The Issue With Standing For Nothing: What Exactly Makes You A “Role Model” In The Black Community?

August 22nd, 2012 - By Charing Ball

 

Source: Flickr – YBFchic

Recently Harry Belafonte caused a minor uproar when he gave his opinion on the state of minorities in Hollywood today:

“And I think one of the great abuses of this modern time is that we should have had such high-profile artists, powerful celebrities. But they have turned their back on social responsibility. That goes for Jay-Z and Beyonce, for example. Give me Bruce Springsteen, and now you’re talking. I really think he is black.”

Much of the backlash to his statement had more to do with his example of Jay-Z and Beyonce, the latter even released a paper thin list of philanthropic efforts to counter his statements, however little introspection is giving to his overall point about how many black artists and celebrities fail to use their platforms for influence outside of themselves. It may be easy to brush Belafonte off as an old hater, in fact, some folks already have, but consider that at the height of his career, Belafonte risked public ostracization by refusing to perform in segregated venues and marched with the likes of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. – even at a time when it wasn’t cool to do so.  He also financially supported the movement, including bailing him, as well as other protestors, out of Birmingham jail where King wrote his famous letter.  And throughout his life, he has continued to be an instrumental voice for human rights, from protesting against apartheid in South Africa and the unfair embargo in Cuba to lending his celebrity to the genocide crisis in Rwanda. If anyone has the right to be critical of today’s black elite involvement, it certainly should be Belafonte.

Yet as many high profile black entertainers, celebrities and political and business leaders continue to enjoy the perks of power and personal influence their visibility has afforded them, most are reluctant to speak truth to power.  In some cases, if that truth works against their own personal interest, some high profile blacks will intentionally work against the community’s best interest.  We see it in rap music; we see it in Hollywood, we see it in politics too. Even writer Richard Hazell, with EurWeb, noticed the same trend among black athletes when he wrote the following:

“Are there any athletes that stand for something socio-political? Are there any that would be willing to risk fame and fortune in the modern era? Well, many risk fame and fortune over dumb stuff; sexual assault, spousal abuse, disorderly conduct, and DUI are but a few of the charges that have been filed against high profile athletes in the last 10 years. During Kobe Bryant’s trial for sexual assault and rape Nike and McDonalds dropped him within days of the allegations surfacing. So athletes are willing to act a fool on their own accord and risk endorsements, but are not willing to risk those same endorsements by taking a stand for a controversial political stance? It’s looking like a duck, it’s quacking like a duck, so it’s not a pigeon.”

Very few black public figures take an active stance for justice anymore. This includes Condoleezza Rice, the first African-American woman to serve as national security advisor and secretary of state. Recently,  it was announced that Rice was admitted to the Augusta National Golf Club‘s, making her the first African American woman member.  And the Black community cheered. Somehow this is supposed to be a milestone in Black history.  This is Rice’s Jackie Robinson moment.  We are supposed to clap, give high-fives and sing the last verse of “We Shall Overcome,” because finally they let one of us into the big house – of golf.

Laugh, but I have been reading this very sentiment all day. I never understood the Black community’s love affair with Rice. In her roles as National Security Advisor and Secretary of State, Condoleezza Rice, along with her cohorts in the Bush Administration, concocted a scheme to suggest that Saddam Hussien was responsible for the September 11th attacks and then led the U.S. into an illegal invasion, which resulted in the deaths of millions of innocent Iraqis along with over 4000 American soldiers.  She also personally approved the use of waterboarding and other harsh interrogation techniques against so-called “insurgents,” a tactic that would become immortalized in the Abu Ghraib scandal.
Closer to home, while the Gulf Coast was underwater thanks to Hurricane Katrina, Rice decided to jet off to New York for some Broadway theater, a tennis match with Monica Seles and shoe shopping at Salvatore Ferragamo.

But she speaks so well and she is accomplished. She speaks multiple languages and plays a mean classical piano. She certainly is not one of those lacefront-having, welfare queens with 10 kids by four different men.  In other words, she is respectable. I know, you were thinking that. In fact, I’m willing to bet that somewhere around the third sentence, some of you have already stopped reading just to write just that very feeling in the comment section below and to remind us that not only is she Condoleeza Rice, she’s DR. Condoleeza Rice.

