And This Is How You Shut Someone Down On-Air Without Being An Angry Black Woman

May 11th, 2012 - By Brande Victorian

Source: poptower.com

In a random internet search I came across a clip about MSNBC host Tamron Hall having an altercation with one of her guests, Tim Carney, and I got a little nervous. Some headlines said she had an on-air tantrum, she shut the conservative commentator down, she talked him off the show, etc., and I clenched at what might have happened. You know we only have to look at somebody a certain way to get that angry black woman labeled slapped on us quickly and I just knew it was coming this time, but not with Tamron.

I’ll admit I had to watch the clip a couple of times to figure out exactly what was going on—more so what set the reporter off so quickly, but it was actually right at the beginning of the discussion. Tim accused her of pulling a “typical media trick” when she questioned him, not about Mitt Romney’s past—particularly some bullying incidents in question—but about how he thought the presidential hopeful’s camp was handling the accusations, and as you can guess from the title of the article, we never got that answer. As soon as the words, “You hype up a story and justify the second-day coverage of the story,” slipped from Tim’s lips, Tamron was done. Immediately, she politely, yet sternly reminded Tim:

“You don’t have to answer a single question I ask you, and you didn’t have to accept the invitation to come on,” she told him.

“Your actions are irritating me right now. You are not going to come on and insult me, you are not going to come on and insult the network, when you knew what we were going to be talking about. Done.”

And just like that, Tim’s mic was cut and his time on News Nation was no more. I will say I got a little antsy when Tamron said his actions were irritating her because I thought, well, that’s not exactly an appropriate reason to kick someone off of your show. However, being insulted as a journalist is, and that’s what Tamron said she was taking a stand for—and amazingly, the public agrees. I just knew when I scrolled down to the comments section of the first article I read the racists Internet thugs would be going in but they weren’t there. Instead, there were comments like, “what a classic lady,” “you go, girl” (you know folks can’t wait to use that phrase), and even statements of people being proud of her and that she’d garnered another viewer.

This isn’t just an isolated incident a few people noticed either, the clip has gone viral and was even trending on Twitter. What’s amazing is Viewers were standing up for her against this white man, calling her a “bada**” and even a “hero.” You know it’s not every day we hear that word associated with a black woman.

Now I know some of this can be chalked up to most of the nation’s frustrations with the right wing but I think Tamron deserves some credit too. Neck rolling, eye rolling, attitudes, all of those things are expected of black women when things get hot. If they can accuse Michelle Obama of being an angry black woman when I don’t think we’ve so much as seen her frown since she entered the White House, how much quicker would they be to say the same in a situation like this? But not today. Tamron proved she can play white people’s game—Fox stays kicking people off the air—and keep her dignity and professional integrity too and I’m just proud to be in a world she’s living in and that didn’t go the prejudice route when they saw her stand her ground. This is how most black women handle conflict and there were a whole lot of people who needed to see this to know that.

Check out the clip of the altercation below. How do you think Tamron handled herself?

Brande Victorian is a blogger and culture writer in New York City. Follower her on Twitter at @be_vic.

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Gimmeabreak78

    I watched the clip and LOOOVED it!  I absolutely hate it when people from both sides of the political aisle come on news programs and get wide-eyed and act gobsmacked at an interviewer’s line of questioning when they knew what the topic of discussion would be from the getgo.  I love how she just cut off his video feed and moved on to the next thing because she had better things to do than listen to this fool fake indignation about an interview he agreed to do.  I mean what did he think he was coming on the show to do–talk about his golf handicap?  I was never really an avid view of MSNBC, but I’ll stay tuned for Tamron now. 

  • TheBigSplash

    Tamron was wrong. She didn’t like his answer and shut him off. That wasn’t journalism. If he didn’t appear on the show that would have looked weak and suspicious. The topic wasn’t that deep. If Tim was abusive or disruptive in some way that was unprofessional then she had a right. But not this time.

    I suspect that Tamron started winding up when Tim referred to extremist language from the left such as “War on Women” as silly. It is; women are America’s number one citizen incidentially. If only there was just such a war on black men…But that was the root of her tantrum. I think The Right is wacky and dangerous, but if Tamron’s network requires that guests use answers scripted by her or her network as a condition of appearance then they need to say so up front.

    • Gimmeabreak78

      I knew someone would completely miss the point.  The point isn’t so much that he didn’t answer questions he knew he would be asked.  Politicians and political operatives on both sides of the aisle are very adept at giving “nonanswers” in response to difficult/unpleasant questions.  The problem was in so doing he insulted both his interviewer and the platform on which he was invited to speak (MSNBC) to air his opiniion.  Just like it’s rude to go to someone’s house and insult your host, it’s rude to go on a news program and insult the interviewer or the network.  Tamron was completely within her rights to kick him out of “her house”. 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/AGABT3WR5KHMHSR2SR7RVY55WM Kimberly Morris

    Tamron Hall handled the situation professionally.  He thought he could out talk her and discredit her skills as a journalist, but she proved that she is very worthy of her position.

  • Ebonydiva82

    She handled herself like the professional she is.

  • Leah12

    It does not hurt that she is an attractive black woman.

  • Eellekhill

    Loved it! Yes Tamron handled that like a pro! 

  • XYZEBRA

    Tamron shut him down w/the quickness & kept it very professional. Done.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LKTYBUVNAR2RVV6QMSJUQEIUGY EVELYND

    yes she did handle her self in a  very proffesionnal manner. as the professional woman she is a white far  right rep will never respect a black woman of her  calaber, or any other black woman, they have no respect for black women and they never will wo
    uld he have talk to megan kelly like that????

  • Ms_Sunshine9898

    I love it! She snapped and she handled that business like a lady!

    • D. Rose in the paint

      Snapping and being a lady are opposites. True ladies dont “snap”, they know how to be assertive while maintaining their dignity. A real lady is Jessica Simpson….a great example of a lady is Ivanka Trump….class on top of class

      • Ms_Sunshine9898

         Snap – “to utter curtly or abruptly cut or break” which is what she did. She “curtly” and “abruptly” cut off his foolishness. Please dismiss yourself to read a dictionary. . . .

        • D. Rose in the paint

           I guess you “told me” “sista girl”!! LMAO

          • Ms_Sunshine9898

            LOL Glad you have a sense of humor!

        • Gimmeabreak78

          I like your “snap”!  LOL.

      • november rain

        Jessica Simpson?! Are you a troll?

      • So what

         a real lady is “jessica simpson”, “ivanka trump”…only beckys have class?  I wonder why people who love beckys so much stay on websites for “sista girls”???

        Obsessed with hate but still never satisfied with your square beckys…

        • D. Rose in the paint

          I chose those 2 women not because of their race….thats what YOU chose to accentuate! You are obviously racist and have anger towards Caucasian women, calling them “Beckys” is racist and derogatory! At any rate I am a fan of The Apprentice and anyone who watches that show will tell you…Ivanka Trump is a class act and has a beautiful personality, she is a great example of how any woman should behave regardless of race. She has grace, style, intelligence, and an outstanding work ethic…I love her. She never talks down to people and is fair. Jessica Simpson is a beautiful person inside and out and always carries herself like a true lady. I see personality and not race, I have no biases for race…I refuse to pick sides. I love ALL OF GOD’S PEOPLE! And you need to grow up and expand your outlook past the African American group! And using the term “becky” takes you down a notch! In the meantime how about you Google these keywords together: “Ivanka Trump Class Act”…..and see how many results pop up agreeing with what I said!