Was There No Better Way? Cops Cuff 6-Year-Old After Throwing Tantrum

April 18th, 2012 - By Brande Victorian

Source:Timesunion.com

A Milledgeville, Georgia, police chief is defending the handcuffing of a kindergartner last Friday as a necessary safety measure after she threw a tantrum in school.

According to a police report, 6-year-old Salecia Johnson  had a tantrum at her Creekside Elementary School that involved tearing items off the walls and throwing books and toys. A small shelf thrown by the girl reportedly struck the principal in the leg during the ruckus and Salecia is also said to have jumped on a paper shredder and attempted to break a glass frame. The school called police to handle the outburst and when an officer tried to calm the girl in the principal’s office, police say she resisted; therefore:

She “was restrained by placing her hands behind her back and handcuffed,” the report states.

A juvenile complaint was filed, accusing the girl of simple battery and damage to property and interim Police Chief Dray Swicord said it’s the police department’s policy to handcuff people when they are taken to the police station, regardless of their age.

According to Salecia’s aunt, Candace Ruff, when she and the girl’s mother went to pick her up, she was in a holding cell and complained about the handcuffs, saying they were really tight and hurt her wrists.

“She was so shaken up when we went there to pick her up,” Ruff said.

The police chief denied the claim and said the girl was taken to the police department’s squad room and not a holding cell, and that officers there tried to calm her and gave her a Coke.

Because of her actions, Salecia has been suspended from school and is not allowed to return again until August. Now the family is pushing for Georgia to change it’s handcuffing policy so that another child doesn’t endure the same treatment.

“We would not like to see this happen to another child, because it’s horrifying. It’s devastating,” Ruff told The Associated Press.

This isn’t the first instance of a young minor being cuffed for acting out in school, and the recent event is dredging up a nationwide debate on whether there is a better way to handle situations like this. Darrel Stephens, a former Charlotte, NC, police chief and executive director of the Major Cities Chiefs Association, told the Grio:

“I have had some concern for a while that the schools have relied a little too heavily on police officers to handle disciplinary problems.”

Shannon Kennedy, a civil rights attorney who has filed a class-action lawsuit against Albuquerque’s public school district and its police department, echoed that same sentiment, saying, “Kids are being arrested for being kids.”

Her suit was filed on behalf of hundreds of kids arrested for minor offenses over the past few years, including having cellphones in class, destroying a history book, and inflating a condom. One popular story that has made headlines is the case of a 13-year-old boy in Albuquerque who was reportedly arrested for burping in gym class.

While the lines have gotten so blurred that teachers trying to discipline students in school often want to rely on higher authorities to handle behavioral problems for threat of parent retaliation, locking kids up for silly things doesn’t send the right message. There has to be a better way to establish discipline among parents and school authorities without always looking to police.

What do you think about Salecia’s arrest and this general trend of handcuffing young kids for offenses in school?

Brande Victorian is a blogger and culture writer in New York City. Follower her on Twitter at @be_vic.

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Dagreen4

    I think they were right. That little girl was out of control and tried to play the victim when the parents came, and they fell right for it. She most likely has a behavior problem in school all the time

  • http://www.facebook.com/barbara.codner Barbara Codner

    Are Southern parents getting soft?  Back in the day, she would’ve picked out her switch and got 3 beatings when she got home.  #1: Mom #2: Dad #3: Aunt 

  • Lkhtpretty

    So sick of bad-ass little children and ineffective parenting. You can’t teacher over disruptive and defiant behaviors. Call the cops to cuff the parents and fine them for the damage she did to school property.