But what’s so respectable about a woman, whose major contribution to society was torture, war and an indifference to the suffering of the black and poor? So what that she was chosen for membership into a golf club, which only started letting in African-Americans on its green in 1990? Who cares that she now gets to rub elbows with these old white men, who were so defiant against the entry of women of any shade that the former chairman once stated, “There may well come a day when women will be invited to join our membership, but that timetable will be ours, and not at the point of a bayonet.”

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • FRANCINE

    As an Afro American I to have wondered why sooooooo many of us who have achieved a level of financial and professional success have not used that power to better franchise others. Too many Afro Americans don’t know who Harry Belafonte is and all the work he and Sidney Poitier, Paul Robeson, Tony Bennett, Frank Sinatra, Henry Fonda, Marlon Brando and so many others who gave their time, money and put their on personal safety on the line in support of Freedom and equality for Black people doing the Civil Rights Movement. We all have growth up with a Condi Rice and we all know that she is type who will always achieve her level of comfort on all of those who stood on line to fight against injustice directed at Black people. I was shocked to learned she is from Birmingham, Alabama and she didn’t participate in boycotts and protest in that city. Her family didn’t do anything except to benefit from blood and deaths of sooooo many Black people.

  • Nat

    Best, most substantial article I have ever read on Madame Noire. Nice.

  • CarlaKah

    Role models of capitalism.

  • disqus_WfmNqv9gsC

    wow, actually read the entire article and it was excellent. I never thought of it like this.

  • Jack

    Your article is flimsy and irresponsible which should not
    really surprise me, I mean after all you are a blogger and bloggers tend to be
    reckless, twisted, and devoid of something the world no longer cares about:
    Facts. Condoleeza Rice was born in
    Birmingham Alabama and was a child of the Civil Rights Era. Her Father was
    active in the Civil Rights Movement and the death of the girls at the 16th
    Street Baptist Church had a deep and profound impact on her life. She was a
    registered Democrat until 1982 and broke with the party over the foreign policy
    of Jimmy Carter. The same Democratic Party that refused to register her Father
    to vote in Alabama so he became a Republican. Black people are not monolithic
    in thoughts, ideas, and beliefs. It
    seems now a days
    that if you are not towing the party line then you are demeaned and criticized
    because your thoughts and perceptions are different. Her ideals of what it means to be Black
    from the Black Democratic establishment. She doesnt believe that African-Americans
    should see themselves as victims and
    that the sacrifices of the Civil Rights movement were not designed to create a
    dependent cuture of cry babies but that blood was shed to make
    African-Americans inclusive in the American Dream. Blame the baby bottle
    mentality on black leadership for the current state of Black America. Not
    Republicans and Not George Bush. Rice
    was Secretary of State and to suggest she was in different to the suffering of
    people in New Orleans is laughable. You can debate foreign Policy all day but
    you misrepresent what actually happened in that era. The safety and peace you
    enjoy today is a result of the work she did. It amazes me how all you American
    hating black bloggers bemoan the evils of America but you benefit from its freedoms. Misrepresentation is what your kind do
    best. You try to blame her for Katrina!? What about the Democratic Mayor
    and Govenor of that state. New Orleans was drenched in poverty for generations. Ray Nagin and his incompetence are to blame for that debacle. Now I remember why I stopped reading blogs. Condeeleza Rice is something Negroes like you can’t stand, Someone who actually has the nerve to think for themselves. If anybody knows about being Black in America its her. If you havent walked in that ladies shoes shut the hell up. The Responses on here are laughable.

