Transgender Woman On Trial For Second-Degree Murder After Homophobic Attack

April 26th, 2012 - By Brande Victorian

Source:Supportcece.wordpress.com

On Monday, Chrishuan “CeCe” McDonald will stand trial for second-degree homicide stemming from an altercation outside of a Minneapolis bar last June, but supporters of the 23-year-old transgender woman say she is the real victim in this case.

On June 5, 2011, two white women and a white man reportedly began harassing CeCe and four of her trans friends, calling them racial and homophobic slurs. One woman allegedly hit Cece in the side of the face with a glass beer mug and when 47-year-old Dean Schmitz reportedly pursued her, Cece fatally stabbed him with a pair of fabric scissors that had been in her purse.

When police arrived on the scene they arrested Cece and no one else. The young woman received 11 stitches after her salivary gland was lacerated and the side of her cheek was sliced open by the beer mug, and according to reports she was interrogated without counsel and placed in solitary confinement, pending the outcome of her upcoming case.

Joey Mogul, partner at the People’s Law Office in Chicago and director of the Civil Rights Clinic at DePaul University College of Law, says CeCe is an obvious victim of racism and transgender phobia:

“This is not the first time Schmitz has been known to use [such slurs]…as ‘n***er’ and ‘f*ggot’. It’s my understanding his brother admitted to the press that [Schmitz] is openly racist and trans-phobic. He’s been convicted on three prior cases for acts of violence.”

Pointing out that CeCe had no criminal record at all, he continued: “Why weren’t Schmitz and those with him charged with inciting to riot? Instead, this woman is a witness for the prosecution.”

City Council member Cam Gordon later reported that the Hennepin county medical examiner found a Nazi swastika tattoo on Schmitz’s chest, but in the face of all of this evidence, prosecutor Michael Freeman refuses to drop the case. In fact, after Cece refused a plea agreement on October 6, the Hennepin County Attorney’s Office added an additional charge of second-degree murder with intent which means she faces up to 80 years in prison.

Supporters of the young woman have started a website to Support CeCe and encourage those who hear this story to sign a petition to have the prosecution drop the charges. Check out more on the site here.

What do you think about this case?

Brande Victorian is a blogger and culture writer in New York City. Follower her on Twitter at @be_vic.

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • ALdo_camus

    Get her plastic surgery by the best.  Trial for the three creeps who assaulted her.  Free her immediately.
     

  • Goodgirl

    Again racism at work!

  • LUVBNBLK

    Depending on Chrishuan’s interaction with the “other” group this case shouldn’t hold up in court. I would love to here the other side of the story to see how the D.A. is trying to spin it (must be an election year). He/she just need to hire a real attorney and not a court appointed one and the case should flop. Good luck Chrishuan.

  • Tburthey

    Apparently, they have no “Stand Your Ground” laws in that state….Hmmm, I agree with everyone else. Its a sad situation but the person clearly used force on her and she returned it. The disparity in treatment has to stop.

  • seek2027

    wow this is crazy

  • FromUR2UB

    Well.  They were looking for trouble and found it.  The guy would still be alive if he’d minded his own business.   When someone actually pursues a person, what do they expect to happen if the person is caught?

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/LZWUQMX3QALBS5NKVPSXR7YROY Keke Small

    She had every right to defend herself. smh this is so sad.

  • Aquariusn916

    The first thing that comes to mind is…Why aren’t the white people being charged with hate crimes? 

  • harlemQueen

    I hope ce-ce will be cleared and set free.  Those punks got what they were looking for.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Goldie-Treasure/100001545308532 Goldie Treasure

    She shouldn’t be in jail. As far as he goes: Good riddance to bad rubbish.

  • Sexiqueen05

    WOW…What happened to self defense? In this case the injuries are glaringly obvious and the perpetrator has a record…..

  • Nehemiah53

    Wait a minute here CeCe is a man [have male hormones, male strengths and statue] not a women he was born a male, and just because he say he is a women don’t change the fact that he was born a male, now from what is reported here it sound like CeCe was defending himself however I don’t believe this is the hold story.

    • Aquariusn916

      The WHOLE story?  He/she was assaulted by harrassed by a group of people spewing racial and homophobic slurs.  What other parts of the story are missing?  The actual words that were directed towards him/her? 

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/LZWUQMX3QALBS5NKVPSXR7YROY Keke Small

      everything is there..

    • activist1

      Cece is a woman. She may have formed as a male but she most likely has a female brain which has been proven scientifically as many trans people have opposite sex brains. A person will change their body to match what their brain says. Cece is female not male.

  • http://twitter.com/reginawoodruff Regina Woodruff

    Does this state where this incident occurred have a “stand your ground” type of law? It seems like that should apply in this case. Cece was defending herself! This is a disgrace.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/LZWUQMX3QALBS5NKVPSXR7YROY Keke Small

      That law is for white people. So it wouldn’t matter anyways

  • Lalatarea

    Utterly speechless over the injustice here! there is sooo much evidence that proves she had every right to defend herself against this violent, racist, homophobic ahole! just wow

    • Lalatarea

      well actually it kinda makes sense since the “victim” is a white man smdh.

    • Nehemiah53

      Wait we don’t know the hold story here!

  • Rob

    Wow. I know she will be in good hands from Joey Mogul. I hope justice is served

  • reealistic

    Wow I’m from Minneapolis and I don’t remember hearing about this. Such an injustice for cece!! It really upsets me…..but unfortunately her incident with the police sounds all but too familiar.

    • emily

      Prayers out to CeCe.  SMH

    • activist1

      You might have. At first, the media continuously used the incorrect gender pronouns to address Cece until some of the activists working with her contacted them about that. Also, I know that activists that are working with Cece on her case. They have contacted every LGBT and black organization and publication to get the word out about her case to these communities as well as the mainstream media to not portray her in a primary negative light as they have been. No one has returned their calls or offered to at least inform communities about what’s going on with her and what she’s been through in jail, the mistreatment she says she’s endured. I don’t think she will get a fair trial. However, kudos to MM for sharing her story.