Why Are We Expected To Line Up For Red Tails But Not Pariah?

January 17th, 2012 - By Charing Ball

"charing ball"I went to go see Pariah over the weekend and actually, I really enjoyed it.

The film, which was written and directed by Dee Rees (protégé of Spike Lee’s protégé’), is a coming of age story of Alike, a 17-year-old Black girl from Harlem coming to terms with her own sexual identity as a lesbian and must waver the waters between her conservative mother, played by Kim Wayans, and her contradictory father, played by Charles Parnell. The film has been getting lots of praise for highlighting the invisible voice of black female queers in the community; however, the intense and strained relationship between mother and daughter has such a universal theme, which makes it relatable to just about anyone, who once struggled in their youth.

Yet the awesomeness of Pariah has been pretty much been overshadowed by the hype over Red Tails.  Despite the film, which centers on the plight and fight of the Tuskegee airmen, being well in the works for well over two decades, the hype around it didn’t start until recently, when folks began to spread the fear of God that if the film is not a box office success than all hope for the future of black films is doomed.

It all started when George Lucas, the Star Wars guy and creator and financier of Red Tails, appeared on The Daily Show to promote the film and started talking about racism in Hollywood.  In a follow up interview, Lucas hinted that if Red Tails was a failure, it could have negative repercussions for black filmmakers: “I realize that by accident I’ve now put the black film community at risk [with Red Tails, whose $58 million budget far exceeds typical all-black productions],” he said. “I’m saying, if this doesn’t work, there’s a good chance you’ll stay where you are for quite a while. It’ll be harder for you guys to break out of that [lower-budget] mold. But if I can break through with this movie, then hopefully there will be someone else out there saying let’s make a prequel and sequel, and soon you have more Tyler Perrys out there.”

Oh great, more Tyler Perrys.

Interesting enough, Red Tails was created by the same guy who brought us Jar Jar Binks, the computer-animated character who appeared in the Star Wars prequels and which generated much controversy over its racially charged, Rastafarian mimicry.   So why there is such a heavy emphasis on supporting Lucas’ Red Tails while genuine black films like Pariah are left to their own devices?

First off, I take issue with what is essentially has been a fear and race-based marketing campaign by Lucas to persuade moviegoers, particularly Black moviegoers, to see this film. We are told that if it would be the end of Black filmmaking as we know it. Never mind, if the film is interesting or compelling or even entertaining. We have a racial duty to unite to see this film or else we make Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. weep?

And never mind that Hollywood has been operating with the same M.O. for decades and decades. The industry will not likely change even if the film magically breaks box office records, which it will probably not. Why? Well stories told from the black perceptive have always had trouble finding dedicated audiences outside of the community. Point blank, the mainstream is less inclined to see films featuring black actors. And if we are to go on the long rationalized reason that Hollywood is a business, than we can be certain that Red Tails, even if it is moderately successful, will not inspire the business to take a chance on us.

But of course, Black filmmakers have known this little secret, which Lucas appeared to just discover, for years. This might explain why Black filmmakers haven’t been waiting around for Hollywood to give the proverbial green light to make and finance their own films. They may not get the big audiences and big box office numbers as their mainstream counterparts but the lack of financial support from inside tinsel town isn’t stopping brothers and sisters from picking up cameras.

However, all may not be lost in the world of Black filmmaking if Red Tails tanks. As reported, Rees is currently working on a project for HBO that will feature actress Viola Davis and a thriller flick called “Bolo.” And on Sunday night, Pariah received a special shout-out at the Golden Globes by legendary film actress Meryl Streep. Likewise the African-American Film Festival Releasing Movement, also known as AFFRM, has been steadily pushing for the theatrical release of quality independent African-American films through simultaneous limited engagements in select cities including I Will Follow and Kinyarwanda.  In short, the future of Black film – with or without the success of Red Tails – will survive.

Don’t get me wrong, I appreciate the effort of Lucas to bring more Black films, or at the very least a black film funded by a white man, to the big screen, but if this flops, I think it is less likely that we can count on him bringing a sequel to the screen. And that is all. So folks can stop with the “must read” emails and Facebook invites for bus trips to the movie theater. There is no more of a moral obligation to see this flick as there would be for any other mainstream film, which lets us carry the lead.