    Your article is flimsy and irresponsible which should not
    really surprise me, I mean after all you are a blogger and bloggers tend to be
    reckless, twisted, and devoid of something the world no longer cares about:
    Facts. Condoleeza Rice was born in
    Birmingham Alabama and was a child of the Civil Rights Era. Her Father was
    active in the Civil Rights Movement and the death of the girls at the 16th
    Street Baptist Church had a deep and profound impact on her life. She was a
    registered Democrat until 1982 and broke with the party over the foreign policy
    of Jimmy Carter. The same Democratic Party that refused to register her Father
    to vote in Alabama so he became a Republican. Black people are not monolithic
    in thoughts, ideas, and beliefs. It
    seems now a days
    that if you are not towing the party line then you are demeaned and criticized
    because your thoughts and perceptions are different. Her ideals of what it means to be Black
    from the Black Democratic establishment. She doesnt believe that African-Americans
    should see themselves as victims and
    that the sacrifices of the Civil Rights movement were not designed to create a
    dependent cuture of cry babies but that blood was shed to make
    African-Americans inclusive in the American Dream. Blame the baby bottle
    mentality on black leadership for the current state of Black America. Not
    Republicans and Not George Bush. Rice
    was Secretary of State and to suggest she was in different to the suffering of
    people in New Orleans is laughable. You can debate foreign Policy all day but
    you misrepresent what actually happened in that era. The safety and peace you
    enjoy today is a result of the work she did. It amazes me how all you American
    hating black bloggers bemoan the evils of America but you benefit from its freedoms. Misrepresentation is what your kind do
    best. You try to blame her for Katrina!? What about the Democratic Mayor
    and Govenor of that state. New Orleans was drenched in poverty for generations. Ray Nagin and his incompetence are to blame for that debacle. Now I remember why I stopped reading blogs. Condeeleza Rice is something Negroes like you can’t stand, Someone who actually has the nerve to think for themselves. If anybody knows about being Black in America its her. If you havent walked in that ladies shoes shut the hell up. The Responses on here are laughable.

    • Elisa

      My thoughts exactly. The article is clearly biased and irresponsible. Devoid of actual facts and based on opinions. Should we not admire President Obama because of what he was able to achieve? Breaking barriers and opening doors for minorities is worthy of admiration.

      • CarlaKah

        I did not see inaccurte facts. Name them please

    • Gimmeabreak78

      Firstly, why did you feel the need to post your rant twice? Secondly, the author didn’t demonize Secy. Rice simply for being a Republican. She criticized her for supporting/endorsing policies which have negative impact on the marginalized and disenfranchized. I think what you said was irresponsible and untrue. There was a political ad recently in which Mitt Romney’s father was shown marching with black people during the Civil Rights Movement. The ad/meme was meant to pursuade black people that Mitt Romney had their political/social interests at heart. Your citiation of Condi Rice’s father’s experience is just as ineffectual. Just like Governor Romney cannot claim to be an advocate for black people based on his father’s Civil Rights credentials, neither can Secretary Rice. As a New Orleanian, I think your criticism of Mayor Nagin was fair, and I would include him in the list of black people who rise to success, then leave the people he came from stranded. The author’s point wasn’t that black people should or shouldn’t be liberals or conservatives, Democrats or Republicans–simply that those of us who have reached the upper echelon of wealth, celebrity, or influence should use it for the betterment of more than just their own pocketbooks and titles.

  • redfingerpaint

    My Black role models all have the same thing in common… (Besides being Black, of course!)
    -No children out of wedlock
    -Believe in Christ and the power of prayer
    -Can speak articulately
    -Have struggled with body image before
    -Promotes the health & wealth (Not just talking finances) for women everywhere

