Let’s Define “Unfaithful”: Is It Still Cheating If You’re Not Married?

July 26th, 2012 - By Alissa Henry
"Kristen and Robert"

Source: fanpop.com

When I was in high-school, I told my friend’s mom that I had just broken up with my boyfriend because he cheated on me.

I was stunned when she immediately rolled her eyes and said, “You kids. It’s not cheating if you’re not married.”

When the news of Kristen Stewart “cheating on” Robert Pattinson exploded in the news yesterday, I was reminded of that conversation,  described as a “shocking cheating scandal” the news coverage surrounding this couple has been absolutely hysterical and I just don’t get it.

The backstory is Kristen and Rob met on the set of the 2008 movie “Twilight”. “Twilight” is the first in a series of four vampire-themed fantasy romance movies. The two star in the movies as a couple and predictably became a couple in real-life.  Recently, Kristen starred in Snow White and the Huntsman. Last week a paparazzo snapped pictures of the 22-year-old making out with the movie’s 41-year-old director in a car. Us Weekly ran the story (and a picture) on their front page and, in a bizarre move, both Kristen and the director Rupert Sanders released a statement to People magazine admitting to the actions and apologizing. Rupert’s wife tweeted “Wow” before shutting down her social media accounts and Robert reportedly moved out of the apartment he shared with Kristen.

Twilight has an enormous fan base and many are clearly unable to separate “Robsten” from the “Bella and Edward” married couple they play in movies. But this isn’t about the strange fans who post four minute videos crying and screaming about the news or those who dramatically Tweet “#MyWholeLifeIsALie”. We already know that people put way too much emotional stock in celebrity relationships despite the less-than-stellar track record Hollywood has in the romance department.

The most bizarre thing of the coverage is the fact that Rupert Sanders’ marriage and consequent adultery seems to fall second to Kristen and Rob’s dating relationship and inevitable breakup.

I get that Kristen and Rob are the celebs here and therefore the only reason why Rupert’s philandering is news is because he was smooching Kristen. Still, I find it very strange that dating relationships and marriage are treated as one in the same despite them being very different — one decidedly less serious than the other.

In my estimation, what makes Kristen’s actions so egregious is not that she was probably bumping uglies with a guy other than the boyfriend she’s been shacking up with, but the fact that the man she was potentially having sex with is married with two kids. She released a statement apologizing to Robert, but it’s Liberty Ross, Rupert’s wife, who was the most wronged here. If Kristen is to be vilified it should be because she slept with another woman’s husband and not because she “cheated” on her boyfriend.

This marriage and dating equivocation seems par for the course in Hollywood especially considering that marriages in that town have the life span of a carton of milk. In fact, sometimes the celebrities will date without true commitment for a relatively long time. Look at Brad and Angelina. They’ve been dating much longer than he was married to Jennifer Aniston. The fake tweet Kanye West sent about dating Kim Kardashian longer than she was married to Kris Humphries was only believed to be sent by him because what was said was true.

It’s not just Hollywood though. Even we regular folk are playing marriage despite not being married at all. What some of us have found out the hard way is dating doesn’t imply any serious commitment whatsoever, neither does sex and neither does sharing an address. Marriage is marriage and dating is still dating.  Just because a couple is doing all the things that married couples do, they still can’t realistically expect the commitment that being married provides. It just doesn’t work that way. Though there’s a surplus of conversation about the “main chick” versus “side chick”, both are essentially the “nothing chick” as far as having “nothing” to indicate a promise of fidelity.

Does this mean people who call each other boyfriend and girlfriend should demand to be the only one he or she is sexting? That seems to be a reasonable expectation especially if one hopes that the relationship will lead to marriage. As one writer succinctly put it “a cheating boyfriend is a cheating fiancé and a cheating fiance is a cheating spouse”. A person’s propensity for lies and deceit that often go along with cheating in a dating relationship is a fairly good indicator of his or her propensity for lies, deceit and cheating in a marriage.

Still, since I’ve gotten married, I understand where my friend’s mother is coming from. Marriage is so much more serious than deciding to exclusively date a person and should be treated as such in every single way. In a dating relationship, a person is expected to be faithful solely because he or she wants to be, whereas in a marriage, a person is expected to be faithful because they’ve made a commitment to be faithful whether they want to or not. People are out here moving in together, having indiscriminate and unprotected sex, moving across the country, creating kids — all in relationships where neither person has committed to be there past next Tuesday. When these relationships meet their inevitable demise, others are shocked as though a relationship confirmed on Facebook means anything past the next second.

I think we would do better to put the emphasis on fidelity where emphasis is warranted: marriage. And, in turn, treat dating relationships like the fickle, irresolute relationships they are because dating and marriage are not nearly the same.

What do you think? Do you think it’s still cheating even if you’re not married? Do you think people equate dating with marriage?

Follow Alissa on Twitter @AlissaInPink

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • http://www.facebook.com/demetrie.oatis Demetrie Oatis

    This article isvbullshit!

    Sovyou mean to tell me that I have to hurry up and Marry this person so they will not cheat on me?

    What happens if that person still does it in our Marriage?

    See my point, the marriav license won’t change anything quick, which is why couples have an exclusive relationship before marriage as a buildup until they decide to be with each other forever.

