What Would It Really Look Like To Not Need White People’s Approval?

April 19th, 2012 - By Brande Victorian

Every week, there’s a new report on an instance of black people being excluded, overlooked, or discriminated in some shape or form. This week it was Acura and “The Bachelor,” a few weeks ago it was Vanity Fair and Kerry Washington, always its fashion magazines and runways and beauty campaigns. The thought that comes up most consistently after the outrage is why are we looking for white people’s approval, why are we seeking their validation, why don’t we spend time nurturing our own? And while I don’t agree that by pointing out these instances of discrimination we are seeking white people’s approval (I think it’s holding them accountable and demonstrating evidence to the contrary of their melting pot, post-racial society, we love diversity claims), I do think that more time would be better spent not seeking or needing to be a part of what white people have going on—and have obviously shown through their actions they want to keep to themselves. But I’m curious if we really know what that would mean or how to even achieve it.

When I think of a time when black people had their “own” on a large scale in entertainment, I think of the Robert Johnson 1980 BET days, even Don Cornelius’ Soul Train days come to mind. These men had a vision to give black people something they could be proud of on TV and they made it happen. But the reality is Bob Johnson had to get John C. Malone to invest $500,000 in the project to get it off the ground, and once the network became a raving success, it no longer remained a black-owned network because he sold it to Viacom for $3 billion in 2003, and ever since we’ve been left with the version of “black entertainment” we see now. When I thought about the wealthy rappers that were acknowledged by Forbes yesterday, I noticed a common thread. A lot of the men’s wealth came from selling companies and brands they’d built. Jay-Z sold Rocawear, 50 Cent sold his stake in Vitamin Water, and Dr. Dre gave up his majority ownership in Beats Electronics for a hefty price. It’s a common—and smart—business practice, but not one that allows us to have the ultimate say in the decisions that upset us, like who appears in which advertisements and how we’re portrayed on TV. That wealth also doesn’t trickle down into the community because we’re not selling these businesses off to other African Americans, they’re going to large corporations headed by white men mostly who could care less about our representation, and the money remains in the hands of the black 1%.

I even think about Oprah and the enormous opportunity to change the face of black programming if she would even just back a venture financially, aside from putting it on her network, but from what we’ve observed of her career that’s just not her thing. If we look at where the wealth is distributed in black America and the individuals who have the dollars to invest in independent black films or black clothing designers, the interest just isn’t there. That doesn’t make these figures bad people. They’re businessmen. White people aren’t thinking about sharing the wealth when they embark on a new venture, they’re building their individual pockets. It’s just that there’s so many more of them and so few of us, and so when we run out of the few select black people who could open doors to come through, we’re left with relying on white people to at least acknowledge we exist in some way and to represent us fairly in the media. That’s why we get so upset when they fail—often times on purpose—it really is our last resort in a lot of ways.

The idea of not having to look at programs and networks that weren’t created for us to begin with as the only source of quality programming is like the black community’s Nirvana but we don’t own much and when something isn’t yours, you don’t get much say in how it operates. There’s hope on the horizon with Diddy and Magic Johnson’s new cable channels that are in the works, but even those networks will be owned by Comcast. A few years ago, Quincy Jones announced plans to buy back Vibe, the magazine he started, I’m not sure if the web presence of the publication is evidence he kept his word or not. I hope that there are other black business minds out there with altruistic goals of putting black people on the map, and not just self, but I’m not too optimistic. I am completely behind the idea that we need to create our own and nurture it, my question is, how will we ever be able to do that without needing white people’s approval, at least from a financial backing standpoint, if we’re not even holding on to the things we’ve built or paving the way for others?

Brande Victorian is a blogger and culture writer in New York City. Follower her on Twitter at @be_vic.

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Pingback: White Approval in Media « Reframing

  • MixedUpInVegas

    Kudos to Madame Noire for an uncommonly well done article.  I must comment, though.  Implicit in what is being said is that somehow black people who have succeeded should pool their resosurces to pull up their less-fortunate brethren.  That is a lot to lay on the usual people mentioned.  Frankly, unless you’re talking about Bill Gates or Warren Buffett, white people who are gazillionaires don’t do that either.  Most black millionaires ++ didn’t come from money–they got their own.  It is unfair and unrealistic of us as a people to expect that they “owe” something back.  If they figure that they can do it and so can anyone else, they are largely correct in that assessment.

