The Blackest Eye: Tales of the Light Skinned Girl Who Wanted to Be Darker

July 10th, 2012 - By Veronica Wells

Source: blacklifecoaches.net

Just like most girls, I grew up thinking, and I still believe today, that my mother is gorgeous. I used to watch her shimmy into sequined dresses when she and my dad would go out dancing. Or I’d gaze at her as she prepared herself for church after my sister and I, with our scarf-tied heads, were already dressed. It was amazing to see this woman subtly, artfully and meticulously enhance her genetic beauty with the aid of makeup. My mother’s beauty, which is both external and internal, was all the more alluring because of her coffee bean brown skin.

My father, who is significantly lighter, praised her for it, her lipstick always complemented it and acne was no match for it. People always told me I resembled her. And though, I could see that we didn’t share the exact same complexion, I knew I wasn’t too far off. Apparently, other people didn’t see it that way. I think I was in the third grade, the first time a friend referred to me as “light-skinned.” While there are still some girls and grown women who would have taken such an assertion, as a compliment, I was shocked, and honestly, slightly offended. There is nothing wrong with being lighter complected but that wasn’t me. I was at least brown, not too many shades away from my mother. As the years went on, the light skin references increased and as I learned more and more about the cultural celebration of lighter skin, so did my frustration. How could anyone assert that “light was right” when I was living with a woman who contradicted the notion everyday? Ridiculous. It was poet, Jessica Care Moore, that expressed my sentiments best when she said, “Even the light skin girls are sick of the light skin girls.”

At some point or another I expressed my frustration to my family members. There was no need to discuss the notion that light was somehow better. That was an absurdity we’d dismissed long ago; but they did find it surprisingly comical that I considered myself to be just a couple of shades away from my mother on the color spectrum. From then on my sister, who is truly just a few shades darker than me, my mother and my younger cousin joked, good-naturedly, about my complexion. They joked that since I was determined to call myself brown, I didn’t know myself. They’d find the lightest black person in the room and ask if we were related. They called me “light bright,” just to work my nerves.

It was  just jokes for them but the quest for brown skin is real for me. Every year, I yearn for summer so I can get outside and pick up a few more shades. I told a guy I was involved with, that though he was kinda light, if we ever had babies, they could still be brown-skinned because my mother and his father have the coveted complexion. I thought I was one of the few women who wanted “happy brown babies,” until I read Demetria Lucas’ “A Belle in Brooklyn,” in which she wrote about the collective [non-ignorant] light skinned girl’s desire to have brown kids. It’s real out here.

At a recent family gathering, I was explaining to an older cousin, who told me to call her Aunt, that I was wearing East African Fulani earrings, that I live in Harlem and write for a black women’s website. After all that she said, sincerely, “Oh, you’re real black.” I offered her a very satisfied smile and nodded. I have to admit though, that later I questioned myself a little bit.  Was I “so black” because I was trying to prove that I was “so black”? Eventually I dismissed that potentially treacherous train of thought. There are plenty of ways to be “so black.”

This past weekend in New Orleans, I interviewed a makeup artist about black women and what we need to know about makeup. He told me what’s tricky about black women is that we have nearly 170 different skin tones, compared to the white woman’s 4. He said it was all about the undertones black women possess. Some of us have red, yellow or gold undertones.

That undertone word, set me off. Here was my chance to ask a professional about the skin I’m in and finally get a real, legit answer. In a self-serving move, I asked him, “So, what type of undertones would you say I have?”

“Look like you have a yellow undertone.”

Damn.

That’s cool. Even though I’ll probably always envy admire the mahogany looking sister, my mom’s coffee bean brown and girls named Ebony, I recognize that my black is still real, even if it has a little yellow in it.

More on Madame Noire!

 

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Dave

    I’m very surpised a lot of african americans talk like being dark skin is such a curse no a days. When I was growing up aa girls would tell me my skin was too dark or I would better looking if my skin was lighter.

  • ana

    my dad is native american and has dark brown skin. i have an olive skin tone, and i always wish i’m as dark as him.

  • Kristina Tramel

    I never wanted to be any darker or lighter than I am now. I grew up in a family with all types of skin tones and I was never raised to think I was better than darker skinned people and my brother(even lighter than me) was never treated better from being lighter.

  • SMDH

    Also, I want to say that the people who imo have the worst complex are brown skinned women lol. At least my bestie makes ya’ll look bad. She is the lightest one in her household. she’s literally the color of peanut butter. she wears makeup that makes her look lighter. It’s fighting words if you tell her she’s dark skinned. she never sits in the sun. and she made sure she had kids by a light skinned man so that her kids wouldnt be dark but it didnt work because two out of her 4 kids are dark skinned considering her family is darkskinned. she actually only has one light skinned kid and the other is brown but the majority of her children are dark (God works in mysterious ways)! I think she never felt light enough for whatever reason but feels she gets a pass because she’s not super dark. Pray for her my fellow mn peeps bc she needs it. all this light skin verse dark skin is stupid we have enough problems trying to be accepted in white America without creating our own version of discrimination.

    • chanela

      right! i know someone who is pretty much heading down that path. she is mixed and got with another mixed man and it makes me so angry how whenever my other friend and her man comes around (hes african) he is the butt of their every joke. everything about africa is hilarious to them. they think dreads and nappy hair are the nastiest things ever (they both have very long and wavy hair)

      the girl even told me once “i saw this latino chick with short nappy hair. i was so surprised that my hair was better than hers when she is latino!” i instantly became sick to my stomach.

  • Jas

    Love this. I felt the same way.

