Landlord Fights “White Only” Pool Sign Discrimination Ruling

December 14th, 2011 - By Brande Victorian

I’m having déjà vu reading about the case of a white Cincinnati resident who is attempting to put the city right back in Jim Crow era with her discriminatory pool policy. On Sept. 29, the Ohio Civil Rights Commission found landlord Jamie Hein to be in violation of the Ohio Civil Rights Act when she posted an iron sign that read “Public Swimming Pool, White Only” at her duplex. Now Hein wants the commission to reconsider its decision.

The landlord posted the sign when a black teenage girl was visiting her parents who lived in the complex. Hein indicated the move was necessary because the girl used chemicals in her hair that would make the pool “cloudy,” according to the commission.

Parents of the teenager filed a discrimination charge with the commission and moved out of the duplex, and the commission determined that the sign “restricts the social interaction between Caucasians and African-Americans and reinforces discriminatory actions aimed at oppressing people of color.” Still, the organization is obligated to hear Hein’s request for reconsideration.

One summer when I came home from college, I invited three of my friends to go swimming in the pool complex where my mother lived. Almost immediately a white woman came over to me and asked what I was doing there and demanded to see my pool pass, which my mom neglected to tell me I needed. I was then asked a series of questions about where I lived, who my parents were, and whether they rented or owned a condominium there. After the interrogation subsided and I voiced my opinion about their obvious race policing, one woman told me, “we just had to make sure you belong; and now it’s your job to do the same when you see people you don’t think belong here.” Anger was not the word for how I felt at the time. A former black coworker of mine also told me that one of her white friends asked that her husband not swim in their pool because of the products he puts in his hair.

I’m not sure what leg Hein has to stand on in trying to prove her actions weren’t discriminatory. If the commissioners uphold their original finding, the case would be referred to the Ohio attorney general’s office, which would represent the commission’s findings before an administrative law judge. Penalties in the case could include a cease-and-desist order and even punitive damages to be determined by the administrative law judge. Parties could still reach a settlement before resorting to legal action, though, commission spokeswoman Brandi Martin said.

Have you ever had an incident like this happen at a public or residential pool?

Brande Victorian is a blogger and culture writer in New York City. Follower her on Twitter at @be_vic.

More on Madame Noire!

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Angelsong

    I will say, and I am a former Northeastern Ohio Native, Ohio is one of the most racist states in the North . Period. I lived most of my life ( except a few years in Boston ) on the East Side Suburbs of Cleveland, and the last few in Ashtabula ( the largest, poorest, 98% white county in the state). They call people of color  ’colored”-  not just the old folks, the people in their 20′s !!! They are so angry about affirmative action, supervisors of color, and people with teeth. These , once again , are the young people. They have one bad street- not neighborhood- and almost all the Black crime happens there. Now there is plenty of theft, robberies and murders etc, all over the rest of the county committed by whites. It has also been recently doc. as one of the Meth capitals in the USA. But this very ‘Christian” community will quote the Bible ” you should stay with your own kind” , like to date/marry a person of color is dating out of the Human race. This was not years ago- this was in 2011. The whites are extremely uneducated and really don’t care, they feel as long as they are white they are all right. I am mixed and when I went to the hospital they would write me as white , I would correct them , but this happened again and again, because they wanted to like me, but they couldn’t bring themselves to like me if I was “colored”. Now this is not to to say that there were not nice, wonderful people there too but they were few and far between. I know as you read this you think I am exaggerating, if I didn’t live it I would not believe it myself. I could write a book. And that pool thing is NOT an isolated incident. Some one needs to do a study on this , how there could be a place that is run like a racist Mayberry circa 1950 in 2011. Pathetic……

  • Zw

    Wow this lady, obviously she’s a bigot, people of all races put some type of chemical in their hair, what about all the holding sprays, spritz, and gels that not only black people use but white people as well.

  • guest

    I’m white, conservative, some might call me a ‘right-winged fundamentalist’ but I find this sign extremely offensive.  This is so wrong and when oh when people are we going to get over ourselves and learn to appreciate each other for our differences?

