From Blackface To Bus Drivers: Why Violence Against Women Is Not A Laughing Matter

October 23rd, 2012 - By Sheena Bryant

Source: www.blackyouthproject.com

Violence against black bodies is something that deeply troubles me.  As an African-American woman, violence against black female bodies specifically causes me great distress and as far as I am concerned, is not a laughing matter.  I cringed as a video displaying a Cleveland bus driver landing an uppercut to the jaw of a young black woman circulated the web.  My heart shattered into thousands of pieces each time I heard someone laugh or comment, “I bet she won’t put her hands on another man.”  While I certainly understand the argument that a man should not have to endure assault or abuse at the hand of a woman, let’s not be mistaken: a line was definitely crossed on that bus.  And, instead of having intelligent conversations about the general lack of respect and regard that black men and women have for each other and their bodies that was displayed in that sad clip, many people chose to laugh about how the driver’s forcible punch resembled a move from the popular video game, Mortal Kombat.

This unfortunate situation isn’t the first time that, as a community, we’ve joked and poked fun at things that don’t contain an iota of humor when you really stop to think about them.  How many times have we chuckled when someone perfectly timed a “keep your pimp hand strong” interjection into an otherwise normal conversation?  I don’t have any close friends or relatives that I’m aware of—and I’m not excluded—who don’t, ‘til this day, get a good laugh out of an “Eat the cake Anna Mae” reference.   I recall the day after the 2009 Chris Brown/Rihanna incident hearing some remarks to the tune of “He beat her a**, she had to do something to provoke him,” said in jest in some instances.

Coincidentally, last week, a group of three white male high school students reenacted Chris Brown beating Rihanna in blackface during a pep rally at New York’s Waverly High School.  People were outraged, characterizing the students’ actions as racist and insensitive.  Black people were deeply offended that white students would exploit such a serious incident to garner laughs and applause, and at a pep rally of all things.  But here’s the thing…we set the precedent.  As a community, we’ve been laughing at violence against women for years now.  While blacks may not perform reenactments of domestic violence in front of large crowds for giggles, some of us certainly posted links to that video of the uppercutting bus driver to see how many likes and comments we’d receive.

Let me be clear; the actions of the Waverly students were deplorable and outright shameful.  I am not placing posting a video and laughing at the same level as donning blackface and behaving like, well, a jacka**.  I am, however, saying that making fun of abuse is ALWAYS unsavory.

There’s a saying that goes, what’s good for the goose is good for the gander.  One of my earliest memories is of singing “I’m Going Up A Yonder” at a dear cousin’s funeral as a young preschooler after she was tragically killed. Her sister’s boyfriend mistook her for his girlfriend and ran her over as she cleaned the snow from her running car.  I also remember looking upon my older sister who was an unrecognizable pulp of flesh when her husband rang our doorbell and left her on our doorstep after beating her with the end of a pistol, almost to the point of death, when I was in high school.  And as a full-fledged woman, I was moved to the point of tears today as I read that Sharmeka Moffitt, a 20-year-old black woman, was set on fire by men—presumably white—in white hoods in a northeastern Louisiana town park on October 21, 2012.  In my world, violence against black female bodies is not a joking matter.  While I’m sure there will be some that will assert that I am taking things too seriously, I’ve seen enough bloody and battered messes to know that let that there are some things that are indeed not good for the goose, and certainly not good for the gander.

Nothing else really needs to be said.   Do you agree?

Sheena Bryant is a writer and blogger in Chicago.  Follow her on twitter at @song_of_herself.

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Anthony-Muthapukkin-Tinney/100001244269956 Anthony Muthapukkin Tinney

    Violence against the black man is perfectly legal,especially when the perpetrator is a black woman.That means any of you on this site can come in my house,slit my throat,and walk away scott-free.Freedom is a beautiful thing.

  • ksw

    Yes, Sis I do agree. And if when don’t see that ours comment’s justifying violence is fueling younger men to commit those same violent acts against young women/girls, We are FOOLING OURSELVES. And for all the women and men who suggest “she got what she deserves”, when it’s your mother, daughter, niece, sister, cousin, friend please revisit your comments and see how mush “sense” your ignorance makes..

  • Candacey Doris

    Agreed. We need to change this, let people of all races know that we aren’t going to accept attacks on us from anyone. That includes other black women too though. Why is watching women fight on BBW fun? If you’re not in a ring, it’s not entertainment. Let’s get a clue and stop promoting violence against ourselves.

