Papa Does Preach: Are Purity Balls Just Another Way For Males to Dominate Women?

August 7th, 2012 - By Toya Sharee

Source: channel.nationalgeographic.com

The last image a young woman wants to have when losing her virginity is a vision of her father.  But for the hundreds of young girls who participate in purity balls each year, decisions about sexuality are heavily influenced by the protective presence of their fathers.

Recently, the popular National Geographic Channel show Taboo featured a segment on the episode “Teen Sex” about the practice of purity balls. A purity ball is a formal dance or ceremony attended by fathers and their daughters where the young women pledge their virginity to the protection of their fathers until they are married.  The fathers then pledge to safe keep what they see as their young daughters’ “purity of mind, body and soul.”  The practice is closely associated with evangelical Christian churches and originated by Randy Wilson in Colorado Springs in 1998.  A field director for the Family Research Council, a conservative Christian organization, Wilson promotes purity balls across the country and his website boasts that they have been held in 48 states.

Before I get into how purity balls can easily take a left turn down a double-standard dead end, in their defense, purity balls send a lot of positive messages.  I could never imagine being able to come to my father and have an honest, un-awkward conversation about sexuality and relationships. In fact, for most young American girls, their father’s reaction to them being sexually active is one of two extremes: Your crazy daddy chasing boys out your bedroom window with his sawed off Smith and Wesson not far off; or what is an even worse reality for many girls: Daddy not being there at all to care.  The purity balls on this episode featured fathers taking a very active involvement in their daughter’s honor and well-being and treating them as the treasures that every little girl should feel like she is to the first man in her life that defines to her what a man should be for a woman.  As one of the fathers on the episode stated, “The man sets the moral compass for the entire family.”  Wilson goes even further emphasizing that purity balls are more about the fathers than they are the daughters. “The idea was to model what the relationship can be as a daughter grows from a child to an adult.  You come in closer, become available to answer whatever questions she has,” Wilson offers to fathers struggling to find a place in the lives of their maturing daughters.

But even with the best intentions in the world, the whole purity ball ceremony is honestly kind of creepy when played out.  The girls march to an altar in a procession of mini child brides alongside their fathers dressed in somber suits. The dads then descend on bended knee placing purity rings on their daughter’s left hands.  The compliant girls adoringly gaze down in white dresses promising to remain abstinent until marriage.  What was also slightly unnerving for me is how young the girls appeared to be.  The youngest girls appeared to be all of 9 or 10 years old and I’m still not convinced that they are 100 percent sure of what they are actually signing up for. As they slow-dragged their feet in tune with their fathers, their expressions were vacant and apathetic, not passionate and empowered like young women convinced of their moral path. Some guidelines state that girls can be as young as four years old and as old as college age, but the majority of young girls who participate do so once they’ve entered puberty.  At an age where young girls are debating the decision of tampon or pad, making a semi-permanent pledge about virginity could be seen as an unnecessary amount of pressure.

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Pam in Fort Valley

    So sad that even in this day we are still debating whether a boy should be told to abstain as we tell our girls. Of course we should, and there isn’t even any doubt. If men and boys would stop pressuring females to have sex, then we would not have this problem in the first place. And these mothers who allow their husbamds to be up in their dauhgtrer’s business and not their son’s purity, has got to wake up and stop this madness. There is no way, that would allow my husband to take charge of my daughter’s sex life. This is weird, gross, creepy, and inappropriate. Take her horseback riding or teach her to play tennis. But stay out of her female business!!! Worry about teaching your son how to be a gentleman and stop looking for a girl to seduce.

  • Smara

    I think the abstinence message shouldn’t be a one time lesson, but just one part of the values that children are raised with. And yes, it should be constant for boys and girls as well.

    The issue is that so many that teach about abstinence think that any alternative message will make their children stray, when in fact, it’s the sheltered (usually religious) kids that are heading to the abortion clinics (because mommy and daddy aren’t excepting no bastard chilruns) in the highest numbers.

