out of hand and you’ve stayed in this and not finished your nursing,she’s probably really worried.you need a career=money to give you and your kids a better life,your man seems unable.how did you expect a man to support you and 2 kids when he wasn’t working? do you want to marry him? only it sounds like you don’t.think very carefully.good luck.

  • Ashley J

    my dad has always told me, "The difference between a man and a boy is that a man knows what he wants and it don't take him all day to go get it!" My dad also told me that if you spend more than a yr in a relationship and he hasn't taken any steps to make you his wife, then you're wasting your time.

    I have lived my life by this and I must say, it hasn't failed me yet! I have no regrets about walking away from relationships b/c I felt like my time was being wasted…I am good enough to be called "wife" not baby mama; not "life partner"; not "long term girlfriend".

    You gotta decide what your worth is!

  • CaribbeanDiva

    i love LaShaun articles! She always keeps it real! Agree agree agree

  • sick and tired

    Question…been involved with the same guy on and off for 8 years this year, now im pregnant. First moved in with him when i was 20. He pulled a few BS stunts but as of last year we got back together full time, and he has stuck with me through totaled car and eviction, on my sister part (her and my salary got us in the place until i lost my job). He wasnt working when he moved back with me but in barbering school. I started nursing school and had to stop cause he couldnt support me and my first two with his barbering salary. .long story short, i know i should have just cut it but at this time, i dont think he will marry me. He seems to be more interested in his career paths than mine or me. Should i just take my 3 kids and leave him to his dream? He says he wants to marry me and asks if i still want to get married in Nov. I think thats too long, especially with newborn due in july. I just think im wasting time, my mom is also hurt i know.

    • Shah

      I think you know the answer, but if you need someone to say it to help you along-you deserve better, and your kids desreve better. Read the article smart women marry for love and money!

  • honeyprincess

    i only got one thing to say and that is AGREEEDDDDD!!!!!

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]