  • rosemary davis

    Sheena I feel so sad for you some how i am feeling your pain coming from a domestic violent household myself I often watch my father strike my mom may times one time knocking her completley out what this man did is probably what he does to his wife or girl friend this was probably not an isolated incident and I undertsand the fact that she spit on him among other things and that in itself may have induced the violence and pain he inflicted on her but I think he should have locked all doors called the police and filed battery charges to say the least against her but certainly not use that type of force on any woman some men that do this type thing come from abusive families and so it carries over in to their adult life I am sure he could tke that upper cut back he would because chances are he will loose his job I am quite sure the transit system have guidelines in handling disruptive passengers and they have to be followed no matter what

  • OSHH

    Any type of abuse is never funny nor should it be accepted.

  • Adrina

    As a BW I must say, BW need to check themselves as well. We attack each other and fight over men who are incarcerated, sell drugs, etc. in PUBLIC and on TV (BBW, LHHATL, etc)! So you have to check yourself when you say, “oh violent crimes against women are unacceptable and ppl should do that to us”. We do it to each other. White girls do it too, and is it right? No. The violence against women (any race) is unacceptable, but what you put out there, you tend to get back. Write an article on cleaning up violence against each other, and then come back to this one. And yes, it is somewhat a double standard when a white person commit a crime against us. We need to come together as a race anyway (but that’s another story for another blog)

    • Janay

      I agree. I do not feel that black women are completely blameless. That woman on the bus was completely loud and aggressive. At the same time a man will always overpower a woman and should not punch a woman. I could have even understanding just the pushing and shoving he did. But women black or white need to watch their mouth and who they are speaking to. People in general do. You never know how the other person will react. In the end both people were wrong the black woman and the black man.

    • http://www.facebook.com/jennifer.edia Jenn E. Penny

      idk why people are so quick to call things like this “violence against women”, now if the clevland bus passenger knocked the driver out or caused him some bodily harm, we wouldnt be having this conversation, NO TYPE OF VIOLENCE should be a laughing matter, but if you deserve it, you deserve it. Men refraining from hitting women isnt something that they are born with, its something that is learned, thats why when their toddlers they hit each other, and when you ask them why? “she hit me first” is normally the answer, when men are taught to stop from striking a woman its usually “women are weaker than men, so its not fair for a man to hit a woman cuz you’re stronger”. BUT not every man is taught that, they continue living with that “if i get hit, im hitting you back regardless” type of thinking, so women should not assume that every man is like that, and keep their hands to them damn selves
      shoot if Chyna (the wrestler) beat up Kevin Hart, ya’ll wont be preaching “Violence against women” will you

  • Meyaka

    Violence against women is not a laughing matter,however when the woman returns to her attacker (Rihanna),or provoke and attack a man first(mortal combat chick),it makes it hard to consider her a victim.

    • http://www.facebook.com/jennifer.edia Jenn E. Penny

      now ABUSE is a different story, violent acts against a person (no matter the race or gender) without provocation or reason is NOT ok and that is not something i agree with, which is why i have no issue if Rhi was to get back with CB, cuz yes they had a fight, and yes he overpowered her and beat her but he did not ABUSE HER, it wasnt an ongoing act. its the same as if Rhi abused him and he went back to her, would you guys call him “stupid” for doing that?

      • Meyaka

        Him beating her down is okay? Because “it was only once”? Wow…. I don’t think I even have it in me to respond to your comment,good for you…I guess.

        • http://www.facebook.com/jennifer.edia Jenn E. Penny

          its the same thing as you getting into a physical fight with a female and then ya’ll putting bygones away and being friends still, i see it all the time, females scrapping in the parking lot and being besties the same day, idk why because he is a man, a stigma must be attached, no im not saying his behavior was right but i dont see gender when it comes to violence, the justice system does that enough. When your mom popped you in the mouth for talking back did you not go back home cuz she may “pop you again”? Violence is violence no matter the context OR gender

          • Meyaka

            Okay.

  • KIR12

    The majority of black women and girls attacked and beaten are assaulted by other black girls and women!

    • Adrina

      Hence, these ratchet shows like Basketball Wives & Bad Girls Club (well I guess that’s with the white girls)

    • OSHH

      Thats not true. There was an article up yesterday on Black voices that says something VERY different, check it out.

      • KIR12

        I looked at it hun, that’s murders. I’m talking about fights and assaults. Come on now, you know what going on. If you don’t believe me, google black women fighting.

  • IllyPhilly

    This same sentiment can be said for every kind of violent act. Any show, any song, any book in some way, shape, or form romanticizes and/or jokes about horrible violent acts. I’m saying you’re taking it too seriously, but anybody-man, woman, child getting set on fire is horrid within itself. Still, you’ll have someone there ready with comic relief on the subject. IDK, maybe finding the humor even though dark, is how people cope.