Getting Closer To The Truth? Key Witnesses in Zimmerman Case Change Their Tune

May 23rd, 2012 - By Marissa Ellis

Source: IBtimes.com

The case against George Zimmerman, the Florida man who claims he killed teenager Trayvon Martin in self defense, is sure to be one of the most defining cases of justice of our time. Although many legal analysts can see just how the Stand Your Ground law may get Zimmerman off the hook, the Orlando Sentinel has just reported that Zimmerman’s self-defense case has weakened in light of recent accounts from witnesses.

Three of the witnesses have changed their original recollections of the February night in question and a fourth witness has completely “abandoned her story.” The Sentinel described how each of the witnesses changed their accounts:

Witness 2

A young woman who lives in the Retreat at Twin Lakes community, where Trayvon was shotwas interviewed twice by Sanford police and once by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

She told authorities that she had taken out her contact lenses just before the incidentIn her first recorded interview with Sanford police four days after the shooting, she told lead Investigator Chris Serino, “I saw two guys running. Couldn’t tell you who was in front, who was behind.”

She stepped away from her window, and when she looked again, she “saw a fistfight. Just fists. I don’t know who was hitting who.”

A week later, she added a detail when talking again to Serino: During the chase, the two figures had been 10 feet apart.

That all changed when she was reinterviewed March 20 by an FDLE agent. That time, she recalled catching a glimpse of just one running figure, she told FDLE Investigator John Batchelor, and she heard the person more than saw him.

“I couldn’t tell you if it was a man, a woman, a kid, black or white. I couldn’t tell you because it was dark and because I didn’t have my contacts on or glasses. … I just know I saw a person out there.”

Witness 12

A young mother who is also a neighbor in the town-home community never gave a recorded interview to Sanford police, according to prosecution records released last week. She first sat down for an audio-recorded interview with an FDLE agent March 20, more than three weeks after the shooting.

During that session, she said she saw two people on the ground immediately after the shooting and was not sure who was on top, Zimmerman or Trayvon.

“I don’t know which one. … All I saw when they were on the ground was dark colors,” she said.

Six days later, however, she was sure: It was Zimmerman on top, she told trial prosecutor Bernie de la Rionda during a 21/2-minute recorded session.

“I know after seeing the TV of what’s happening, comparing their sizes, I think Zimmerman was definitely on top because of his size,” she said.

For witness 6, the Sentinel reported that the witness originally described a black man on top of a lighter-skinned man, throwing punches. Later, he told an agent that he wasn’t sure that Trayvon was throwing punches, as he could’ve been pinning him down to the ground.

As for witness 13, he is the one that spoke to a calm Zimmerman immediately after the shooting. He didn’t neccessarily change his story but he gave more detail as to the non-chalant attitude of Zimmerman’s demeanor following the shooting. “Zimmerman’s tone, the witness said, was “not like ‘I can’t believe I just shot someone!’ — it was more like, ‘Just tell my wife I shot somebody …,’ like it was nothing.”

Do you think these witnesses took the questioning more seriously now that the case is so high-profile or do you think they may be sympathizing with Trayvon Martin after allowing the news to penetrate?

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • guestdfw

    I can’t help but wonder if they truly don’t recall or they are afraid of participating in a trial and people try to blame them or worse. Ya’ll know we got some ig’nant people out there who would try to turn this into a race war (New Black Panther Party). I honestly want to keep an open mind but the 911 tape is what did it for me. Zimmerman admitted to following Martin. I don’t care if they were the same color or not. Zimmerman killed Martin. Since this is in FL, I think Zimmerman will get away with it. I listened to Zimmerman defenders and they just keep with a very weak defense, “you don’t know what happened after he hung up with 911″ yes I do Zimmerman followed Martin and Martin Stood his Ground and was killed for it.

    • Guest

      Can you imagine how the ish would hit the fan if the witnesses’ accounts originally favored Trayvon and then later changed to favor Zimmerman?

      • guestdfw

         I agree. The whole handling of this has been a mess from the police to media. I do not like that some of the information went to the media first. I wonder how bad of a job the police did to collect evidence (beyond what we heard in the media).  I hope they take that Stand Your Ground law and flush it.  I just want justice for Trayvon. 

