Wanting To Reconcile With A Former Friend After Her Breakup? Don’t Say “I Told You So”

August 15th, 2012 - By Alissa Henry
"black female friends"

Source: askmissa.com

As a rule, I don’t negatively comment on my friend’s significant others. Regardless of my personal feelings about him, if she’s happy then I’m happy for her and if she’s pissed then I’ll commiserate. If she wants revenge, I’ll Google tips and if she wants to marry him I’ll be a bridesmaid.

I haven’t always been this way. I used to tell my friends exactly what I thought of their boyfriends – good or bad. Although I couldn’t seem to make a good decision in the love department, I was quick to offer my advice if I thought a friend was making a poor one.

This, I learned the hard way, can be disastrous. For one, badmouthing a friend’s boyfriend when she likes him doesn’t make sense. So what if I think he’s ugly, ignorant, too short, too scrawny, too nice, too impatient, or generally not good enough for her? I’m not the one who’s dating him. I don’t determine what it is she should value in a man. If she asks my advice on one situation, like what to get him for Christmas, that isn’t my opportunity to volunteer: “A set of encyclopedias because he’s an idiot.”

Even badmouthing a friend’s ex-boyfriend after they breakup can be dangerous. The rate of reconciliation is incredibly high the days and weeks following a split. If I’ve spent the last few weeks talking about how she dodged a bullet cause he looked more like Katt Williams than Morris Chestnut anyway then what happens when they get back together? She’ll know I thought he had the personality of a doorknob and our friendship will probably suffer for it. The best thing to do is to just not say anything negative about him until she’s clearly moved on (if at all).

Sometimes we don’t do the best thing though. Sometimes, we tell our friend when we think her boyfriend is buffoon. We tell her that she’s making a mistake by dating him (or marrying him!) and that she could and should do better. In those instances, the friendship might fall apart. It’s a rare female that chooses her friends over her boyfriend.

But what happens when your friendship crumbles then she ends up dumping her shoddy boyfriend (or fiancé, or husband)? When the entire reason you fell out was because of your ill feelings toward him does that mean the friendship is back on? Not necessarily. However, if you’re interested in saving that friendship there are some things you can do.

  1. Reach out to her – Gauge when is the right time then make a concerted effort to reach out. True, you may not want to show up at her house unannounced with Ben & Jerry’s and romantic comedies on DVD, but a simple phone call to say “hello” can be enough to at least crack the ice.
  2. Make amends – Accept responsibility for the part you played in the demise of the friendship and express sincere interest in reconciling.
  3. Resist the urge to say “I told you so” – It can vindicating to know that you warned her about him before he turned out to be exactly who you said he was.  Still, don’t bother reminding her you told her so. You both already know that and if you’re truly interested in salvaging a friendship then you shouldn’t be rubbing salt in a wound.
  4. Understand being right about this guy doesn’t make you right about every guy – Giving someone good advice in one instance doesn’t make you her life coach.
  5. Let go of the past – As far as it depends on you, refuse to rehash what went wrong in the friendship before. Focus on moving past that. If you have to look back, look back at the good times before the falling out to remember why you were friends in the first place.

So many things are said and done to destroy even the most solid of friendships. As a result, it can feel like there is no way to get back to where you were. That’s because there isn’t. We can never go back in time and continue on as if nothing changed. We can however use what’s changed to build something even stronger. And, in the future, we can take care to keep our friendship about our friendship and not allow our opinion of each other’s relationship to destroy that.

Have you ever fallen out with a friend because of who she was dating? Did you reconcile?

Follow Alissa on Twitter @AlissaInPink

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • RifaG

    Is this veiled advice for Jen? lol

  • Yay!

    As you mentioned at the start of your article, the best policy is to follow the friend’s lead. If she’s happy I’ll be happy for her. If she’s sad I’ll try to make her feel better. Either way my opinions of her man will be kept to a strict neutral. Ideally good girlfriends should be able to talk about all things under the sun, but as an adult I find commenting on a friend’s man is the quickest way to end a friendship. As long as she’s safe there is no good reason (or time) for me to have all kinds of opinions her man.

