Black Girls Share Letters To The Fathers They Never Had In ‘Dear Daddy’

May 30th, 2012 - By Brande Victorian

So often we talk about the effect not having a father has on young black boys, but black girls aren’t immune to the consequences of having an absentee father. Documentary filmmaker Janks Morton is exploring that effect in a new doculogue titled, “Dear Daddy.”

Last summer, Morton had eight girls from a Boys & Girls club in DC that he works with write one-page letters to their fathers and then read them on camera for his project. In the trailer for the film, we see 18-year-old Jasmine Bowden reads of a list of things she hates about her father not being there—the fact that she can’t turn to him for help when she has a problem, the fact that her dad has never offered to help her mother raise her, and the fact that he only comes around when he needs something.

Nearly a year later, Jasmine appeared on NPR yesterday with Morton and Jonetta Rose Barras, author of Whatever Happened to Daddy’s Little Girl? to talk about what happens when black mothers are the only ones around and it was still difficult for the teen to talk about how her father’s absence has affected her. She told Michelle Martin of Tell Me More that her father still isn’t around and that:

“If I had my dad around I really think I probably would’ve made some good choices in boys.”

From the young women he worked with, Morton said the pain girls experienced was the same no matter what circumstances led to their fathers not being around.

“What I saw, it doesn’t matter. The deserter, deceased, the disenfranchised, the whatever the circumstance, it doesn’t matter. The trauma that these girls – these 1.8 million, 18 to 24-year-old black girls, 1.8 million – are carrying on their heart, it’s not been given a voice. And what I found is that this arc, it goes through a woman’s life. It just manifests itself in all these different ways that I think, that if we can get this generation, you know, an opportunity to purge themselves of this trauma, I think there are some greatness that can begin to happen in the relationship dynamic in blacks.”

Though that pain may be the same, it can manifest itself in different ways, though mostly it’s seen with women believing they can’t depend on men, and sometimes depending on other things to cope.

“What I’ve seen with these young women specifically is that this kind of cultural construct we, or this mantra we have of, you know, all the women, independent, stand on your own two feet – which leads to all those great workshops that Jonetta talks about. They’ll give you all of these great things, self-worth, identity, financial literacy, all of these things to deal with all of the secondary manifestations. But to get to the pathology of where the pain hurts, where it starts, I don’t know what it is but that thing is off the table in our community. And this film is, what I’m trying to do, I think that really, if we start here a lot of this other things, you know, abusing your body with drugs, abusing your body with food, all those other workshops get put out of business if we deal with father absence and void vacancy at this juncture.”

Check out more of Morton and Jasmine’s interview on NPR here along with the trailer to his film below. What do you think about this doculogue?


Brande Victorian is a blogger and culture writer in New York City. Follower her on Twitter at @be_vic.

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Deda

    Man up black men, cuz telling a child its because your mom is a sorry excuse to have for 18 plus years.. no u just to lazy to get a lawyer and call the police, my dad was in my life and he would do anything to see me.. also what did u do for her to prevent u from seeing your child, nothing right? Yeah you not fooling no one but yourself.. everyone in jail has the same excuse, i didnt do nothing they just locked me up for no reason.. get out of here..

  • Erikacavanar

    Wow, painful. I can not imagine what my life would be like without my father.This actually made me cry. if people aren’t ready to be parents why don’t they use protection instead of leaving all this hurt and pain behind?   

    • Todd

      Excellent question.  Kudos to your parents for making great choices.  Give them a kiss for me.

  • Todd

    Don’t discount the notion that mothers push their children’s fathers away.   Now some of you will respond with the classic ‘well if he was a real man he would stay no matter what’ but that’s not true.   Men need respect and when a women disrespects it will drive him away.  Take into account that most of the disrespect comes as a result of how to care for the child and the child becomes the source of strife.   

    Before the child came you were just ‘kickin’ it’ but after the child is born, this turns into demands. You need, the child needs and suddenly he moves from being your equal to being your servant who is responsible for supplying the needs of you and your child.   What happens when he fall short?  He is either ridiculed or disrespected.   

    Women sometimes have a hard time understanding that men CHOOSE to be with you.  And with that choice comes the expectation of reciprocation.  But when a child comes along the women takes that affection and transfers it to the child.  The man often feels marginalized and can experience rejection as she gleefully invests herself into her new love.   

    Men don’t talk about it but in every way it like being cheated on.  A woman may be true with her body but we have no problems with supporting a woman being free with her heart and emotions.  Even in homes where the man is present he is often last in line after the children, her mother, her friends, her job, etc.  Therefore the man leaves in search of someone who is willing to put him first in their lives.  

    So it begs the question – Why should he put you and the child first when you are all too comfortable putting him last? 

    • Dancerzrule14

      oh please!! a man should ALWAYS put his child first. im sorry but I DONT CARE what the situation is. a real man who truly wants to have a relationship with his kid u will go to court and do whatever u have to do to see it. even if he  has to “take a hit” form the babymomma every single time he goes to see his child he would do it. and im sorry but triflin babymommas is NOT the main reason that black men dont care about thier children.

      • Todd

        Obviously they aren’t.  That’s the point.   

  • Tsk

    Blah blah people can only play the blame game this is so old

    • Ladybug94

      It’s not old if it is still affecting children in a very negative way. Until that ends, it’s relevant and needs to be addressed.

  • Treacle123

    Growing up, I remember so many of my school mates didn’t celebrate Father’s Day and that’s so sad. Based on this article and some of the previous comments, it’s for this reason I am soo happy that I know who my father is and I grew up with him under the same roof. I love my dad, he is very hard working and did more than his best to take care of his family.

    • Todd

      I’m glad for you.  Kudos to your parents for making great choices…

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]