Sinead O’Connor’s Letter, Ghetto Court and What We Shouldn’t be Talking About

March 27th, 2012 - By Charing Ball

The uncomfortable truth is that the days of independent labels, radio stations and hip hop shows, which gave the Black Power movement a soundtrack in the 60s and a diverse voice to Black urban youth through hip hop in the 80s, are long gone. Today, everything is a conglomerate and those holding the purse strings on the airwaves and in the music industry are largely White folks, who have little to no connection to the very community they take the genre from.

And since the name of the game is profit, especially at a time when record companies are struggling to stay afloat, the formula to ensure that the industry stays relevant and that those dollars keep rolling, is to appeal to their core record buying audience, who too are mostly white, with what they want to hear.  Blacks rapping about guns, drugs and all the “Scarface” type stuff has much more appealing image than listening to them rap about Black consciousness. And unfortunately, to live comfortably and be successful, a lot of us buy into it too: whether we regularly consume it and start to believe that reality ourselves or if we go willingly to help produce these images for profit.

The whole thing reminds me of the old Dave Chapelle joke about the MTV coverage of the September 11tth terrorist attack and the cult of celebrities in which after any tragedy, we want to know what a celebrity thinks – even if it is Ja Rule. Said Chappelle: “Who give a F**k what Ja Rule thinks?! I don’t want to dance. I’m scared to death. I want some answers that Ja-Rule might not have right now. You think when bad Shyte happens I be the crib like, ‘Oh my God, this is terrible!  Can somebody please, find Ja Rule, get hold of this Mfer so I can make sense of all this?” I swear that is my favorite joke of all time.

Anyway, the point is that when stuff like the Trayvon Martin murder happens, I don’t really care what an Lil Wayne or Rick Ross have to say. I mean what could they say of importance, which would offer any insight beyond what their music already says? In fact, I would prefer that many of them don’t say anything. Or else we might have Soulja Boy thanking slave masters or T-Pain campaigning for Fox News again.

On the flip side of that, I didn’t want to see Kanye West dragged through the mud because he rightly pointed out the George Bush didn’t care about Black People.  Nor do I want to see Common being crucified as a militant Black terrorist because he  dropped Assata Shakur’s name in a song.  Because this too is what is likely to happen when a rapper breaks their silence and speaks openly and honestly about what we feel are the important issues right now.

What I find most ironic about this criticism on the rappers’ social responsibilities is how we readily miss, or ignore, obvious parallels to other ways in which our community remains silent. Like how our Black politicians will, on one hand, freely speak out about the degradation within the Black community and our responsibilities as people to fix it yet tread lightly – if not remain neutral – through discussions around race and racism and how that too has a hand in why our community is in the condition it is in today. Perhaps they are too opportunistic just like the rappers. Or maybe those same racial paradigms that hold rappers to fear of being marginalized in the industry are also the same conditions that hold politicians hostage to the fear of not being reelected. (Ahem Obama).

I think this is what irks me the most about O’Connor’s letter – more than how irked I am about Eric B new TV show, the shucking and jiving in hip hop and the virtual silence of our political leaders.  It’s that once again, when folks, our folks in particular, are trying to exercise their voices to bang on the very system that is denying Martin, and others like him, justice, here comes someone, particularly someone with no real connection to the community, derailing the conversation to speak about what she feels we need to focus on.  Ironically, nowhere in her letter was any sort of nod to all conscious rappers, who do speak up about the important issues in our community.  Talib Kweli, Common, Wyclef Jean, Yasiin Bey, aka Mos Def and many others have been delivering their own brand of conscious music for years. A number of rappers have created music inspired by the teenager’s murder by George Zimmerman including Jasiri X and even unlikely social commentator,  Plies, who released a “We are Trayvon” with proceeds going to the Martin family.  These artists and those types of songs don’t get spins on the radio or get featured on video countdown shows, and they don’t get mentioned in O’Connor’s letter either.

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5G3UV47TG33STBZQ5KY7GDTMHQ Astro

    Black on Black violence is rampant everywhere, including majority Black nations. In fact it can be worse… If the Black police ain’t killing, it’s the neighbours, or that taxi cab (go to the Caribbean away from the Tourist area) It’s a mess. What I hate is that we cry racism, but we cripples our own on so many level.

    The Trayvon case can only go one way. That killer has to go to jail though or I predict a riot.