    Like I said, the values should be there, but the issue of sex should be in a constant flowing conversation from a VERY early age.

    Ironically enough, I was raised in a very Christian home and I’m the only sibling (of 6) to still be an “active” member of the faith, and, as far as I know, to still be a virgin (22 years old). I doubt that i’d still be “pure” based solely on my parents. They were controlling and suffocating.

    To make any message stick to a child, you have to make it about them. They shouldn’t be told to wait because daddy want’s them to. They have to be convinced that this is the way they want to live.

  • Kaine

    Bossip is not my thing, went there once and never went back, I was hoping people would have more mature comments on this site, you obviously proved me wrong.You are truly off. it’s about time you stop replying.

  • ykarer

    HEELL YEEESS!!!!!!1111
    :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
    I HAVE DONE IT – FINALLLLY…..I got rid of all my ISHHH from my credit report y’all – I was in deep for 5 years AND DIDN’T THINK I WOULD GET OUT. Coudn’t buy sheeet. Just approved for that 25k loan to buy a new CAMA AROOOOO SPECIAL EDITION!!!
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    IF YOU GOT PROBLEMS WITH THAT CRE DIT HISTORY ISHH, GET RID OF ALL OF IT. YOu can get yours too, call these people at 877-243-0956 – they did an amazing job for me and fo a price that can’t be beat nowhere, cheap as fuqq. Got Rid of all my Shyyyt – and they did it in a very short time frame.
    ================================================================
    My homegirl was in horrible shape too and strugglin worse than me, and she clean in one season! Hit em up – they will help!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
    bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb

  • Pfft

    Well, if it’s any consolation, I only have a son (currently pregnant with daughter) and I talk to him ALL the time about abstaining from sex as does my husband. We tell him all the consequences from diseases, to unwanted pregnancy. How if he gets a girl pregnant, he will quit foot ball and baseball to pick up a job of which most his funds will go towards maintaining care for his child. We wear him thin at least once a week with talks because we are serious. There will be repercussions for poor choices. Period.

    Honestly, I think in a society that ALL about sex, these parents are doing what they think is best. Is it best, not sure, but let’s be real. Too often on these blogs we read people griping about lack of interaction on the part of black fathers to protect their daughter. Granted this may not be the best idea according to some, it’s a start. Give the man props for trying. All this said, I agree, boys should be brought in on this as well. It takes two to have sex.

  • Kay

    Men Don’t have purity balls so why should women? I could understand if this was initiated by the girl but the fact that the fathers have such a big role in this makes it weird and creepy. This double standard mess has to end.

  • NiceNasty

    Does it matter? I mean think about it, really it’s all in supply and demand and if more of the population of girls waited then guess what? Men will have no other choice but to wait or be gay. yea I know that there will be some that don’t wait(girls), but after awhile they are going to be all used up and ain’t nobody gon want them. Somethings you have to think deeper into things, if you want better end results. Also I wish people STOP wondering about what the next person is doing when someone is telling you something that can be benefical to your well being. I mean if someone is doing something BOTH of you know can jus mess your life up tells you not to do it will you do it anyway knowing the end results are horrifying? That’s stupid, when you could have totally avioded that. But now your in a place that you know good and well you don’t want to be, all because you worrying about something that the person next to you is doing.

  • Negress

    Right is still right. Figure out a way to make it work before you get worked. There is nothing wrong with teaching girls to value themselves. If they can learn to be video girls…

  • http://www.facebook.com/ajakalilogan Aja Kali Laury

    I feel that they should be pledging to themselves, not their father, it always seemed kind of “weird” to me

  • Kimster

    So who is going to pledge to safe keep our young men and sons’ “purity of mind, body and soul” at these balls? It takes both genders to have premarital sex. The double standard in this practice is insulting at best.

  • Camille

    I always wondered about those who promise to wait to have sex until marriage. what if you never get married. they are making marriage seem like it is a concrete certain part of life. gives some girls an unattainable dream.

