Interfaith Relationships: Could You Marry Someone Of A Completely Different Faith?

July 31st, 2012 - By Stephanie Guerilus

Source: timescrest.com

Religion is one of those subjects that is often avoided in conversation in order to keep the peace. However, when it comes to relationships and families, sometimes a firewall of tolerance just isn’t strong enough to stand.

For most people, the God they serve and their faith, is at the core of their essence. I’m not any different. My mom is Baptist and my Dad is a Jehovah’s Witness. I was raised as a believer of Jesus Christ. I respect my father’s way of life and have even tolerated some of his attempts to convert me, but my heart has never been swayed. Although, my aunt believes that I don’t go to church as much as I should. She tells me all the time that church is the perfect place for me to meet a husband. Okay auntie…But hey, birds of a feather do flock together, however, interfaith relationships are becoming commonplace. More and more are marrying individuals of religious backgrounds that differ from their own.

Love has a way of overcoming obstacles. It can cover the many challenges that religion creates. Since marriage is about two people becoming one, compromise is already ingrained in the dynamics. When there is love, you find a way to make it all work. Each person gives and takes a little bit. Taye Diggs, who identifies as a Christian, married Idina Menzel who is Jewish. He has stated that he hopes to allow his son to see both of what their beliefs offer so that he can choose for himself:

“These days, thank God, people are a little bit more accepting and people’s views are broadening and it’s not as accepted to just choose one, how you might have been forced to in the past. I think it depends on the parents’ perspective and how they feel about those issues and how they kind of want to pass that down to their child. As proud as I am of my blackness, I think it’s important to show Walker that he should be just as proud of his Jewish mother and all of the culture that that includes as well.”

But, there comes a point when the fundamental differences between two people create a wall. It becomes a war and one side has to lose because there’s no more room left for compromise, and that usually happens when it comes to what the religious beliefs of the children will be, or when one side wants their spouse to convert. While Diggs for now seems to think having both religious beliefs of being of Jewish faith and Christian faith will benefit his child (and luckily, his wife wasn’t pushed to share his beliefs), other people don’t fare so well. Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes reportedly broke up because she didn’t want their 6-year-old daughter, Suri, further subjected to the tenets of Scientology. Katie was raised a Catholic and converted for a few years, but as time went on, she affirmed her prior faith. She recently claimed membership at a Catholic church and enrolled her daughter in a school that practices the faith.

Katie’s not the only one who has had second thoughts about losing themselves in another religion in order to please a partner, but that’s not to say that interfaith relationships are doomed from the start. If two people are committed to reconciling their strong opinions about God and how their respective faiths should work in their lives, more power to them. But as an absolute authority on Stephanie (that’s me of course), I’d prefer to be equally yoked with my significant other. Love is enough of a battlefield and a divided house will easily fall apart.

Could you marry someone of a different faith?

Stephanie Guerilus is a multimedia journalist and author. Follow her @qsteph

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Smara

    That depends on how you view religion.

    If it’s like a hobby to you, or something you “do” a few days in a year, then yeah, why not?

    But anyone that follows a religion that they TRUELY and whole-heartedly believe is the ONLY way to get to heaven or paradise or eternal bliss or chocolate island, then no, dating/marrying outside of ones religion is a bad move to make.

    Christian perspective: We’re taught that a life without the acceptance of Christ will end in ETERNAL hell fire. We’re also taught that marriage isn’t until death, it is for all eternity.

    So anyone that calls themselves a Christian, shouldn’t be able to, in good conscience, go to sleep next to a muslim or whatever, that they claim to love but be okay with the fact that that person will spend eternity in misery.

    They honestly, would spend the entire duration of the relationship in evangelism mode, tryna save their spouse’s soul. Which, of course, would only damage the marriage.

    You can’t have your cake and eat it. Either you don’t COMPLETELY believe in your religion, or you don’t truly love that person if you don’t put pressure on them to convert.

    “No, I just respect their decision to worship differently” some may say.
    And to that I say: respect goes out of the window if you truly believe eternal pain in a definite consequence, especially when we’re talking about someone you claim to love. (Again, key words: truly believe).

    The people that can make inter religious relationships work are functioning agnostics; The people with religious affiliations (mostly because of how they were raised), that occasionally visit the church, mosque, or synagogue, but have no significant activity or investment into the faith.

    That’s not even to mention what happens to the kids.

    If you disagree, you might be one of those functioning agnostics or a hopeless romantic.

  • La-Di-Da

    In my experience it didn’t even work just dating someone of a different faith than me. We disagreed on so many moral issues because my source was the Bible and his was something completely different. I can’t even imagine how rocky it would have been had we gotten married, and even more so if we had children with him telling them one thing while I say another. A marriage should be built on a solid foundation, and while you don’t have to literally agree on everything, faith and morals are not a good area to have opposing views.

  • Pingback: Interfaith Relationships: Could You Marry Someone Of A Completely Different Faith? | 93.1 WZAK

  • Is It 5:00 Yet?

    Nope. Marriage will already have it’s difficulties and there is no need to have an unnecessary stress added to a marriage.

  • ThisChick

    Nope. “Do not be unequally yoked with unbelievers. For what partnership has righteousness with lawlessness? Or what fellowship has light with darkness?”- 2 Corinthians 6:14
    #JS

    • Is It 5:00 Yet?

