Should I Have Given Him an Ultimatum? I Told My Boyfriend What I Wanted and He Left

June 12th, 2012 - By madamenoire

From HelloBeautiful.com

Dear Gay Best Friend,

Eight months ago I began dating the boy, because he is far from a man, that I absolutely loved in high school. His friends were my friends and they decided to hook us up. We never went on an official date, never had the honeymoon phase of the “relationship,” and I never understood that those were stages that most people had when beginning a relationship because I’d never had a “real” one without cheating.

Time rolls by, he would call every Saturday, and I liked that. We both worked throughout the week, so I didn’t mind him not calling or text throughout. When we hit the “relationship” stage I had to ask if we were a couple. When Friday night came around I would have to ask did he want to do anything with me.

Now, let me describe him for you. He was thirty years old. He lived at home with his mama. I could understand that because I live at home too because of student loans. But, he lived at home because his ex put him out. I didn’t know the story at the time and continued to TRY to see the good in him when I found out.

He did not have a car!!! I thought it was because of his wreck he had, which turned out to be a DUI and he had a suspended license. I still stayed.

He was a horrible boyfriend! We never went out period, unless drinking was involved. I would text him, no reply. Then I would stop texting he would say, “What’s wrong with you, haven’t heard from you in a while.” I got to the point where I started cheating, I didn’t sleep with any of them, and doing things alone or with other people, then he would call and text a billion times “What you doing?” I would tell him the truth, because I would ask him first to do the things with me.

I stopped cheating on him and about the fourth month we began to have sex. Can you say, WTH!!!! I thought it was my fault that the sex was bad, but um…no! I still stayed because when we did see each other, (sometimes once a week even a month and we stayed five minutes away from each other) we would be great. He started off saying he loved me and I was a deer in head lights. I would say it back but not mean it in that type of way. My family was going through deaths and sickness, and you would think you could call and rely on your man. Child please!!!. He would be fishing and playing basketball with his friends.

To sum all this nonsense up: He was broke. Never spent time with me unless we were drinking, always with his friends, and when I say always I mean 6 days out the week, you knew it rained the seventh day because he would be at home. He drunk too much, lied about what days he worked and didn’t work.

I finally woke up the eighth month and give him a list of choices, and when I say list I mean typed and copied and handed it to him. Choice one: Break up. Choice two: Get serious about us. Choice three: Stay the way we are and I will cheat and you don’t get that privilege because you are happy being unhappy. He decided to stop speaking to me. Meaning he cussed and fussed to his friends and completely avoided me. My friend said I had the right to do it but I need to sit down and talk with him to see if we could work it out. I think she’s dumb because she’s taking care of a sorry nergo and always crying.

My question to you, am I wrong for caring about myself and giving him ultimatums or was I wrong and seemed selfish and not caring about the “relationship” and his nonexistent feelings. -Ms. I Come First

Check out what Terrence Dean, a.k.a., the gay best friend has to say about her decision at HelloBeautiful.com.

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Uptowninfluence

    You answered your question in your question. And no one needs to be jugdemental. We’ve all been in situations with someone and we didn’t deserve the outcome, and cheating doesn’t always have to be physical. You can mentally and emotionally cheat as well. And you gave him options and what happened? He left. Ok, good bye, adios, ciao, duces. You don’t need this to be answered for you. You respected yourself enough to realize that you deserve better. If dude really cared he wouldn’t leave and try to understand your feelings, you wouldn’t be cheating, and this letter wouldn’t be existent.

  • Kashbmaryd

    If you are with someone and you feel that you have to cheat in order to get attention, maybe you should be giving yourself an ultimatum. This chick is probably going to have more relationship problems because, ironically, she is guilty of being immature as well. She needs to grow up, frankly, and get her own proprietors priorities in order.

  • Guest

    Ok, this is gonna sound really foul, but this is my opinion and advice, nothing more. IT…IS..YOUR…FAULT. Yes, I said it, it’s your fault. Now from my assessment, I see all the things that you found to be unattractive to him and you mentioned nothing appealing. You commenced to describe your constant unhappiness, admitted how you yourself cheated, called your friend stupid for her similar behavior and yet you are not taking responsibility for your own actions. A person can only do to you what you LET them do.You might not be able to control his actions in the relationship, but you can control yours. An ultimatum was not needed because he clearly showed you that he wasn’t serious to begin with. It’s like Maya Angelou said..
    “The first time someone shows you who they are, believe them.” If you want a guy to treat you a certain way, you have to voice your standards from the get-go. No ultimatum is needed, because he was never serious to begin with, so why would an ultimatum matter now?

  • Nope

    So, your ultimatum to a “boy” (which you were in a relationship with for 8 months, including sex… neither at gun point) backfired……… Get over it and get over him. You’re a willing participant, not a victim.

  • Pivyque

    more women need to do that in order to get what want and weed out the ones with no intentions on giving it to them.

  • lalatarea

    really? several times throughout the letter you made it clear he was a no good piece of… and ur asking if u made the right choice? I’m getting the feeling that this isn’t a real letter…just a allow day at madamenoire

  • http://profiles.yahoo.com/u/V6O2EBOSDDIC3EESW3JS22OYWA Vic

    That’s what you get for putting ultimatums on people. Nobody likes to be coerced.

    • thetruth

      Vic you must be the lazy bump she was referring to in the letter. Typical idiotic response. Good for her for putting ultimatums. Men like him deserve the low quality women only. That’s all they get and nothing more. He is mad cause she realized he is worthless. Dump that zero and get you a hero!!!!

  • Ladybug94

    I have come across some men who feel women should contact them. Moving on, nothing about this guy sounds attractive and he has less than nothing going for him. Move on and leave him be.