    Also, half of the Marriages these days are fake, while their are couples out their that are not Married yet but are truly commited to eachother to the point where they should Marry each other.

    This article waz made to make an excuse that people can cheat on eachvothe, jist like tv showz like Desperate Housewives that make it okay that a Wife or Husband can cheat on their spouse.

  • V

    I think, whether you´ve signed something or not, if you say you´re going to behave a certain way and then you don´t, that´s dishonest. Maybe it´s not adultery, because that happens when you´re married, but its is cheating. Not being married gives you the flexibility of saying “well, its been fun” and then moving on without paperwork. It doesn´t make lying respectable.

  • DoinMe

    This article is badly flawed and lacks logic. Based on the author’s view, cheating is fine while dating, but once the papers are signed, cheating is off limits. Really? I wonder if her husband was a cheater while they were dating. If so, a piece of paper won’t change his behavior.

  • guest

    The premise of this article is ridiculous. There are plenty of people in committed relationships who aren’t married. You should be faithful to your partner whether you are married or not. A cheating boyfriend is a cheating husband.

  • Miss D

    With the author’s logic….everyone is free to screw around till they get married. Then it’s time to settle down. Advice Fail.

  • http://twitter.com/llora1000 HairByLlora

    NO its not Cheating. I don’t know why people always want to ‘flap their gums’ eveytime someone they “love” goes off with someone else. If you don’t have an agreement in church its not cheating. Be careless with your life all you want, get a baby, an std etc before marriage but don’t say you got cheated on cos that make you sound very dumb & disorganized. Commitment is between 2 people, not one; so think twice about your relationship. TAKE IT TO CHURCH with lots of people watching lol….

    • http://twitter.com/vashtikk11 ♥♡PURE ESTROGEN♡♥

      They think married people are bad, but the people in “committed relationships” are screwing around MORE! lol

      • http://twitter.com/llora1000 HairByLlora

        All I know is a leagal doc asks if you are single or married Mr,Mrs,or Miss proof that a “committed relationship” is insignificant!

        • http://twitter.com/vashtikk11 ♥♡PURE ESTROGEN♡♥

          I think they ask about Civil Unions and Domestic Partnerships now…don’t quote me on that. lol

    • Miss Anonymous

      I agree, so many do the crying and boo hooing of ” I loved him, gave him 3 kids, sexed him when he wanted and I even didnt bring marriage up, how come he went and married the new chick after all I done for him. I should be his wife”. Yeah it hurts when your in a relationship with someone and they give you your walking papers, but technically yall dont have to divide your assets and the like like you do with marriage.

  • Rhonda Chambers

    I can’t believe the writer would make so light of dating someone. How a man treats you during your courtship, is a firm indicator of what he might be like as a husband. I don’t date casually and I make it clear i’m looking for a life partner not a good time. People should stop dating without a purpose. It only leads to unwanted pregnancies, fatherless children, and diseases being spread.

  • Pingback: You’re Still Single Until You Get Married, True? | Married 2 The Blog Presented By BlogXilla

  • Chris

    This is stupid nonsense. A marriage is not the only form of commitment. The author of this article is obviously someone for whom the word commitment has a very loose meaning. SMH with Disgust. Of course someone can be cheated on outside of marriage!! What kind of nonsensical argument is this???

  • Darcampb

    Wow! The author is a condescending idiot. Yes, sweetie , other people’s relationships are legitimate even without a ring. What in the world ?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Cristina-Okotte/100002169431801 Cristina Okotte

    I think ….she is 22 y/o !that’s all

  • IllyPhilly

    I thought they were married? Robsten as you called it.

  • trina

    As far as relationships go, this will always be debatable. I, apart from the majority, believe that it is not cheating if your dating. We always hear of who got married and divorced in the media and it is made into a big deal. When people are dating, you hear about their breakup for a minute and then it’s on to the next one. WHATEVER! Blah, blah, blah… JMO. Liked the article.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JAI4SRENU2A5WKRTELXXYJPDSI Kayla

    What kind of question is that? Of course it’s cheating !!

  • Pivyque

    Well…I get your point, but I think it is betrayal either way. I will admit that I take my marriage more seriously than I have ever taken a dating relationship. For example, if my husband gets a job in japan or something, I would go..no questions. Dating? Even long term with the same love there..no thanks. We can break up or do long distance lol But in regards to cheating…I agree with one of the other posts about it being cheating when you are single and adultery once you are married…same feelings, different name.

    • http://www.facebook.com/demetrie.oatis Demetrie Oatis

      I know people myselfvthat are Married and have some one that are overseas due to job duties.

      Especially in the military.

  • FromUR2UB

    Well, it hurts the same whether married or not. It’s the lying and deception that makes it cheating, in either case. You still feel stupid for having believed what you learned were lies. A single person who dates two people, who know the relationslhip isn’t exclusive, is not cheating. But, if one of those people has been lead to believe the realtionship is exclusive, if he/she has been lied to about the other person’s whereabouts, it’s cheating…gaining an unfair advantage.

  • Lovelorn

    I believe that cheating is cheating whether it be in dating, marriage or engagement. Essentially, the whole point of dating is to practice being married. How would someone really be able to go from just dating this and that person or sleeping with this and that person to waking up one day and saying “I want to be married” without knowing what monogamy is? I find that to be crazy…