Is Toni Braxton The Next New “American Idol” Judge?

July 26th, 2012 - By Brande Victorian

Source: Zimbio.com

Here in the office we’ve been talking about who else “American Idol” needs to give a job to with those vacant judge spots and Toni Braxton was definitely one of the names that came up. According to Sister 2 Sister and an inside source, that could actually be happening.

“An insider who works for Simon Cowell claims producers were less than discreet when discussing the newest addition to the judging panel and plans to add Toni were overheard,” the site said.

The news has yet to be confirmed but the source made this statement:

“When I overheard the producers during a candid conversation regarding having two Black, female judges for the first in the history of the show, I almost jumped out of my skin. To add to what was already internal pandemonium, I overheard them say that Toni Braxton was replacing Steven Tyler.”

Two black ladies and two judges who can actually sang? “Idol” is not playing with the competition next season. This news could be really good for Toni. She clearly wants to establish herself outside of her sisters again and since they’ve gained fame on their own from the “Braxton Family Values” reality show, they’ll be fine without her. Toni also has plans to drop another CD, so “American Idol” exposure could do wonders for a revival of her career. And did I mention she also actually has talent? With her and Mariah on the judging panel, this could be a monumental season. The only thing is two divas behind one small desk could get testy.

What do you think? Would Toni be a good “American Idol” judge?

Brande Victorian is the news and operations editor for madamenoire.com. Follow her on twitter @Be_Vic.

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • CA Pullen

    I think it would be great. As long as she is straight up and tell the one who don’t have the talent that they can’t sing. I hope that she and Mariah Carey are not like Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler sugar coat it and tell people that they sound good when they actually don’t. I say put Re Re Franklin (Aretha) on the show for a judge.

  • jaimuziq

    Tamar would be so jealous lol

  • Guess

    Yes the rating will go up then. Great Singer on top of it. I was at the point of not watching next season, but two good singers. Yes. Now who for the third judge Hummmm! Got to be a good Male singer NO JACKSON . Please don’t mess up the flow.

  • anonymous

    Three Black judges on the show? I’ll believe it when I see it!

    • guess

      Third one got to a seasoned Male singer.

  • Snapps izking

    Wow, what a combination to have both Toni Braxton and Mariah
    Carey on American Idol with Randy Jackson. This will make me more excited to
    get down to season 12 and watch two of my favorite singers on a great show I’ve
    watched for a few years. I love to watch AI and other primetime recordings on
    my Hopper, and now I can do it commercial free. I love the Auto Hop feature,
    which lets you skip all those annoying TV commercials. I work in the evening
    and record all my PrimeTime Anytime shows while I work, so I can view them a
    day or two later. By doing so I have the option to watch or skip commercials
    with the touch of a button. One of my coworkers at Dish showed me how this
    feature worked before I tried it out at home.
    All I have to do is select enable and the Hopper lets me watch
    commercial free TV. This will keep me from having to replace my batteries in my
    remote often.

  • Liv

    I think she’d be GREATTT!!!! I would watch

  • cleojonesin

    I watched this past season (after not watching for years) and those kids could SANG! I felt bad for poor Jennifer trying to ‘critique’ them. Toni would be great, i love her!

  • SayWhat!

    That would be great and I believe she would hold no punches and be honest! There ratings could go back up if this happens.

  • Yamini

    I hope this is true. I haven’t watched this show for a long time now but I would tune in for this…

  • LoveLi

    I don’t think I’ve watched since Ruben or Fantasia, but they would defnitely have me if they got both Toni and Mariah

  • olivia

    That would get me to watch…two people that can actually sing.