What Would You Do If Your Child Said College Wasn’t For Them?

June 7th, 2012 - By Clarke Gail Baines

First and foremost, let me say that this story isn’t about my child in particular, but about a niece of mine with a lot of talent and potential. I just thought I would bring this scenario to you guys to get your opinion on it and know what you would do as a parent (as I know many of our readers are mothers).

So during a recent trip to see my family, I had the chance to see almost all of my nieces and nephews. Two of them, twins, my family has been somewhat estranged from because of their mother and her rocky relationship with my brother. They’re both married to different people, but they still don’t get along all these years later. I also had something of an online argument with her and her sisters after one of my nephews other aunts decided to publicly disrespect my brother–his father–via Facebook after HE did the same. After some good time passed, my niece and nephew came to my mother’s home for the first time in years during Thanksgiving and we all got to reconnect. At THAT time, they were talking about their post-high school plans, their sports (which had always been a huge part of their high school career) and what they hoped to study.

Fast forward to graduation time and my visit home in May. As my sister picked up her doctorate, my cousin graduated from high school and talked about going away to a Big 10 University in the fall, and my nephew was asked to play baseball at a Division I school, my niece was the only graduate I knew who didn’t seem to have any after-the-fact plans. When I talked to her father about it all, since she was doing a good job of being MIA after all the festivities, I was quite disturbed to find that she had told him and others that she really didn’t think she was going to go to school. Though she had been accepted to a good school that wanted her to play softball in another state, she didn’t want to go that far because she didn’t know anybody out there…

Always one to stand out and stand on her own, even as a twin, she all of a sudden wasn’t ready to stand completely alone for the sake of her education. It was almost June and she hadn’t said yes or no to any school, and it seemed she was just going to take a break from school altogether. I could understand her reservations about attending a school far away from home, as I was the last child in my family and was somewhat scared about making  the decision to go out-of-state for school back in the day. But to have no plans and to say you’re not really feeling the idea of school? C’mon, this is 2012, and in this world and in this tepid economy, NOT going to school these days is unacceptable in my opinion.

And I’m saying it’s not acceptable because I think it’s a wack way of thinking or something like that, but rather, because as a friend would say, these days a bachelor’s degree in SOMETHING is your ticket in the door. At this point, it’s what the high school diploma used to be, and while many would say that a college degree doesn’t guarantee you any kind of job in this shoddy economy, we know that it at least offers you a shot at something and you won’t have your resume immediately put in the “No, thanks” pile. Many fields require a bit more, but a bachelor’s degree is something you should strive to have, whether you’re taking a few classes while working, or if you’re literally in the books full-time solely focused on your studies. If my niece decides to take some time off, that’s fine, but the whole concept of saying, “School’s just not for everybody” is on the nonsense level at this point. It’s for everybody, son. Even if she doesn’t go away, she needs to take her behind to school and not waste too much time waiting to do so. Her parents don’t seem too bothered by her choice at the moment (only time will tell how they’ll act if she’s sitting around on her mother’s couch in the fall), but as her aunt, I’ll say I’m clearly a bit worried. It’s already tough out here, I hope she doesn’t make things for herself much tougher.

So I guess that leads me to my question for you: As a parent, how would you react if your child (or even your niece or nephew as in my case), told you they didn’t want to go to college? No big deal? Or big problem?

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Mercedes

    Ok, so…completely backwards,..I’ve recently graduated high school. And I already know that college is not my forte. I’m not outgoing enough or have the bravery to walk into a classroom with hundreds of students. I’m sure that others would agree that college is, indeed, not for everyone. But if you don’t attend college, then what can you? I’ve been asking this question for some time now and still have not acquired a decent answer. I have thought about Community Colleges or even online courses…but, those really don’t seem like they do much for a person (depending on what your studying). and can anyone tell me what a Trade School is? and honestly, i need all the help i can get on any of this…I’m running out of ideas.. I’m defiantly not a military girl and i will indeed get a job, but is there anything else to look into? I wish that High School would teach students different options for those of us who aren’t into college…sadly my school frowned upon that idea along with many parents. And to some of the parents who are reading this, remember that some kids truly may not be up for college just yet or may never be. Don’t regret forcing your child into something that they know(or you may know too) they’re not ready for. Thanks!

  • Pingback: Dealing with a Child who Doesn't Want to go to College | Contemporary Mother

  • nisha136988

    As a college graduate myself I agree when everyone that says that college is not for everyone. I do not know why people make it seem as though if you do not go to school you will not make any money or have a successful career. There are many careers that are still considered professional that does not require a degree. If my son said that he would rather do something else then I will support him as long as he has a plan. The reason I went to college was really for my parents. I am definitely an exception because I’m glad that they push me. I think in today’s world that college is more about the experience rather than the education. Like mentioned before that a degree is equivalent to the degree under (bachelors is a HS diploma etc); therefore it’s like your not really going for the education because you already kind of have it. Overall college is a great learning experience but the classroom is not for everyone.

