Helping or Hurting? Why I Decided To Stop Giving Relationship Advice To My Girlfriends

June 25th, 2012 - By Marissa Ellis

Men often say that women giving relationship advice to other women is like the blind leading the blind. Although I don’t totally agree, I do understand.

Over a ten year period, I went from being the girl who analyzed, supported, and offered plentiful advice to girlfriends who were caught up in crazy relationships and the girl who spoke freely about her own relationship TO the friend who listened quietly, and who in turn started guarding the details of her own relationship.

Before entering the world of dating, I had pre-conceived notions, like my fellow girlfriends, as to how that new world of romance would work. I remember watching daytime talk shows with my mother when I was in junior high and seeing woman talk about escaping domestic abuse situations and wondering…why the hell were they in the situation in the first place. If someone, disrespects you, you would leave. If someone treats you less than the wonderful Queen that you are, you find someone who would, right? It all seemed so simple then.

Slowly but surely(but more so slowly), I came to understand that the reality was much more complicated.

In the early post-college years of dating life,  my girlfriends and I advised each other on men who were not treating us well enough, men who didn’t care us about enough, men who cheated, and men who were simply not worthy of our stellar attributes. I thought it was the right thing to do to sound off when I thought a friend of mine was selling herself short. But the more encounters that I experienced that warranted that advice, the more I realized that it was the same girl who was on the receiving end. Some of my friends learned their lessons and vastly improved their lot in the dating game but a substantial amount did not.

My friend Serena (name changed obviously) knew she suffered from low expectations, but even with that realization she still got into relationships with men who were lukewarm about her and who did little to win her over, while she doted on them and went the extra mile to keep them content. By the time we hit our 30s, I knew I could no longer continue giving her advice; if I did, I risked sacrificing our friendship.

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Kells

    I have a friend that when I give her the most sincere and honest advice she tries to turn the same advice around on me when I am in a not so even similar situation. I find myself asking why keep coming back to me with the same issues if you don’t like my responses. Needless to say I am just about good on her b/c I feel like sets herself up for relationship failures and now it seems like she doesn’t want to see me happy in realtionships b/c she isn’t in a happy relationship.. How else can I take her responses when I go to het with my own issues?

  • Na Na

    I have this situation as my friend is almost 30 and desperate to have a baby. The guy she is dating has minimal employment, irritates her and they fight constantly. So when she calls me saying she hopes her period doesn’t come or what do I think about her and so an so purposely trying to get pregnant im at a loss for words. Thanks for this article because Im tired of dancing around some very obvious issues.

  • Linda

    I think it’s more of a bad idea than a good thing. Often times, my friends have Hell getting a man’s attention for anything more than just sex. You can tell them the truth, but they can turn on you.

  • Pivyque

    I get your point. I usually don’t give advice to close friends. I ask them questions that guide them to the point that I am trying to make. I have always been the type to keep things (good and bad) to myself unless there was a point to be made to help the person I was telling. I can say the only person I give advice to is my sister, because no matter how she tries to flip it, the guy is not worth it. I have seen it with my own eyes lol I won’t push it because she is grown, but when she asks….I tell her exactly what I think!

  • mz_chocolatina

    To many people involved in your relationSHIP and it will sink. .

  • Guest360

    Giving advice is fine but it’s imperative to not let that advice drive how your friends’ relationships go i.e. the “Girl you need to leave him” or the “Go ‘head and marry him before someone else does” type of advice. I too have had problems with my girlfriends when it comes to situations like this and I had to back off a bit and let them do what they wanted to do. As a girlfriend, it is your duty to listen and support so do that, whether you like the guy or not.

  • IllyPhilly

    It’s hard not to give advice, but DON’T. I have tried to help so many friends and all it did was backfire.

  • Miss_Understood

    I can definitely relate. My friends have always came to me for advice and support (although, not always reciprocated) and when I was younger I would just agree with them because I figured that’s what they needed and did not want to be disloyal.

    Anyway, as I got older, I realized that if someone is mature enough to ask for the truth-they should be mature enough to handle it. I just make all efforts not to seem judgemental. Also, I am careful about the way give feedback ie “I understand why you would think that”, “I know it’s always easier said than done” and “if I were in this situation, I would probably feel/react similarly”. My friends who are mature may not agree with me but they appreciate my honesty because they know that I honestly care…

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]