  • Trisha_B

    Its sad that people are just jumping to “arrest her!” w/ little information. How about what happened to make her spazz out? Did she just walk into the school tearing it up? Is this the 1st outburst she had? Or does she do this regularly? How is she any other day at school? Is she social or by herself? Why weren’t the parents contacted first? On another site they said the mother was called but they couldn’t get a hold of her, so why they didn’t they call the father (he was interviewed as well). Does she have a medical issue or disability? Does she take medication for anything that may deal w/ anger? What’s going on at home? Things going on at home could have messed her up & she took it out at school? She’s 6, those teachers couldn’t control her? I guess she turned into baby hulk & no one could hold her smh. There are so many missing holes in this & people are just agreeing its ok to arrest her. If this little girl has a history of acting out, her parents don’t discipline her, there’s no medical issues then i would understand the police involvement. But like i said there are missing pieces to the story that should have been stated for me to say this was the right choice smh

    • Martinlove56

      Ur right if it was there child they wouldn’t saying bad things about our babies going jail at such early age. This law was put in place to hurt certain kids. You all just don’t get it.

      • Ruby Reed

        If it was my son, I would beat his butt. I was a teacher and now I am a social worker. Kids behave differently sometimes when they get to school. I understand the school maybe went overboard, but you have to understand the liabilites and prcedures in place at schools.

        • Martinlove56

          Okeee.kid comes too school tells you da teacher or social worker his parents are beating him or her all da time ur job is to report this. If finding is true? Cps is called by you da teacher social worker cops are called parent go to jail. Trying to do da right thing.

    • Ruby Reed

      I honestly believe the police were called to “scare” the child. I do not believe they thought the little girl would continue to act up when she saw the police. Also, the mother said she has tantrums. I am not understanding the apathetic response from the parents.

  • Mommamichelle

    I have to agree with the school officials and the police in this case.  The child was beyond out of control.  She basically assaulted a school official and had the potential to do more harm to herself and others.  If she had injured another child during “tantrum”, then there would definetly been an arrest and lawsuits against the school.  Maybe being handcuffed and detained should have shaken her up.  This little girl needs to understand the consequences of her actions; something her parents obviously are not teaching her.  Instead of expending energy in getting the laws changed; the parents need to focus on why this child is so out of control.  This is the typical response of parents who are failing to do their jobs at home, and then expect the world to handle their “baby” with kid gloves.  Teachers and school officials are responsible for the education and safety of all of the children in their care.  If this girl’s family don’t want her treated like a criminal, then they should focus on changing her behavior.

    Also, if I were the principal that was hurt, I would file civil charges against the family.  These parent’s who send their little monsters to schools need to be held accountable for the problem children they have created.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1809982908 Anita Moorer

    I can’t imagine that this was the first outburst by this child.  I would like to know if a comprehensive evaluation was requested by the teacher/parent to assess the child for behavior issues.  There are many steps that a school can take before handcuffs.

  • StarFruit

    Ummmm, I’m sorry but 6yrs old is a little too old to be throwing a tantrum! Parents expect school officials to control their bad a$$ kids, but then they cry wolf when the control is in a manner that they don’t approve of. People please get your own children under control at home first! smh…

    • http://www.facebook.com/barbara.codner Barbara Codner

       I was thinking the same thing.  6 years old is a little too damn old to have tantrums!!

      • Martinlove56

        You’re a sick person that needs help.

  • Mioshi

    Oh well parents need to control their children……I am a teacher by the way.

  • Sophia

    Good kids too rude nowadays

  • Jcmitchell

    I dont know…I’m a teacher and all is we need is ONE.. just ONE example of some Bey Beys kid getting arrested for acting a dam* fool to set the whole school straight. Schools nowadays get more complaints about teachers taking away supply boxes and toys and other bs than educational issues.  Its a shame.  These behaviors set off the whole class and is a major distraction to the ones who want to learn.  If they can start to ticket these sorry parents for their baby acting up, then maybe it will help them to instill better behaviors at home before they get to a school.  I spend more time with behavior issues than I do teaching. Hot mess. 

  • Bear

    Being a teacher, I know all too well how students can become extremely aggressive and be downright rude. The administration and police did the right thing.  I can’t fathom how they were supposed to calm this child down if they didn’t restrain her.  The six year old had run a muck!  

  • Raquel

    I agree with the school and police handcuffing this child. Had the teachers or school done anything else to restrain her, the parents would have filed a lawsuit. We have backed ourselves into a corner with all the lawyers who are quick to file a lawsuit. Instead, why are we not addressing the PARENTS of this child who is acting crazy in school? Why is there no shame anymore? If I would have acted that way in school (which I did not) my parents would have whooped my butt first and asked questions later. I don’t know too many kids when I went to school who acted this crazy at 6 years old. That child needs more parent involvement and discipline. Quit blaming the school and police for having to restrain your out of control kid and take some responsibility.