  • Blahblah

    racist or not, it was a sign on PRIVATE property. 

    • Google Is Your Friend

      Familiarize yourself with federal civil rights laws before you post a comment.

  • msMaKi

    most of the pools i’ve been to make you rinse your self BEFORE getting in. its to remove excess oil’s/lotion/dirt/etc on your body and in your hair.  Black people are definitely NOT the only ones who use products in their hair…my daughter (we are hispanic/polynesian) uses product in her hair daily cuz its a nappy mess if we let it go…i agree the landlord was wrong…but it also seems to me the author is a cry baby and always wants to talk about race…in this world it is only about black and white…but i NEVER hear anyone sticking up for the brown people in between…maybe if our world thought in the present instead of what happened in the past, we’d get along much better.

  • Wesleyan

    Isn’t that the point of chlorine, chemicals and filtration systems in pools in the first place. If one girls hair chemicals can make a pool cloudy then that pool isn’t fit for anyone to swim in because they’re obviously not doing their job with the filtration system. FYI Black people aren’t the only people who put chemicals in their hair especially with the Brazilian Keratin Treatments and other advanced technology processes for hair today.

  • B Lloyd94

    It’s not hard to believe rhat such racial b.s. is still issued out in communities all over the world, but when one is given an actual name that’s promoting racism, it’s pretty easy to take care of. See you later Jamie, can’t wait to talk.

    • Capiscan

      I can’t believe that Mrs. Hein is stupid enough to appeal.  Seiously?

    • LisaLuvless

      Promoting racism? Or did I say motivated by racism. Two very different words. Hope you’re comment wasn’t based off of my comment to the blogger.

  • Burito9245

    we still have a long way to go.

    • Caribbean in the house.

      because your a puzzy thats why.

      • sofie212

        CARIBE1
        I highly suggest that you obtain a GED along with an American English dictionary before replying to comments on this article. The stench of your ignorance is overwhelming.

  • Caribe1

    aha, its good for you dumb afro-american negro. thats right white people let them know they are not wanted. f*ck dr.martin luther king.

    • guest

      I dare you to walk up to a black person and say what you just posted.  Doubt if you would because most of you idiots are cowards hiding behind your computer.

      • Caribbean in the house

        i did that already & i told him eff the naacp & the civil rights leader & al sharpton in new york plenty of time. i am not afraid of no negro who is afraid of the white man known as your masters. bring the war on puzzy negros, i have my high powered weapon [not your daily afro-american 9mm gun you people use in the hoods] ready & go. & when you die & go to the other side tell dr.king i said he’s a puzzy too & that corny “we shall over come song is a weak lyrics”. i tried to hang a negro one time in a fight but i felt sorry for the puzzy. bring the war on anytime.

      • Caribbean in the house

        lets start a racial war puzzy & go run to you puzzy naacp & your civil rights leader. if whites already started a racial war with you negros then lets start another one. i would love to gun down your little ones too so they won’t grow up to be a nuisance to the white man. you said i hide behind a computer then come & meet me in hempstead longisland n.y. 115550. even the nassau county police can’t save you.

        • Caribbean in the house

          i meant 11550

      • Grfd703

        Don’t feed the troll.  He’s just trying to incite a reaction.  I’m a 45 year old white guy who is disgusted by asshats like this one.  The pool owner has the right to REQUIRE people to shower and/or rinse off prior to entering the pool.  To exclude anyone on the basis of their race is just wrong.  What if the non-white person has no hair?  This woman is an idiot.  Or just a bald-faced racist using a pool as her catalyst for practicing racism.  Disgusting.  

    • Lola21

      You white cracker, thats why all yall smell like wet dogs 

  • LisaLuvless

    I’m starting to get the feeling you’re motivated by racism and discrimination. All your posts have the same moral undertone.

    • sophie

      What exactly is “moral,” about obvious racial discrimination? 

      • LisaLuvless

        The fact that it’s immoral. All Brande Victorian posts.
        I am not discusssing the actual article at all, I’m speaking of her.

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]