  • Gailj57

      I still believe Zimmerman killed him, but because of the wishy-washy people, this man will get away with murder.

  • Stephanie

    I’m confused as to why there is so much confusion about this case …
    Zimmerman was clearly the aggressor throughout this whole ordeal,
    Trayvon did absolutely nothing wrong that night … if a stranger is
    following you through your neighborhood & then approaches you, wouldn’t you feel afraid, threaten???

    We’ll never know the entire truth, but some things we do know are true:

    Sanford police did a poor/sloppy, I don’t give a damn job
    Trayvon did absolutely nothing wrong that night
    Zimmerman was the aggressor (from start to finish)
    Zimmerman followed Trayvon
    Zimmerman approached Trayvon (didn’t identify himself as a neighborhood watchman)
    Words were exchanged between Zimmerman & Trayvon
    Zimmerman & Trayvon got into a fist-fight
    Trayvon was obviously getting the better of Zimmerman, but Zimmerman’s wounds did not look like he was in a life or death struggle
    Zimmerman pulled out his gun & killed, no, MURDERED Trayvon

    I doubt if Zimmerman will get convicted of 1st or 2nd degree murder, but he should get convicted of manslaughter (the max sentence)…he was the cause of Trayvon’s murder, Trayvon’s murder was preventable!!!! #justice4TrayvonMartin #convictionofZimmerman

    • Guest

      There are many reasons why there is so much confusion, the main one being that the media has not been remotely interested in researching all the known facts to present them properly.

      Also, many people are arbitrarily deciding what is against the law whether it is or not. For instance, many people believe that it is against the law to follow someone and ask them what they are doing. Many people believe that it is against the law to disregard the suggestion of a 911 dispatcher. They are wrong on both counts.

      And many people are stating “We’ll never know the entire truth, but some things we do know are true” and then stating things that cannot be known to be true.

      “Sanford police did a poor/sloppy, I don’t give a damn job”
      We don’t yet know this to be true.

      “Trayvon did absolutely nothing wrong that night”
      We have no way of knowing this to be true.

      “Zimmerman was the aggressor (from start to finish)”
      We have no way of knowing this to be true.

      “Zimmerman followed Trayvon”
      “Zimmerman approached Trayvon (didn’t identify himself as a neighborhood watchman)”
      Words were exchanged between Zimmerman & Trayvon”
      “Zimmerman & Trayvon got into a fist-fight”
      All these we know to be true.

      “Trayvon was obviously getting the better of Zimmerman, but Zimmerman’s
      wounds did not look like he was in a life or death struggle”
      True in retrospect, but Zimmerman may have legitimately believed he was in a life or death struggle in the heat of the moment.

      “Zimmerman pulled out his gun & killed, no, MURDERED Trayvon”
      The first part is undisputably true. The capitalized part, not so much.

  • jumelle

    Just as the police were quick to get Mr. Zimmerman away from the scene, I wouldn’t be surprised if they played a part in his “injuries”

    #coverup

  • Nibayaneloci86

    everybody can’t be lying. so hopefully its the former….

  • Domkalonli

    How can you be the agressor if you are walking down the street minding your own business!..come on if someone is following you doesn’t that mean you should protect yourself not the other way around!

    • Qua_rius

      Exactly!!!

  • superwoman

    Self defense? Paaaalease! George Zimmerman is twice the size Trayvon was. If George Zimmerman is being truthful about a fist fight with Trayvon, I think the reason he pulled out a gun and killed that young man is because he got upset that Trayvon was getting the best of him and “punked out” and used a weapon. He also was already looking for trouble by following and then stopping Trayvon in the first place. Since when does a neighborhood watch person carry a gun? This people is racism at its best because if the tables were turned Trayvon would STILL be in jail right now while the investigation continues not in hiding like George Zimmerman.

  • Dnlumaque

    This man has solidified his seat in hell. He will face God, so he better pray his days on earth are slow. Because his judgment day will be brutual.

  • TRUTH

    SMH at this case.  It’s screams phaq a black race. 

    Wasn’t Trayvon Standing his ground when Zimmerfaq followed him?  It’s outrageous!!

    • Qua_rius

      It amazes me how so many people refuses to point out the “strong” possibility that Trayvon was actually standing his ground and Zimmerman was the initial aggressor.

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]