  • Kenedy

    I agree with what the school authorities & police did. This child was physically threatening others by throwing ish around. The parents should be more concerned about their bad parenting than why the police handcuffed their child

  • Chicago’s Finest

    As usual we don’t have all the details regarding this story and can only give opinion based on the info that’s provided. Police Officers use handcuffs when they feel like either the child (in this situation) or others may be injured. And I would like to believe that they were more lenient in making that decision because of her age and that the handcuffs were used to avoid whipping her behind like she deserved. I think we’re focusing too much on her age, anyone would be appalled that a 6 year old was handcuffed, it just sounds wrong. Throwing a shelf, breaking glass, jumping on a shredder…she was a danger to herself and others. What if she had really hurt herself? What would the parents be saying then? Why did you allow my child to behave that way? Would you rather they locked her in a closet until her parents came? She was being disruptive to the environment. Should they have called child protective services? I don’t think calling the Police was an unreasonable thing to do based on the information that’s being given.

  • RahTruth

    Schools have every right to restrain a child who is a threat to his/her own safety and the safety of others. If a staff member would have touched her and accidentally put one scratch on her, the parents could sue. So, they did what they had to do.

  • Tiff

    In this particular case, I agree with school authorities and police.  I don’t think there should be a blanket policy regarding arresting kids because they don’t follow school policies, but in this case the child was causing considerable damage to school property, and injury to a school official and even fought the police officer when he tried to calm her down.  They tried to call her mother multiple times, but could not reach her.  I hope in all the anger the family is expressing toward the police, they are also taking the opportunity to correct Salecia’s behavior.

  • LippyLiz

    I believe the school official was right in calling the police and the officer was right in handcuffing her. Whether she was 6-years-old or not, there could have been further damage and possible injury to, not only the child herself, but the staff. Not to mention, if the Principal/teacher attempted to restrain her, the
    parent(s) would have been quick to scream “assault” or “unlawful
    handling of a child”. They may have even gone as far as to accuse them
    of fondling her. People fail to realize she may have learned a lesson, that should have been taught at home, so now she knows if she disrespects an authoritative figure, there will be consequences. She will also think about this the next time she gets into a position she doesn’t like and will react to it in a different manner. Teachers are overworked, underpaid, and risk their lives trying to make a way for children to have an education. This child was disrupting the education of her fellow classmates, so therefore was sent to the Principal’s office, and continued her tirade of ignorant and crass behavior. If she in fact does have behavioral issues, this should have been addressed by the parent(s) prior to her enrollment. If they did not know they need to find a doctor. If she always acts out, then this is a simple, and all too familiar, case of children not being disciplined well. Either because the parents are too young and irresponsible to raise them with any scruples or respect of their fellow man, or they’re raised by grandparents that are too old and possibly too unhealthy to properly raise a small child. She needs to respect her elders and authoritative figures before she grows up thinking this behavior is the norm or acceptable. Children especially need to respect the people trying to help them get an education that may lead to them become the next President, or even have a job in that matter. There are no laws for children in school settings, and obviously, the
    behavior policy is not being enforced or is not taken too seriously by
    the students. And anyone who tries to make this a race issue is reaching really far. I went to predominantly White schools my whole life and have seen just as many of them arrested, restrained, or put out of the school for behavior problems, drugs, and lack of participation. The Black community is always talking about “saving our sons” but what about our daughters?

    • StarFruit

      100% Co-sign

      • Cris1582

        Make that 200%

      • Cris1582

        Make that 200%

    • Martinlove56

      Ur a sick person probably don’t have kids. People like you value property over human life. You don’t cuff babies she don’t understand ..there are so many evil people in da world today. They’re our babies black or white.