  • olamide

    My brother told my parent college wasn’t for him on the day of his high school graduation. My parent were very upset because my parent are college graduates, so they expect the same from us. They gave him an option, you either go to college or you get a 9 to 5 job. They gave him responsibilities, you help with the bills, no bringing home random girls, no hard partying while living under our roof. He tried at first, then broke the rules. My parent told him, he needs to find his own place. He moved out, and just got out of control. My dad became very stern and strict with him. He asked him one day, what do you want to do in life? He said, he will like to own his business, and you can make it without a degree. Yeah, if your dad’s name is Bill Gates or you are connected to Old money. If you want to be successful, you have to work extremely hard. It’s getting harder now because you are competing with some over achievers, and you have to constantly prove that you are competent and have something to offer. After hustling it out, he reluctantly went back to college at 26, got his bachelor’s in business administration graduated two years ago. He’s currently working with a company, and he’s happy at where he’s at. The reality is, college is not for everyone. Make sure you do something productive with your life. College is just a boost, open a little bit more opportunities than having none. There are some lucky entrepreneurs who made it without it, but that’s like five in thousands. Don’t just sit around doing nothing, staying on the streets hustling when you can do better things with your life.

  • Lanika

    A traditional four year degree doesnt guarantee a job and it isnt the only way to a successful career. There are many fields that you can go into without a degree. You can earn a paralegal certificate in less than a year and work in a professional field making decent money. Trade schools, cosmetology schools, the military, workforce development and continuing education classes are good alternatives to colleges and are also alot cheaper.

  • Evie

    I feel like black people make
    such a big stink about going to college just to please the white folks
    by saying “hey, look at me! I’m in college/getting a degree, i’m not a
    stupid black person! I’m no stereotype, see!”. Um no, college educated or not, you’re still
    nothing to a lot of them. College isn’t for everyone, and it sure isn’t
    a guarantee to get you a job (look at how many college/uni graduates
    who are unemployed and still can’t find a job, or who are working the
    same job as a non college person). So wtf is the big deal black folks?
    Stop trying to please Massa and do you. There’s also a lot of stupid
    folks with a diploma/degree, does that mean they’re less stupid? no.
    There’s plenty of other careers and paths you can go into without no
    damn college and loans.

  • L-Boogie

    Be supportive and find another avenue to improve their future.

  • http://twitter.com/MzRaeBaby313 One and Only MzRae

    College isn’t for everyone!! I went to school and had to drop out (I have two children though, it was very different for me)….most of the ppl I know that went to college still work barely over minimum wage jobs, because no one will hire them due to lack of EXPERIENCE. I know 4 ppl right now that have a bachelor’s in nursing and can’t get a job because no one wants to hire an nurse with no experience. On the contrary, I have friends that are hairstylist and barbers that make more money than the people that went to school. My older cousin started his own catering business from selling dinners to local businesses in the community. Welders, plumbers, mechanics all make good money as well. If she doesn’t want a formal education, maybe she should try acquiring a skill. As for myself, I am a makeup artist and make in 1 or 2 days what ppl make in 4. The last thing you want to do is spend money for nothing or possibly get into loads of student loan debt just to drop out and go be a receptionist for $8 an hour.

  • Ladybug94

    College isn’t for everybody, however, the child does need to have some other plans for supporting themselves as an adult. This could either be going to technical school or maybe they have a talent which is good enough to make a living from.

  • Angel

    I hear ppl say they have friends who didnt go to college that are doing well…what exactly are they doing though?

    • Ladybug94

      Angel, I know several people in business for themselves who have never gone to college. One that immediately comes to mind does contract work for the government, she is able to work from her $450,000 home and she’s sending her oldest child college. It can be done. Steve Jobs was a college dropout. Steve Harvey was a college dropout so let’s not limit ourselves.

      • Tanesha

        This is true. College is not for everyone. But let’s be clear, Steve Jobs and Steve Harvey are the exceptions, not the rule. If you go get a trade, you can do very well. I’m also all for being an entrepreneur, but it typically takes money to start a business and and many fail in the first five years. Dont get me wrong, I believe in following your dreams and I do think we need to teach ppl how to create stable jobs and not get one, but right now, unless you have a trade, or a certification,college, although not a guarantee like it once was, is still the best way to avoid poverty.

        • Angel

          @tanesha i was thinking the same thing? Like steve is an entertainer and how many ppl can do what steve jobs has done? But yes u are both right…college may not b for everyone

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]