  • CarlaKah

    Protect your daughters by allowing them to be wise, well-informed and self-confident. Not this horse-shit.

    • Adrina

      Exactly

    • Guest1234

      zackly!

  • MLS2698

    Do the boys have pure balls? Um, let me rephrase that: Are boys required to stay ” pure” until marriage? No, I don’t agree with these ” balls”, and parents should have open discussions at home, rather than making a public spectacle/occasion that, if broken, makes the teen/woman feel extremely ashamed.

  • Kaine

    In some cases it may be solely for control, and in some cases it may not be. I actually saw this documentary where this picture is from. This father was genuinely concerned for his daughters well being. I agree that the way he shows his concern maybe a little controversial and rub people the wrong way, but with so many teen girls being knocked up, having abortions, and catching STD’s( especially in the black community),I can’t really blame this guy for going the extra mile to try and keep his daughters under lock.More fathers should be as active in there kids lives as this guy is. In this same documentary they featured a 13 year old who got pregnant and kicked out of her house.Smh. I heard that purity balls don’t really make a difference in waiting till marriage but i think they still send a positive message and help maintain high moral standards. However, if people still want to engage in purity balls they need to have it for boys as well. That would deter people from labeling it as sexist, and who knows maybe that will actually improve the numbers of participants actually waiting to have sex, if both males and females are taught the same values.

    • MLS2698

      Did the father state that he kept his virginity until marriage in that documentary ( dumb question, huh? cause I know he didn’t) Had the 13 yr old been to a purity ball?

      • Kaine

        How in the world would you possibly know whether he did or didn’t?Do you know him personally, and has he told you about his sex life? and they didn’t mention whether the 13 year old had a purity ball ( though I doubt it, cause it only makes sense to mention it). the documentary wasn’t solely about purity balls, it was a about teen girls and sex. The 13 year old they featured lived in Australia. They also featured teen girls in Cambodia who’s fathers build them “sex huts”, to ” entertain” neighborhood boys.

        • MLS2698

          Because that’s the point of this article: Men requesting that girls/ women remain pure, but not having a stance for themselves. I sense some anger…..are you a man? Obviously I didn’t see the documentary, and was asking out of curiosity. YOU SO SENSITIVE!

          • Kaine

            How am I being sensitive? Im not upset at all. You’re the one who seems to be getting bothered. You made a blanket assumption, so I questioned how you “knew” the things you claimed to know about this man. I saw the documentary so I have a different take on the issue. I clearly stated in my comment that If girls are asked to remain pure, so should boys….so im not really sure why you keep trying to make a point about men when I already agree with you. And I know you were being curious, that’s why I explained the rest of the documentary to you. So again, what’s up with all the assuming of me being angry, sensitive, and a man coming from???

            • MLS2698

              Hush, this is a blog. And I wasn’t looking for you to agree with me. How do the teen girls get knocked up? Never mind, must be a teen boy involved, too.Thanks for clearing that up.

              • Kaine

                Hush? please, and who are you to be telling anyone to hush with your childish attitude?lol. Exactly, it’s a blog, so stop crying when someone doesn’t back down from one of your replies. And you’re welcome, I have no problem clearing things up for people who have comprehension issues.

                • MLS2698

                  Yeah, you’re a man. My last comment got moderated. This is just in case it doesn’t show.

                  • Kaine

                    Lol. yea ok. sure…I’m a man, whatever you want to tell yourself to make yourself feel validated is fine with me.

  • C.Sheri

    Agree. I have 3 brothers and as the only girl, of course, I was told to abstain from sex until marriage while my brothers had girlfriends, children and all other kinds of drama associated with their sex lives. My father was quite the rolling stone as well…. So I’m trying to imagine my father, telling me that he will “Hold on ” to my virginity until I’m married. WTF?

  • IllyPhilly

    “The last image a young woman wants to have when losing her virginity is a vision of her father.” That just made my day.