  • Pingback: free emoticons

  • KickWhitesOutAfrica

    I have to dismiss the words of Sinead O’Connor because I don’t know
    what RAP has to do with the murder of Trayvon Martin. Besides, who is she to be
    dropping her “knowledge” on what black folks ought to be doing?  Ms O’Connor’s time would best be spent
    focussing on the Catholic/Protestant divide in Ireland.  In regards to Trayvon Martin, there are two questions
    that are not being brought to the fore. 
    The first question I asked when I heard about the murder of a young
    black boy in a white gated community was this: What was he doing in a WHITE
    gated community in the first place?  I
    have since learned that Trayvon was visiting his father who was at his fiancée’s
    house… which prompts my second question: In view that Trayvon’s father’s fiancée
    lives in a WHITE gated community… is Trayvon’s father’s fiancée a WHITE woman?  If the answer to this question is ‘YES’ then I
    put the blame for Trayvon’s murder squarely on his father, because if Trayvon’s
    father wasn’t dating a WHITE woman his son would not have been in a WHITE gated
    community to come face to face with a trigger happy racist and 17 year old Trayvon
    Martin would STILL BE ALIVE TODAY.

  • tsmith16789

    LOL…I find it interesting that whenever there are serious black issue such as the trayvon martin incident “THE OTHERS” are quick to blame hip-hop, hoodies and other things that have nothing to do with the fact that this child was racially profiled because of the color of his skin.

    Does black on black crime exist, Yes.  Does the hip-hop game need to be redefined, Yes.  These are things we are already aware of as a race and a nation. I believe “The OTHERS” want to take the heat off of the fact that when they see a blackman, regardless of the type of apparel he is wearing, he must be up to no good. he is trouble. I am a sr. software test engineer and when I am in meeting wearing a suit to meet outside vendors, I still get those looks like I am going to harm them when I just want to do my job PERIOD.

    My MESSAGE TO BLACKWOMEN: I know some of you guys are but please stand with blackmen on this issue.  lets get on the same page of racial equality and stand together on this tragic incident. The same way our parents and grandparent stood together during the jim crow era and the civil rights movement. lets not allow our petty differences divide us in our common goal to seek justice for the family of trayvon martin and countless other blackmen who have been killed base on idiotic perceptions and assumptions. We as blackmen love you, I love you and the GOD I serve put it best when He said a house divided cannot stand.

    Corporate Brother

  • Ifuaskme2

    She does not have to point out what few rappers are doing. She’s simply focusing on the problem. And Martin’s rally is not an example of black on black crime. In fact, the only rallies that get attention or support is white on black crime. Like 2PAC says…. ‘You better watch it or be a victim, in the white man’s world.’

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SCV2NFHLMLXKJSLD3UC5BCOAJ4 Lady Jane

    Many valid points were made in this article. I have not read Sinead O’Connor open letter, but it seems to bring out some valid points also. What Black America must realize is that the media and music industry want to publize every negative image they can promote. This image will give the racists and the bigots something to point at because they can no longer say that we are ignorant, lazy and every other lie they can conjure up. If the rich can keep the 99% fighting among themselves (poor whites and blacks) they can continue on their way hoarding the riches and the money. EVERYBODY needs to wake up and get a grip. I am not a fan of rap music or the fashions they promote, but the Judases will continue to take the money and the copy cat “thugs” be damned. It is all about the money.

  • Chanda

    On a lighter note, who would wanna appear on Ghetto Court? Seriously. Don’t we already have Maury?

  • Angelb_33

    Agree!!!  with 100% Sinead O’Connor message. can’t fault no one but ourselfs, and the leaders of today who is only all about a dollar. Pray the family soon have peace and closure, young trayvone resting.