    My personal opinion–and I will be battered here for this–is that anyone can do better than what they were born to.  I see it over and over in my own family and in other working people around me.  We, as a group, tend to shoot ourselves in the foot and then expect those who didn’t to raise us up.  Sorry, but your own life choices make a huge difference in what your accomplish in life.  Blame it on white people if you want to, blame the government but heaven forbid you should blame yourself for not taking the time-honored way to raise your own self up–avoid trouble with the law, pursue an education, avoid having OWW children, stay away from addictive drugs and carry yourself with pride in public. 

     Thoes who do those things do better for themselves and their families.  Those who don’t, well, don’t.  It is that simple.

    • DoinMe

      Bill Gates, Warren Buffet, and other white billionaires do indeed pull up their own by employing them in their corporations, making loans for their buddies to start businesses, opening doors and other opportunities to them FIRST. Most blacks don’t have those same resources and part of the problem with us is that we have taken on this “I got mine, you get yours attitude” which,  collectively, has gotten us nowhere. 
       
      What you are speaking about is individual success, which is fine, but in order for us to make it collectively like other affluent minorities, it will require pooling of resources. No one is expecting black millionaires/billionaires to pull up the less fortunate. But what they can do is create further opportunities for those who are ready, willing, and able to take it. Right now, most blacks are dependent on white folks to hire them at some company.
      If you want to see what a successful black community looks like when we keep our resources among us, uplift our own, and not having to depend on whites for employment, schools, and other socieconomic well-being, look at some of the black communities of the early 1900s–Black Wall Street, Detroit Paradise Valley/Black Bottom, Rosewood, St. Louis Little Africa, just to name a few.

  • Gabe Ware

    I care less about white peoples “approval” in general.  But that’s because as an adult i am educated, i am intelligent, i respect myself and i work hard to be the best me that i know how. If i am holding my own and doing something constructive, then to hell with what others think or approve of.  Its called high self esteem.
     
    I always say that as a people Blacks are wide, but we are not DEEP.  Meaning that i could point to one Black astro-physicist, one or two Black billionaires etc, even one Black President of the United States!  But overall we are not achieving in large enough numbers to propel ourselves forward.  And so we always single out Oprah, Tyler Perry, Bob Johnson etc as though these few people could lift up our entire race *sigh*.  It’s just not realistic. Fact of the matter is, we will start to reach higher heights as a group when we realize that the next Oprah Winfrey, Bob Johnson or Tyler Perry could be staring right at you in the mirror!  And that takes a high self esteem, educated, informed, hard working individual effort.  Yes im talking about YOU.  Ever hear people on tv going on and on about “personal responsibility”? It means that everyone has to be accountable for their own actions and their own well being.  Too many African Americans have what amounts to a basic self esteem problem.  We just don’t think enough of ourselves period.  White people many times have an OVER inflated sense of self.  Their attitude seems arrogant as hell and often annoying, but that attitude breeds way more success than failure. Ponder on these two words – SELF LOVE.  I’m going to say it again – SELF LOVE.  When a person truly learns to loves his or herself, their every action speaks to that fact. They respect themselves, they strive for higher heights, they educate their children, and they start to naturally love and defend others that happen to LOOK LIKE THEM.  People who love themselves care nothing about needing the approval of someone else because they are busy striving and moving forward. 

    • KickWhitesOutAfrica

      A wonderful comment – you’ve hit the nail right on the head. Kudos 2U

  • Pingback: UPTOWN Magazine » What Would It Really Look Like To Not Need White People’s Approval?

  • Bwdbwndbnsbdbs

    This is the first article I’ve read here in a long time that represents what this site is supposed to be about instead of being “the 7 things men _____” or “basketball wives _____”. Bravo.

    • KickWhitesOutAfrica

      I completely agree.  We need more articles like this… and not the navel gazing stuff.