Long gone are the days that we should have to feel a need to prove anything to Hollywood.  If anything, it is the reverse.  And if Hollywood is as racist as we all know it is why should we feel the need to let the decision of what images gets green-lighted continue to be placed in the hands of those, who don’t see us as human beings? I mean, the last time Hollywood took interest in the black market we got a bunch of one-dimensional Blaxiploitation and gangster flicks in both the 70s and in the 90s.

Instead let’s throw our support – and dollars – behind filmmakers, who continue to make conscious efforts to not only make films despite not having the blessings of mainstream Hollywood but make good films period.

Charing Ball is the author of the blog People, Places & Things.

 

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Melissa

    A different issue – only touched upon here, but brought up more extensively in other discussions of Mr. Lucas’ behavior – is the fact that there is an assumption that white people won’t see films with majority black casts, or films with black-centric themes (not always one and the same.)  I tend to disagree; I don’t think I’m exceptional in any way, and I am a Caucasian female interested in such films. However, I find that if I attend such films alone, I attract a lot of negative attention from other moviegoers who are not Caucasian. Sometimes, thought not always, it’s not just “hmm, wonder what she is doing here” but “how DARE she.” I’ve noticed that it depends on where the venue is.  More “indie style” films such as Precious or Pariah are often found at theaters that focus on such films, and I’ve found those theaters more racially mixed and my presence there unremarkable. However, going to see something such as “The Best Man” or “Love and Basketball” at a mainstream theater, the audience was almost exclusively black and I got some negative attention.  Some people merely looked surprised to see me (someone like me), but other people definitely seemed displeased. I’m not a shrinking violet but on the other hand I’m not interested in too much hassle, especially as it’s not my intention to infringe on other people’s comfort or enjoyment. I admit these experiences have made me more cautious about going to see certain films in the theater. I am reminded of going to see step contests in college years ago. I’d never heard of them and my black girlfriends were happy to take me and introduce me to the fun. But some of their sorority sisters were plenty pissed off about it and weren’t shy about showing it. I wonder how many other Caucasian people would rather watch on DVD than see a movie in the theater for such a reason?

  • Pingback: Red Tails, Not the Silver Bullet of Racism « No Tsuris

  • Samjetjr

    R U serious? First of all, no one is forcing anyone to see anything. Red Tails is based on factual events. It’s not a “Black” movie. It’s a movie about a squadron of black men who fought valiantly to protect the country that continued to oppress them despite their bravery to do what no white man would. Personally, I am glad the story is being told, no matter the color of the producer. It is history that has been kept from us for decades. So why not support it, why not go see it, why not take your son or daughter with you, so they can see the truth about what real bravery is, what a real hero is. Not Kobe Bryant, not Lebron James, not Michael Jordan, or any number of other athlete’s of every color, that have been branded and looked upon as heros. And you are comparing it to a well written, well acted movie about a 17 year old lesbian in harlem who is coming to terms with her sexuality. HUH?!?! 17 year old lesbian? That’s what you think we should take or daughters or sons to see? Not yet seasoned enough to know much about anything, yet she knows she is a lesbian….smh. My point is, just because a film is written, produced, or directed by an african american should we support it. Every film I belive should be taken for what it is. A good film is a good film, a bad film is a bad film. No matter the color behind the camera. These two films are not of the same genre, and should not even be mentioned in the same sentence. That’s my opinion…..

  • Ericasmi36

    Support our heroes who
    serving our nation. Support our troops that safeguard our safety. A good place
    tailor-made for personnel in uniform:uniformedkiss*C0*M. It brings together those working in professions
    such as the armed forces, police, navy, security, medical, ambulance, prison,
    air crew and fire fighters, for friendship, love, romance, marriage and even
    more.