    • tiredofthebs

      @ redfingerpaint
      I am in no way promoting single parenthood, but don’t you think it’s interesting how Kourtney Kardashian, Kim from RHOA, Madonna (before getting married), Angelina Jolie, Jessica Simpson, Emily B from L&Hip Hop, Evelyn from BBW and countless other non-Black women can have kids out of wedlock, but are never deemed with the social stigma in the likeness as Black women who are in the same predicament. Whether, or not they’re with the father of their kids, we can use Nia Long for an example.
      As a Black woman, I completely understand how this issue effects our community, but lets not act like that is a litmus test of character. I know some GREAT single mothers, that despite every obstacle from racism and sexism, who were determined for their kids to have a good life. Many of their children have a good life, and many don’t just like ppl who come from two parent homes. Of course there are many issues one can have, by not having the stability from two parents, but I know ppl who are equally, if not more effed up than ppl that come from a two parent home.
      As for speaking articulately, what does that encompass? Language is determined by location, so regardless of how some one speaks they’re actually correct (it becomes a problem when they are no longer in the area where their language is spoken, which is where Standard English comes in. SE only exists so that ppl of diff locations can communicate with each other. Therefore, someone saying Good Morning, or What’s Up are both suitable morning greetings. However, obviously if one says What’s Up in a office, it’s only inappropriate because it’s not Standard English (then again it depends on the office)
      I really dislike when ppl of color try to define who they like, on opinions and factors of anyone, including non-Blacks.
      I will continue my comment later.

      • redfingerpaint

        You are absolutely right, those women don’t hear anything about having had children out of wedlock. Choosing to have a child out of wedlock is something that I’ve been told that you just don’t do. There are great single mothers who want nothing but the best for their children. I come from a two-parent household and I’ve grown up praying that I have the wonderful happy marriage that my parents have. Even though it hasn’t happened to me, I see and hear the struggles that single mothers go through and I don’t want that to happen to me. I know I can’t control whether or not my marriage lasts forever. I want to be able to show my (nonexistent) child(ren) the happiness I’ve been able to witness. The first things that come to mind when you mention Kourtney Kardashian, Kim from RHOA, Madonna, Angelina Jolie, Jessica Simpson, Emily B from L&Hip Hop, and Evelyn from BBW aren’t positive things…

        Language is determined by location; however, Standard American English has standards. (I.e. Fluency, phonetics, grammar, enunciation, etc.) My parents spent a lot of money on my education, and I want people to know that I’m an educated American. (Because we still have those who are illiterate)

        So you’re saying I shouldn’t choose who I like based on my opinion? Please tell me how you think I should choose who I like…

        Side note to those to gave me a thumbs down: What I said wasn’t to be taken with malice, I apologize. I didn’t mean to offend or upset anyone. I simply stated what my Black role models have in common.

  • DoinMe

    EXCELLENT article. Although I totally agree with this article, there is a flip side to this. I remember when Tyrese spoke out about some liquor store being set-up directly across the street from an elementary school in some city he was visiting. He took to the airwaves to express his outrage. The next day, the “powers-that-be” were after his head and he said this is why black celebs, athletes, and others in public can’t/won’t speak out because their careers will be nixed. Look at how the Heat treated DWade and LeBron when they wore hoodies expressing solidarity for Trayvon Martin. The Heat managers/owners were against it and treated them like slaves needing permission. However, in saying that, there has to be a point where these public figures have to stop being so afraid of “the man” and threatening their livelihoods and take a stand for something much bigger than they are.

    • CarlaKah

      Which DWade abd LeBron did.

  • Gimmeabreak78

    Excellent article. It articulates exactly what I have said for years. It’s not enough to make it up the ladder. It’s even worse to kick the ladder out from under you so no one else can make it, and worse yet to point and sneer in contempt for your brothers and sister still struggling at the bottom. There are a lot of black celebrities, business leaders, professionals, and politicians who are guilty of squandering their gifts, talents, and influence on themselves only. However, there are many more who make an effort to mentor, educate, and offer a hand up to the struggling and suffering. It is important that while we properly hold the ones who can do better accountable, but we should also laud the ones who are using their sizeable influence for the betterment of others. By the way, it’s worth noting that most of the ones who use their influence to positively impact the less fortunate do it quietly, and without fanfare. For example, NFL player Namdi Asomugha could do what many football players do, and simply set up football camps in his name, which in and of itself is fine. However, Asomugha is aware that most kids won’t grow up to be NFL players, so he started a college tour program which has nothing to do with football at all, but the goal of the program is to create the expectation in our young people (especially our young men), that your brains have a better chance of getting you out of poverty than your athletic prowess.

  • hey

    EVERYONE is a role model…either a good one or a bad one.

