Street Lit Debate: Does Urban Fiction Undermine the Black Canon?

July 26th, 2011 - By TheEditor

With four titles to his credit, L says his latest novel Represent — featuring a character sentenced to life in prison — may be perceived as street lit, but “I feel, personally, it’s not.” He recognizes street lit is often characterized by storylines “about growing up in the streets, or maybe coming out of jail, or getting ready to go to jail, or some type of illegal activity,“ but L, a trained social worker, asserts his plots and characters are born of hours of field research and interviews.

Rather than seeing it as limiting, Tinesha Davis defends the term ‘street lit,’ taking umbrage with the racism and self-hate implied in seeing the label as a stigma. “We [as black people] have this love-hate relationship with ourselves,” she asserts. “As soon as it’s not approved of, [we say] ‘They’re not ‘street lit’ books… I want to be affiliated with the more highbrow, educated writers.’”

But, as a kid Davis loved street lit, listing James de Jongh’s City Cool: A Ritual of Belonging and Ann Petry’s The Street as her favorites “simply because they spoke to the experiences I had when I was younger.” For this reason, though book club and seller Black Expressions bought her novel Holler at the Moon as literary fiction, Davis says wanted it to be classified as street lit. “[The realities depicted in street lit books are] a piece of America’s story and we can’t dismiss it.”

Stacey Barney, an editor at Penguin Group and the editor of Maldonado’s book, says street lit has evolved quite a bit from the days of Iceberg Slim.  “There’s something of a redefining going on,” she explains.  “There’s something emerging called urban literature.” She further elucidates, “[It] takes place in an urban landscape, but it doesn’t necessarily have the same spree of violence that ‘street lit’ has. But it’s not watered down in any way. It’s very real.”

Maldonado — who also teaches sixth and seventh grade history and has three years’ experience training teachers and administrators to implement conflict resolution programs — adds, “I write my books to present real problems that have people stuck, and then have these characters work out and develop new solutions to create new realities for themselves.”

For bestselling author Victoria Christopher Murray who also sets her books in urban areas, Maldonado’s commitment to moving beyond the hopeless depiction of the struggles of the urban poor is key. “My parents taught me [reading] was to expand my mind; expand my experiences… so what worries me,” she says, “is that [street lit] keeps people stuck in the same place, with the same stories over and over.”

Of urban-themed books that don’t have any redemptive quality, Murray says, “I wouldn’t even call it literature.” She continues, “100 years from now when people look back to what we were writing and what we were reading, I don’t want this to be a representation of who we are.”

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Pingback: Self-Publishing Finally Gets Its Respect « people who write

  • Wolfgang Smith

    The street lit debate reminds of the “gangsta rap” vs. “conscious rap” debate of the 90s.

    If MORE Black readers supported Black authors from OTHER genres, we wouldn’t have articles like this.

    Real talk.

    It’s a double edge sword because hood books are a form of escapism while others books from different genres are ignored by the Black demographic for the most part.

    It boils down to the purchasing habits of the reader…we live in a capitalistic society…if readers want more of a variety from Black authors, they should SUPPORT the alternative instead of complaining.

  • Itsthatgirlz

    I agree with Roy. My big problem with urban/street lit – I call them hood books – is that there are too many of them that are terribly written. Its not worth the effort to pick through all the trash that gets published to find the gems. I feel like a big problem is when the books get self published, they don't go through the editing and rewriting process, which are the most important parts of writing. I admit, the subject matter isn't my favorite, but every once in a while I can get into it, if its done well. Its just too hard to find it done well among hood books.

  • IHateRealityTV

    In my opinion, I think the so called "street lit" can be repetitive in the story lines, but if done correctly can be just as entertaining and thought provoking. My grief is not only the repetive story lines but more so the lack of originality. I dont think that African American writers should remove themselves from this genre, but they def. should focus on doing it in a different way. Im one of those people who would read almost anything and I never limit myself to a certain style of writing, genre, specific writers (african-american), but some do. I think "street lit" is away to get people into reading period.

  • NoReally

    It is what it is…at least black folks are reading. ..lol…admittedly I love my “street lit” but sometimes it does start having the same story lines…girls who love thugs who love drugs and guns….but I love me some chunichi, teri woods, noire, danielle santiago, and ashley and jaquavis, etc

  • Fulcrcle

    I agree with you Roy. Whether I'm walking in a brick and mortar bookstore or browing e-books for my kindle, the market is oversaturated with the same urban fiction themes. They're all about drugs, drug dealers, designer clothes and dime pieces. The grammar and editing is horrible! These books are only worth 99 cents and I refuse to purchase them period! I have stopped looking at these books and moved toward non-fiction and African American paranormal just to get away from it.

  • http://www.roypickering.net Roy Pickering

    Does Urban Fiction Undermine the Black Canon? Yes it does somewhat because there is so much of it, with a high percentage of it not being very well written. If there was balance to what was being published that would be fine. So called Urban Fiction would be but one genre among the mix, if not adding much to the canon then at least not subtracting from it. But if the vast majority of books by black authors put out each year are a) poorly written regardless of whether self pubbed or not b) covering a pretty narrow range of subject matter, and c) the range of topics consists of nothing particularly positive, thus reinforcing negative stereotypes, basically gangsta rap hip hop videos in book form, then this is a problem in need of fixing. I don't fault the authors though. They're just hustling to make a dollar out of 15 cents. The mainstream publishing industry needs to get its head screwed on right. But I don't totally fault them either because money talks. The major industry players will publish what people are buying and reject what people are ignoring regardless of quality/merit.

    • Royal Chocolate

      You are correct but I just love reading these.

      And not just this type of stuff, I just finished Isabel Wilkerson's The Warmth of Other Suns so my literary interests vary. But like you said, "money talks."

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]