      I agree.

    • Na Na

      Unbelievers of what? Do people of other religions not believe in God? We’re talking about faith bearing people, not atheists or Devil worshipers.

  • A.J.

    This is an excellent article, and one that begs serious consideration in this day and age. While I do believe that true love can overcome any obstacles, but one’s religious faith is something that cannot be ignored as just another minor thing. As a Christian, I could not see myself getting married to a man that doesn’t share my faith. Likewise, I would want our children to grow up under one faith as well. It’s not just the unequally yoked thing, it comes down to a basic understanding, respect, and compatibility that two people from the same faith have. And I don’t think that anyone should be considered a snob or exclusionary if they say that they only want to marry someone within their faith, whatever they believe.

  • victoria

    I married a man of a different race, but I will not marry a man of a different religion. For me it’s important that my kids are raised knowing the truth that Christ is Lord. I dont want them doubting that because daddy believes something else.

    • A.J.

      True. I believe that there is nothing wrong with people of different races marrying, as long as they share the same faith.

  • http://www.facebook.com/pepita.rodriquez Pepita Rodriquez

    It depends on the religion, some people belong to a faith but do not practice it so in that case it would be a non-issue for me. But I would say, I would be weary of marrying a strict Muslim man or a Hindu or Spiritual Baptist or Jew. They have practices that i am uncomfortable with. If my Muslim husband suddenly says he wants a second and third wife I would not be cool with that at all.

  • realadulttalk

    I think I could marry someone of a different religion…but it would depend on the religion. I am a Christian and need that person to be as well. Relationships are hard enough…religion is a hard one to not be on the same page. Plus, my father would be an issue…he’s a pastor…that could get very ugly.

  • Nope

    People of the same faith cant always make relationships work. Don’t see why one’s faith needs to be another excuse.

    • Sheena

      Good observation.

  • Nope

    Just some food for thought but most Christians know less about their own religion than Jews, Muslims, Atheists, etc.know about their respective religions. Hell, they know more about Christianity that Christians. Yet many Christians seem to be the most adamnant about being equally yoked. You mean equally ignorant about the history and theological understanding (not the School House Rocks version you probably get on Sunday…) of what you think you believe?

    • realadulttalk

      Really now…that seems a pretty blanket statement. What I find amusing is that you named religions that have a “cultural” but not necessarily “religious” following.

      • Nope

        There are plenty of studies on the ignorance most Christians have of their own religion as opposed to the knowledge others have of their own beliefs. I’ll give you that as far as cultural vs religious. I guess one caveat is that for Blacks in particular I’d argue that Christianity is cultural.

    • victoria

      Yes, too many Christians dont know the Bible. But we do know that Jesus is Lord and died for our sins. And that all will kneel before HIM. One thing ALL people have in common is that Jesus is our Lord whether you accept that or not.

  • http://www.facebook.com/ebony.rouse2 Ebony Rouse

    I am a christian and my other half is muslim and we have been thou a lot its has been 12 yrs now and we have talk at the beginning of the relationship that we won’t pressure one another to convert but his side of the family is just now starting him to pressure me into converting I have looked at and understand but I have been a christian all my life and find it kinda difficult to convert a same as for him but I I do want to look into this new age muslim……Idk I guess we will cross that road when we get there

    • Na Na

      As a Muslim man marrying a woman of another Faith, it isn’t necessary that she convert. This might not be the place but what type of issues do you guys face? I am Muslim and my significant other is Christian so to speak, although from us being together he is finding more out about what it actually means to be a Christian, but what types of issues? Like around Christmas time and stuff?

  • sabrina

    GIRRRRRL!!! Me and my friends have this discussion ALL THE TIME! I would honestly have to say no, because I’m firm about having a Christian husband. That will make everything much easier…the trials and tribulations and everything else that comes with marriage. Plus, I feel we’ll be even more connected because we’ll be on the same level spiritually…which is essentially what I want in any partner.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/FTHIDMNTLTJAIILXEWRQ3UADBY StephanieR

    No!

  • Angel

    Nope. Im Christian and imo it only makes sense to marry one.

  • Na Na

    Good article. I am Muslim, I believe there is One God….that’s it. 4 years ago I began my first relationship with a man who practices Christianity. That did not work at all! We were both trying to prove to the other that our way of life was better. FAst forward 4 years and I am in a relationship with a man who identifies himself as Christian, however both of our belief is that we pray to and believe in One God, and we take the teachings of Jesus and all the Prophets and apply them to our lives. Its pretty simple once you reach a certain level of personal understanding. I know my faith is all my own and I don’t have to prove to anyone how wonderful my God is, I just live my life and let it be an example of how good things can be when you are just a good person. I think the term “religion” has us all mixed up and gang banging for a similar belief that we all share. By the way, I was raised in a Christian household and have been practicing Islamic traditions for 7 years now so I am very familiar with both sides of the fence.

    • guest

      That’s good seeing people of two different faiths making it work. However, it’s one thing to date, it’s something completely different to marry and have kids and still trying to maintain that balance,because usually parents want to raise their kids up in their own faith. But I’ve heard that some people can make it work.