  • maggie

    That title underlines about 85% of the decisions black people make in this country.

  • DoinMe

    I wish I could personally high five the author of this article. Imagine if all of the Oprah’s, Jay-Zs, Diddy’s, Bob Johnson’s, and other wealthy blacks pooled together their resources to create opportunities, just how much power and wealth we would have. Black communities had more power and wealth before we integrated because we were forced to do business, employ, attend black schools, and simply kept it all in the community.  

    • KickWhitesOutAfrica

      It would be
      wonderful if just Oprah Winfrey and Jay-Z got together and held a press
      conference to address the black community about creating another Black Wall
      Street – an independent African-American city that thrives on non-approval from
      whites.  But sadly, that is unlikely to happen
      because mega rich Oprah Winfrey and Jay-Z are ADDICTED to the approval of white
      people.  Wealthy blacks in America are
      too adoringly engrossed with white people who say “You’re just like us” – it’s
      the golden acceptance they’ve worked so hard to achieve and attain.  When wealthy blacks look into the eyes of wealthy
      whites they see someone who has graciously accepted them for who they are irrespective
      of their “unfortunate” swarthy skin.  But
      when wealthy whites look into the eyes of wealthy blacks… all they see is an
      uppity n***** who got lucky.

      • DoinMe

        Wow! That’s pretty deep and you might be right.

  • LaLaLaMeansILoveYou

    Good point made but I honestly don’t see it (african americans’ need for approval/desire to fit into white society) ever coming to an end.

    They tell us our features are ugly and we chop off half our noses, lighten our skin, damage our hair attempting to straighten it or spend small fortunes on fake hair that does not grow out of our heads so that we can finally be “beautiful”.

    They tell us that “good” or “acceptable” names are Amber, Jennifer, Gavin, Mark, etc., and suddenly we are embarrassed and ashamed to name our children Tameka, Lakisha, or Trevon, because they are perceived as “ghetto” or out of fear that they won’t be able to get a job when they grow up…because a white person will see the name on the application and make assumptions leading them to dump it in the trash.

    We cannot wear certain clothes or jewelry because it is associated with being black and therefore “ghetto”. Even our music is watered down now in an attempt to “crossover” to the pop charts, instead of staying true to our soulful roots, which is what made our music so special in the first place and made other cultures want to steal from it.

    If a black male celebrity is dating a beautiful black woman, she is called a “regular” or “basic” chick (ala Lebron’s fiance’ Savannah), but if a black male celebrity is dating a woman of ANY race except full black, she is a “dime” or an “upgrade” from dating a black woman.

    Our thinking is so far gone that I really don’t see us ever coming out of this downward spiral that we’ve been on ever since the black power & “I’m Black and I’m Proud” days came to an end.

    • http://twitter.com/Superflythug Mongo Slade

      U make valid points

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1294119081 Fannelle FromNewyork

    Even though we have some affluent, powerful black people, the people with the most money are white people.  And as long as that is a fact, black people will always be concerned with having the approval of white people.  Look at the Obama’s.  Before President Obama was elected, his daughters wore braids!  Now you NEVER see them in braids.  Mrs. Obama and her daughters always have permed hair.   I’ve spoken to many attorneys who happen to be black and they always tell me how disapproving their white bosses are of dreadlocks and braids!  Most black people in general know that if they want to get a job they have to remove as much of their outward signs of “blackness” as possible. 

    • Moosegrl_86

      Their daughter’s don’t have perms. Look at the picture of them during easter. Sasha’s hair is natural and Malia’s was straightened. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FIN6IQP2R5QWALHVUDALMTLXAM MST2010

    I agree!  Who cares if black people are on the cover of a silly-azz magazine or an even dumber television show?  The only thing I’m worried about is acceptance from God!

  • Guest

    Wow, this is one of the best things I’ve read on Madame Noire in a while. Good stuff.

  • Truthhurtz

    Great article! Definitely something to ponder.

  • Nataliemalone85

    Excellent article!

  • Candacey Doris

    Rarely have i read an article here when i agree with everything written, but here it is.

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]