  • linda

    If I’m asked my opinion of course I’ll say something but after the
    first time, it’s no longer my place to continue to tell her how bad of a
    guy he is or impose on her relationship like that.~ blackwhiteplanet _℃om ~~~~~ is for thousands of upscale men and beautiful
    women, who understand that ambition, success, and glamour are key elements of
    attraction. It’s worth a try!it’s more so likes that attract to each other… clean people don’t want
    to be friends with dirty people, honest people don’t have time for
    liars..etc..

  • Kitty

    I went through this with my former best friend. Her boyfriend didn’t like me and the feeling was mutual. He was abusive and controlling. I supported her in her decisions about being with him because they had kids together. When she told me they were getting married I was less then pleased. She asked me to be in the wedding and I expressed that I would but I don’t agree with it. Needless to say she got angry with my feelings and stopped speaking to me. Of course he whipped her again after the marriage and they divorced shortly after, but I lost her friendship forever because I spoke up.

  • Guest360

    I kinda agree and disagree. One of the things I value in friendships is honesty and the same is true for my friends. Now I’m not saying that I go out of my way to talk about their boyfriends in a negative way but I do give my two cents. If their boyfriend was a jerk to me, I say so. If I think he’s sneaky or bad news, I’m going to give her a heads up. Any decision they make afterwards is theirs and theirs alone and at that point it’s my duty as a friend to support her in whatever decision she makes, even if I don’t like it. If I’m asked my opinion of course I’ll say something but after the first time, it’s no longer my place to continue to tell her how bad of a guy he is or impose on her relationship like that.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JAI4SRENU2A5WKRTELXXYJPDSI Kayla

    In all honesty. Maybe it is best to go your separate ways. Now while your obviously aren’t the expert in dating, how can why would you be friends with someone who has a poor taste in men? That may have been cute when you two were in highschool, but it’s obvious if your friend is making the same dumb choice over and over and over again. Then it should be clear they are obviously immature, and still have a lot of growing up to do. A true friend can’t and shouldn’t sit idly by while the boyfriend takes advantage and treats your friend harshly. going through that same scenario time and time again can be nauseating. You know how they say “birds of a feather flock together”, so perhaps both of you have a lot of growing up to you and are equally immature, or you don’t want your friend’s poor choices rubbing off on you. I would hope anyone would want a group of friends that reflect the same positive qualities as themselves. i.e. maturity,loyalty,honesty etc…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JAI4SRENU2A5WKRTELXXYJPDSI Kayla

    In all honesty. Maybe it is best to go your separate ways. Now while your obviously aren’t the expert in dating, how can why would you be friends with someone who has a poor taste in men? That may have been cute when you two were in highschool, but it’s obvious if your friend is making the same dumb choice over and over and over again. Then it should be clear they are obviously immature, and still have a lot of growing up to do. A true friend can’t and shouldn’t sit idly by while the boyfriend takes advantage and treats your friend harshly. going through that same scenario time and time again can be nauseating. You know how they say “birds of a feather flock together”, so perhaps both of you have a lot of growing up to you and are equally immature, or you don’t want your friend’s poor choices rubbing off on you. I would hope anyone would want a group of friends that reflect the same positive qualities as themselves. i.e. maturity,loyalty,honesty etc…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JAI4SRENU2A5WKRTELXXYJPDSI Kayla

    In all honesty. Maybe it is best to go your separate ways. Now while your obviously aren’t the expert in dating, how can why would you be friends with someone who has a poor taste in men? That may have been cute when you two were in highschool, but it’s obvious if your friend is making the same dumb choice over and over and over again. Then it should be clear they are obviously immature, and still have a lot of growing up to do. A true friend can’t and shouldn’t sit idly by while the boyfriend takes advantage and treats your friend harshly. going through that same scenario time and time again can be nauseating. You know how they say “birds of a feather flock together”, so perhaps both of you have a lot of growing up to you and are equally immature, or you don’t want your friend’s poor choices rubbing off on you. I would hope anyone would want a group of friends that reflect the same positive qualities as themselves. i.e. maturity,loyalty,honesty etc…

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]