  • Pingback: Links of Great Interest: Everybody wanna have a good time — The Hathor Legacy

  • Garret Davis

    First of all using the word queer in this article seemed a lil odd but I digress, I get a bit tired of the works black film when we are humans and just because there .might be a plethora of black humans in a film why is it a black film instead of a story about people who happen tip be black.When we go see films with white people in them are they called white films.We pay right into the hands of the people who tell us our sorties and the films that have us in them, that they don’t sell overseas.One of the very reasons that you liked Pariah was because this story crossed all color lines, this story could have happened in any race of people.Instead of making black films we should make films about our experiences period.Let me add that one of the reasons Red Tails was asn important film to see was because of its chronicling of the history men who were denied their rightful place on or history books.Yet I do age that all our stories are important and valid.

    • Samjetjr

      Read my comment

  • http://twitter.com/EchoedNightmare Lil’ Miss Nightmare

    It’s interesting to think that you have to have money to make an impact in the movie business. Yes, lots of money to make a film will make it a heavier marketed movie, & have all the glitz of hollywood, but it doesn’t make a bigger impact than a lower budget movie. Most of my favorite movie are low budget films that have become cult classics. And there has been more than one big budget hollywood film that went down in flames.
    Before this article I have never heard of Pariah, but because of some of the content described in this article I will probably make the effort to see it, not because of the George Lucas, big money, or making Dr. King weep talk, but showing an honest portrayal of homosexuality in the African American culture is something, I believe, is worth seeing & knowing more about. 

  • Omega64

    Red Tails is a part of our history, if not for this movie
    our story will fade into obscurity in the next 15 years, why? because all of
    the men who lived the movies (Tuskegee Airmen) will be gone and with them there
    story that played a great part in American History. This not casting any disparagements
    on Lakeshia, it just shows how limit some of her generation is when it comes to
    knowing  the contributions of the African
    Americans to America and the world. The first African American to be granted a pilot’s
    license in was a women (Bessie Colemen) that might be good for the younger
    generation to know.  

  • Priscilla

    This article is so negative and counter-productive. “We” are where we are because of this type of thinking. Speak life. If you want to promote Pariah or other “black” films, do it. But leave the negativity out… We all know what happens to crabs in a bucket. Smh.

  • Priscilla

    This article is so negative and counter-productive. “We” are where we are because of this type of thinking. Speak life. If you want to promote Pariah or other “black” films, do it. But leave the negativity out… We all know what happens to crabs in a bucket. Smh.

    • Samjetjr

      Read my comment

  • Msolankeuk

    very well said.  I saw an email proporting to be from Tyler Perry about this and encouraging black folk to go see the Lucas film.  It came across to me as a scare mongering marketing ploy. Those white folk who claim to be progressive should encourage their communities to support black films.  If he’s not doing so already perhaps Mr Lucas should invest some time and energy doing this with his peers and contacts …..

  • Snow’s Cousin Ice Train

    Well, Pariah sounds…boring. Sorry, but regardless of who made it, Red Tails sounds more like my kind of movie.

  • http://twitter.com/freekeith Keith Gill

    I dig the piece and I agree with most of your points however I would say that it is important to note that Hollywood is a business. As such the respond to condumer markets. If Hollywood really is racist then its because the consumer market is inherently racist.
    Red Tails being a box office success does alot for what Hollywood sees as  a ”market” for serious Black films. If it translates to dollars for the big movie houses then it helps give legitimate black filmakers a better oportunity to have their work get to a bigger stage….. Yeah so the success of a this very big budget film has reprocussions that can be very beneficial for the likes of Dees Rees.
    Plus in supporting a movie like Red Tails you are also supporting the talented Black Actors that find it increasingly difficult to get quality roled in Hollywood. 

  • Yellowtiger

    Why is it that black people over analyze everything!  It really makes me sick sometimes.  As an African -American woman, I have had my shares of side eyes and smdh, especially when it comes to some of the crap the Hollywood puts out (White Chicks anyone?) on just the assumption that black folks only like funny, stupid,silly and sometimes downright offensive s***. (Soul Plane) But this movie, Red Tails, has the naysayers coming out of the woodworks.  Asking questions like “Why should I go see it?” blah blah blah, snarl, frown, stomps feet like small child. Stop over analyzing the message and just be comfortable in knowing that some of us would like to see a movie that does not make our I.Q drop.