  • Terry Jay

    What O’Connor is indirectly pointing out is that rapper’s are not being ‘paid’ to cater to the conscious, they are being ‘paid’ to cater to the market (money knows it’s market); and the ‘market’ is not, or is not interested in, being conscious of the problems that plague the black community. The market couldn’t care less about the problems that black people face daily, so the money flows where the market goes. But what’s most ironic is that rap’s beginnings were extremely conscious. The social consciousness of rap is what made it successful and acceptable. How can anyone expect rappers who only rap about money, ‘bling’, sex, and guns to be socially conscious? Their consciousness is lost in the pursuit for dead presidents. They have allowed themselves to be defined by those that hold the purse strings. Like those that control the industry, they have become desensitized and robotic. The mainstream market only wants to be entertained. If it’s not entertaining, they don’t want it. And the mainstream has always been fascinated by guns, money, and violence. While the negative messages that rappers currently communicate are destructive to the communities that they come from, the mainstream is being entertained and purse-holders are fat and happy. While the market changes over time, the problems that affect the black community have remained the same, and even worsened. And just as gangsta rap, and the violence it speaks of, has become the ‘face’ of Black America, others in society (especially those that don’t have a clue) view black males as the face of violence. O’connor’s message could be that it’s time for rappers to stop exploiting their own people and the youth that listen to their music. Instead, for them to use their talents to send messages that breath life (not death) into the community. Forget all the messages of materialistic gain. People and healthy communities are more important than material things. And if you support music that is not healthy for the spirit and that is not socially uplifting, you are contributing to the death of people who were beautifully created and naturally social.

  • Dcarter910

    Hey MN this article is a step in the right direction BUT….

    Why dont you have more articles on:
    1. The health care issue before the supreme court and what it means for black america (low quality coverage but higher taxes vs no coverage to expensive coverage)

    2. Black on black crime and “civil rights” “”leaders”’ not fighting nearly as hard to stop black on black crime which is the #1 killer black men and obstacle to over come toward social prosperity

    3. The impact of government debt and spending on the future viability of the country especially when you see Europe economically and socially falling apart for doing the same deficit spending america is doing now?

    Why supposedly socially conscience web forums like this one confine black awareness to basic relationship issues, entertainment news, and other semi-mundane issues that does not require deep intellectual debate and collective insight into national and international topics as if we;
    a. are too limited in our holistic view of society/world and the effects it will have on our communities
    b. those things are too difficult for us to understand and discuss as an intelligent segment of society

    Just asking…Tired of hearing about the Stars and relationships issues…blackmen and women alike can intellectually grow asymmetrically across a wide range of topics and geo-political issues.

  • Jolie

    It does make me angry when our entertainers are nowhere to be found when something like this happens but they were tweeting #KONY2012. In the 60′s to early 80′s our artists would have been in the streets! In this age there is just an absence of respect overall. Human life is treated like a game of Mortal Kombat, the title of President means a hill of beans, and we measure our intelligence by the ‘like’ and ‘rt’ button …I’m just disappointed.

    I just had to put this little blurb out there.

  • Love_Sexy

    She made a very good point.

  • Danielle Stevenson

    O’Connor didn’t mention 
    Talib Kweli, Common, Wyclef Jean, Mos Def and the other conscious rappers is because they don’t embrace the gangsta esthetic; they talk about more than strippers, hos, poppin bottles, etc. I agree with her and I think that, while it is a valid point, this wasn’t quite the time to make it. 

    • Love_Sexy

      I agree with you 100% about not being a good time to make such a point.

    • Mrsadkiah

      They may not embrace the gangsta esthetic but they are not angels. Common, Kweli and Mos Def  all have rapped about effing this b**** and getting brain from that h** and my money this and my lifestyle that. While they are typically more conscious and I prefer them to the Guccis, the Lil Waynes and the Young Jeezys, they are not innocent in this. 
      Rap music in general is not teaching good morals and values to our children. But it is not the job of the rappers to do so. 

  • Yolanda Penn

    You (the author) r prejudging E, not even giving him the respect tht he so deserves n has demostrated…u just assume, every black person will sell-out.

    Everytime something happens in the black community the media or some attention slore starts to blame it on rap as if rap is the only influence in the black community.

    Also the past doesnt matter at one time slaves wouldnt fight but look at us now. So stop bring up BBW, HWoA, there r other shows on tv that represent us. So stop acting like we cant think for ourselves.! Damn if u no linger believe in us get off our blog and we can stop supportn u, bc clearly u cant c the positive in us anymore! U had no solutions in ur article…..how r u helping

    • Ona2684

      I think you might be missing the point…

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1415696195 Calandrial PhoenixRising Afriy

    Wow!!! Not one darn comment. 

    Great article. I agree with many of your points.  I hope we can grow from the loss of Trayvon Martin’s life.  I pray his parents find some kind of peace.  I hate that this young man’s character is being muddied for typical teenage behavior – it should not lessen the impact or manner of his death.