Why Sisters Don’t Get Second Chances

November 30th, 2010 - By Leslie Pitterson


I put down the copy of the paper and had one of those moments.  You know, one of those moments when I can hear Kanye’s “racism still alive, they just be concealing it” line ringing in my head.

It seems it was only yesterday when Dr. Laura Schelessinger made a woefully insincere apology for uttering the N-word on the airwaves.  And while the incident is far from forgotten, the good doctor has gotten a new gig.

According to Schelessinger, XM Sirus Programming Head, Jeremy Coleman reached out to her the day after she had made her public apology on Larry King Live and began courting her for crossing over and bring her show to satellite radio.  With their latest addition, XM can now proudly boast the biggest radio personality acquisition since Howard Stern.

Schelessinger’s new deal was nothing illegal.  It is a clean business move.  But despite it being right in the books, the whole thing feels dirty.  The dynamics that create these unfair, unjust situations needs to change.

Not only did Schelessinger leave her old job on her own terms, she basically received new interest from employers in the wake of the scandal.  While it is easy to focus the conversation around her actions, one has to think about XM’s as well.  What was going through Jeremy Coleman’s head when he approached Schelessinger?

To put it bluntly: ratings.  Racial slurs or no racial slurs, Schelessinger has a loyal audience that would follow her everywhere she goes.  This however is no excuse. By making Schelessinger an offer, Coleman and XM have stamped and approved her behavior and ignorance.

The whole situation is an interesting case study into the dynamics of race in corporate America.  I mean think about it: if a black commentator had made offensive racial comments on-air what are the odds the situation would have turned out the same?

Zero to none.

Forget trying to play colorblind, if a black woman had made those comments, the only thing she’d be seeing is a pastel pink slip.  Certainly, no black woman I know would be promoted for making salacious comments about white people.  But more importantly, what about the other party involved?

As women of color in the workplace, we may not have all experienced working with a Dr. Laura, but in all probability we will work with at least one Jeremy Coleman in our lifetime.  It is crazy how the people who display basic prejudices are often outnumbered and helped by those who mindlessly support it.  While our workplaces are governed by HR rules on racial slurs, there are no clear policies against condoning the same.

While many of us would like to ignore it, black and white employees face very different experiences in workplace.  The expectations for people of color are lower and the penalties for our mistakes are higher.  Think about it:  Mel Gibson got an offer to be in the movie, ‘Hangover 2,’ after his expletive filled rants.  Now riddle me this: where is Isaiah Washington a.k.a. Dr. Burke?

As people of color, the second chance is either a miracle or rarity, but most times unlikely.  Whether fair or not, it is definitely not to be depended on.  Many of us have grown up hearing the saying that “good is not enough.”   But the sad fact is even excellence is no guarantee.

The reality of it can often be disheartening but instead of causing us to fall to despair, the Schelessingers and Colemans of the world should give us even more reason to push harder, to go further and to breakthrough.  For all the slackness and second chances given to our counterparts, for us there is nothing but this chance right here, right now.  So this week, ladies go above and beyond.

“Phenomenal” is our only option, because ordinary is not one.

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Black and proud

    one brutha, one sister, two haters, one wanna be. Have mercy

  • The Phantom

    If you think it’s hard being a black woman in corporate America, try being a black MAN in corporate America. At least they’re hiring the sistas. In most offices, I see plenty of whites and black women but very few black men. And it’s not like we’re all unqualified to work there.

  • Tamara T.

    AMEN! As a woman living in the Pacific Northwest, working in an ubber corporate environment, I wholeheartedly agreed with this article. Now, regardless of ethnicity, being offensive and belligerent (Mel, Isaiah, etc) is never acceptable. But the fact is, the less melanin you have the more mercy you'll receive. I find myself calculating my day to day encounters. From my tone, body language, attire and even posture, just so I rise above any low expectations my employer and/or co-workers may have for me. I had to vent to my mother the other day about how I am probably more successful that most of the "Beckys and Johns" out there that see me and make a conclusion about who I am and what I am worth. I am a dark skinned, college educated, entrepreneur..why am I being made to feel unaccomplished by bigotry? The pressure can be overwhelming at times with having to prove yourself to people you could give two, steaming s**ts about. But I digress, this article was on point and I am satisfied that you brought this topic to the surface. Kudos!

  • Camille

    This article is good and has very valid points for us women of color. We've all had to deal with discrimination and racism in the workplace at some point in our lives, but thank God for the internet businesses, where you don't have to worry about age or race discrimination & have the opportunity to have a global market of customers. Regular store-front & "building" businesses are becoming more & more obsolete & I'm happy about that! Good riddens!! Now I know that this statement may bother some on this post, but I think that the Dr. Laura situation was taken the wrong way. Dr. Laura just repeated what BLACK MEN continually say to each other, which was very accurate. I do fault Dr. Laura for not being sensitive enough for the caller who called in for her advice. We all make mistakes & many women (of all races) can be insensitive to others due to a number of reasons…ie. "that time of the month", "children getting on your nerves", "husband pissed you off" etc. If the average person listened to some of the conversations that the sistas have with one another, what would they hear? Something that would offend someone at some point in time I'm sure & the same can be said for women of other races. I don't think that the Dr. Laura rant was way out there like that racist jerk/comedian who played on Sienfeld who made those HORRIBLE comments to the black guy in the audience…in reference to blacks having rights and so many years ago we were hanging from a rope!! What a racist jerk! Now HE should never be able to find work in Hollywood again!

  • BBBEE25

    Exactly where is Isaiah? I used him as an example 2 days ago…speaking about a similar race related matter.

  • GisforGiggles

    Dr.Laura–if you are the REAL Dr.Laura,

    I'm sorry, but the whole scenario/scandal you put yourself revealed that your full of sh*t. It's one thing to say sorry for doing something wrong, but a completely different thing all together, to recognize and understand that YOU WERE WRONG, and therefore want to make amends for your wrongdoing.

    From you defensiveness, quick resignation, and refusal to ADMIT YOU WERE WRONG–no, it is plain to see that you, your heart, and your apology was NOT sincere, you were just upset for getting caught, and not remorseful for doing wrong.

  • dr laura schlessinger

    Why do you make the assumption that my apology was “woefully insincere”? How do you know my heart? I apologized the same day and without being asked. I stand by my points…but not by my stunningly inartful way I expressed myself – I hurt people and never intend to do so. That recognition of hurting people was the impetus of the apology. Thank you for the opportunity to express my truth. drl

  • ItDoesn’tMatter

    Fantastic Article!

  • JUST SAYIN’

    We need know how to get the money, practice spending it, recycling it in our communities and most of all support each other.

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Why Sisters Don’t Get Second Chances « Madame Noire -- Topsy.com

  • Ms. Mack

    I am so in agreement with this article. I was fired from my position in 2008 from a prominent brokerage house becuase I took instruction from my supoervisor and she gave me the wrong instructions she blamed the entire incident on me. Yes of course she was a old white woman that was not formally educated and I was and sure was smarter than her but I WAS BLACK!. Well I just found a job with a governmnt gency 6 months ago and m extremly happy because managers are not allowed to do that to employees.

  • MiMo

    I totally agree Leslie. You have to get it right the first time, no room for errors because that next blonde wonder that comes thru the door smiling, you might very well be out on your ass for not making coffee for the meeting that morning. I had a friend in HR that’s black and her boss is white. She dangled my friends past over her head and overlooked her for raises and promotions until she, along with myself, all the other people of color were RIF. It was a swift kick for a job well done.

  • Chip

    The role of Dr. Burke was played by Isaiah Washington, not Isaiah Thomas.