      • Ruby Reed

        I have a child. And six year olds do understand. My three year old understands. Actions have consequences, children must learn that! Parents must learn to discipline their children… if you don’t police officers and corrections officers will.  America is getting away from Biblical principals telling you the responsibility of parents and children. This little girl destroyed furniture and property, and she injured the principal! Kids now days do not respect authority… their parents, teachers, police, etc. I wish my son would!! Then the parents obviously are not disciplining their child in any form…. The mom said I guess she was having a bad day. No ma’am, no ham, no turk!

        • Martinlove56

          You don’t get it …God forbid if ur kid act out get cuff sent too jail would you say ur bad parent. Picture this. Da law dosen aloud you to beat ur kids if so you go to jail you can’t win ..so when da kids act out they go too jail as a criminal. This law was design to hurt poor black kid’s .da parents don’t have rights anymore. But da police do. And turnaround an blame da parents.

          • Emm

            You are aware that there are better ways to discipline your child than “beat ur kids,” right? Because there are rules and regulations from the time you are born until the time you leave this earth. This situation was handled properly. The child wasn’t abused, she was taken out of a situation that she had gotten herself into. 

  • Charla

    The school shouldn’t have called the police because she is only 6. However, her behavior is beyond a typical temper tantrum that a child her age would throw. Maybe she has behavior problems and thus need a school that will better suit her needs. Teachers have between 20-30 students per class and aren’t their to teach your child how to behave in public. That is the parents job.

  • Guest

    Giving police the power to handcuff children has the potential for things to go a little overboard.  While I do believe most police officers are simply trying to do their job, as with any profession it just takes one to get too aggressive and for there to be a huge fallout.  In this case, although unfortunate, children must learn how to handle their own behavior.  While I agree that the discipline of a child who is hitting others and screaming when they do not get their way is not the job of the teacher or the police officers, I think many may fail to realize that the parents should be blamed for not giving this poor child such a lesson.  Perhaps if they had done so, she wouldn’t have been traumatized and had to endure this unfortunate situation.

  • PinkRunner

    School officials should not have called the police on this little girl. Instead they should have called her parents to kick her behind. See what happens when you “spare the rod?”

    • My3Cents

      Call her parents. The same parents that have been doing such a phenomenal job raising her, she was acting wild and crazy in school?. I was surprise about a 6 year old being handcuffed , i read the story and i was like, I have well behaved nieces and nephews and i do not want them around children like her for safety reasons  So yes, go ahead and handcuff her. If i was the parent i would be so embarrass, knowing my child was acting this bad to the point they had to call the cops. This situation speak volumes about your parenting style. Speaking of parents, where is the father?

      • Msmykimoto2u

        There is no reason to arrest a 6 yr old child unless they had a murder weapon….no reason and that is just sad

        • Cris1582

          There is plenty of reason to arrest a child if they are acting completely unruly and school officials can’t spank them so if you want to be a criminal then get treated like one.  If a grown woman came to your place of business acting like that I’m sure your “no murder weapon” rule would be right out the window.  People, even children need to take responsibility for their actions and live with consequences.

        • Cris1582

          There is plenty of reason to arrest a child if they are acting completely unruly and school officials can’t spank them so if you want to be a criminal then get treated like one.  If a grown woman came to your place of business acting like that I’m sure your “no murder weapon” rule would be right out the window.  People, even children need to take responsibility for their actions and live with consequences.

          • Msmykimoto2u

            You cant really compare the strength of a grown woman to that of a 6 yr old child. I dont think the time was taken to try and remove the child from class and calm her down. Seems to me like they just did what they could to remove her without really having to deal with her

    • Cris1582

      If you look at the story and the responses of the parents, I honestly doubt they would have done anything.  School officials are tired of being sued for having to be parents when parents just let their kids run wild.  

      If I was her mother I would spank her for getting into that situation and hide my face.  I wouldn’t dare want anyone to know my child acted that crazy in a public place.

    • Cris1582

      If you look at the story and the responses of the parents, I honestly doubt they would have done anything.  School officials are tired of being sued for having to be parents when parents just let their kids run wild.  

      If I was her mother I would spank her for getting into that situation and hide my face.  I wouldn’t dare want anyone to know my child acted that crazy in a public place.

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]