  • Msmykimoto2u

    Lovely article =)

  • Candacey Doris

    I still wish i was as dark as my mother. She has a great skin tone, just lighter than Alek Wek. No wrinkles, great in any color and perfectly even at 50 i can only hope my skin holds up as well. I’m not dark or light, I’m always just sort of in between. When looking for makeup it’s a hassle to fin the right shade and even a little demoralizing. But i’ve never tried to be more black or white. It’s not worth it trying to be someone you’re not.

  • sammi_lu

    My daughter who is a lighter shade of me beams when anyone says that she is my spitting image.. I heard one of her friends the other day tell her jokingly that people would believe that she was my daughter before they would my daughter because is so “light skinned”. Just a few days later my daughter randomly said she wished she were darker like me. I told her of course she is perfect just the way she is..I couldn’t help but feel I should have added something else to my comment to ease her mind because I knew where it was coming from. However, I didn’t feel like getting that heavy into a conversation that is so irrelevant and divisive with a very impressionable 10 yr old so I stuck a pin it and decided I’d have to think about this from both sides of the debate before going that road.

  • kay

    My bf of ten years told me a few years ago about “light skinned girl issues.” I had no idea because I am brown and I’ve always been looked over if I was with my light skinned friends. My bf told me that light skin women are treated differently and they have their own struggles. She was so happy when her daughter came out brown skin. She didn’t want her daughter to go through what she went through.

  • Realgirl

    the problem with having lighter skin is that people assume that you are stuck up or think you are better than everyone…they just have no clue that those stigmas HURT and are far from the truth. I was like you, couldn’t wait until summer so I could get a tan, but then I often wonder if I was darker, would I then have wished I was lighter. and the issues with color within our communities continues……

  • Chocolat Sucre’

    I am a dark-skinned woman and my mother has fair skin. My father is very dark skinned (just to give you some background). I’ve never envied lighter skinned women or spoke down to them because just as I don’t want them to judge me based on my complexion, I’m not going to judge them based on theirs. I love my skin, and I love my friends and family members skin color (whatever shade it is)
    ! My mother taught me at a young age that I was beautiful, regardless of the complexion. I’ve heard my share of jokes due to my shade and I also have light skinned friends who face exclusion because they weren’t black enough. I think its sad on both accounts but the thing to understand is that you can’t let someone else’s ignorance affect your esteem. The debate on complexions will continually go one because everyone wants to pick a side as opposed to focusing on the true issue, which is self-esteem and insecurity. If we get those in check then the debate will cease because no one will have to “prove” anything to anyone.

  • http://twitter.com/sabadaga SANDRA

    it’s so sad to see so much hatred between us. Black men who hate black women, darksin who hate lightskin people, african who hate other blacks and so on. We love being hateful people SMH

  • ms.leaseONlife

    We can argue thé infomus skin conplexion fude that has hunted the black community for years…. But it will still go back to saying that wé always Want what wé dont have because wé ulimately feel that wé will be better off with it butthe truth is……..everything you go through Wright now you will go through no matter what color you are ( IT’S DESTINY….AND THAT’S What builds character….4rm a beautiful Browning sista…..

  • NikkitaMichelle

    We all have friends of darker complexions who shy away from the sun because “they don’t want to get black.” Uhh we’re black people. Or they don’t want to date dark men because they didn’t want dark children. Uhh the Lord works in mysterious ways there’s no guarantees your children will be light. Or my friends will say that I have the standard of beauty because I’m light. (So we’re ignoring the fact the the majority of the super models out there are not light skinned (Iman, Naomi, Beverly Peele, Alec Wek, etc.) I’ve been teased about my shade or lack there of my entire life. “Light bright damn near white.” “High yellow hefer.” “Red bone no yellow bone.” It goes on and on. I would prefer to be darker, but that’s not how God made me.

  • Pivyque

    I’m glad someone said it. I have always wanted Kelly Rowland’s or Gabrielle Union’s skin tone. It is so beautiful to me. My mother’s side of the family is very light and my father’s side is a nice mixture, but I didn’t get that. I’ve learned to accept my color over the years, mostly because of my husband tho. He’s always told me that God didn’t create me with their tone because he knew I wouldn’t know how to act lol

  • Eternal

    I can’t identify with the story (since I’m a fab shade of brown) but my sister, mother and best friend are all “yellow” (their word) and all want to be browner.

    I don’t get the impression that the writer wants to seem like she’s a victim, no where does she indicate that her life was worse for being lighter than her mom.

    Rather, she’s talking about her standard of beauty, which is based off of her mother. For most women this is our standard of beauty. We learn how to style our hair, wear make up and fashion sense from our mothers. Whether we follow our mothers’ lead or deflect completely from her sense of beauty, that is where we learn how to beautify ourselves.

    I’m shocked at the comments, it makes me wonder if some people even read the story before commenting.

  • Ash

    My mom said to me one day, “You’re lucky you only have strikes against as a woman in the workforce”. When I asked her what she was talking about, she told me that it’s harder to get a job if you are: a woman, a minority, overweight/obese, dark-skinned, and single parent.

  • Ash

    I don’t like the fact that if I’m outside for 15 minutes, I get a tan. Maybe I’m being sensitive or overdramatic, but I also get very annoyed when people ask if I’m biracial. Trust me, if I get my hair wet, I’ll have a Don King afro.

  • monitorette

    Hi Ms Wells, I’m a reader from France who has happily discovered Madame noire through surfing on the net.
    I personally do not define you as a light skin person. You are as brown as my friends from Cameroun or from the Ivory Coast.
    To me there are dark skin tones, brown skin tones and then light skin tones.

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]