  • Jenn

    I enjoyed the article. I do think sometimes we (including Mr. Belafonte) want to make these ‘larger than life’ celebrities into do-good, humanitarian people when they are who they are. Beyonce didn’t say I want to become a singer to change the world, she wanted to become a singer. If you don’t have that care in you from the beginning just because you have the fame and money doesn’t mean you’ll turn into one. Unfortunitely, I think a lot of celebs do good out of pressure or obligation (clearly with that baby list Beyonce deemed necessary to provide -_-). Again good article!

    • onelove

      But, where Mr Belafonte is coming from is the Carters can use their status as a platform to stand for social issues. Even if it’s a personal interest of theirs that they think will be beneficial to somebody. So, I guess it’s rightfully okay to conclude the Carters don’t care about anything else other than themselves. I think, it’s that expectation or human nature that when someone makes it, it’s nice to help others out, doesn’t have to be financial, it can be other ways. People will listen to Beyonce more than some regular lady talking about something positive but then Bey can’t give what she doesn’t have. The truth about it, some people will attack me for this, we don’t know how to help each other out. I think, once some of us make it, we are just glad to make it and don’t think about anybody else, whether it’s consciously or subconsciously. I know, it’s due to the fact that we are trying to be careful and not lose our job or fans. But, if Mr Belafonte and many others have that mindset we won’t be where we are now. I live in a diverse neighborhood, and I see the support other groups give each other, and some of them might not be the nicest but one thing they understand is, unity. I have to support another person who looks like me bcos he/she is representing me, my people. Black people are jut different, is it that we don’t have as much heart to help others as much as other ethnic group does? Whether is fake or not, somebody is benefiting from it as opposed to keeping your mouth shut and only care for yourself. I give credit to those humanitarians out there who are not popular but giving their time, money, voice to make a difference.

      • Gye Nyame

        I loved this article except the Condi rant. Don’t get me wrong, she is not my role model and I totally disagree with her policies, but I’m not into blacks constantly and publicly tearing each other apart. Whites must get a kick out of how we destroy one another so effortlessly. You can agree that someone is intelligent and accomplished, but disagree with their policies/positions, that’s what other races do, but ultimately they stick together and protect one another. Another assumption the author makes is just b/c a person is black doesn’t mean they are conscious or has a sense of self. If you don’t know your history (beyonce), or have a sense of self (jay-z), then you can’t take a stand on behalf of your community like mr. belafonte. Activism is the act of expressing one’s belief in order to bring about change, if you don’t know anything, you don’t believe in anything, so you don’t stand for anything.

    • DoinMe

      “Unfortunitely, I think a lot of celebs do good out of pressure or obligation…”

      That’s true. Some of them do it either for PR purposes or to get tax write offs. Charity is not the same thing as the type of activism Harry Belafonte is speaking about.

  • salobe246

    I fully understand the purpose of this article. with that said, i should also acknowledge that fact that it is a catch 22 as well. Condoleezza has a cousin named Constance Rice. The history of education, purpose and success in their family run deep, whether that is because they are fair skinned people or because they fought for it is a conversation for another day. The fact is that Connie Rice has fought and does fight for a better Los Angeles from a legal and political angle. But no one hears about her story – even though she wrote a book about it. It is important to call out the celebs with billies and millies but its just as important to recognize and publicize folks who are doing good work with less limelight.

  • tiredofthebs

    I literally enjoy your articles!!!
    Though, I must be honest, I dislike the assumption that the entire Black community believes that “speaking well” or not being a “welfare queen” makes her a role model.
    Many of us, like you, are not delusional, or ignorant enough to believe that education, and “speaking well” equates to one being a role model. Fortunately, that’s only for the ignorant, because if they look at it, most of the ppl who fit into that category are the same ones that help put them and/or keep them in the ghetto, and for many arrest them.
    The same way the Black reality stars don’t represent me, the ignorant ones in our community don’t either.
    Overall, I loved that you were on point about your subject matter, this is the kind of knowledge that should be discussed in our communities to bring change! Please keep the articles coming!

  • Dee

    Amen and Amen!!!