The Fly Jock’s Beef with Smiley and West

July 7th, 2011 - By TheEditor

"Yvette Carnell "Stop the presses and mark the day. On July 1st, media personality Tom Joyner -chief peddler  of the culture of consumerism in the black community-took a break from picking the pockets of black people to blast his former aces Cornel West and Tavis Smiley. And get this, Smiley and West hadn’t even done anything wrong.  That didn’t stop Joyner from holding them responsible – with a straight face no less – for MSNBC contributor Mark Halprin calling President Obama a package on the air.

Those who know the history between Smiley and Joyner know that Tom “buy my cruise tickets” Joyner has been nursing his wounded ego ever since Smiley bolted from his hee-haw show back in 2008.  The problem: Smiley didn’t seal his goodbye with a butt kiss.

Smiley, however, made up for his oversight in a Huffington Post op-ed in which he professed his undying adoration for Joyner and confessed that he “would take a bullet for Tom Joyner.” How ironic is it that the man who affectionately disclosed that he would take a bullet for Joyner is now defending against pot shots from that very same man?

In Joyner’s op-ed, he said of Smiley and West that “these two have done much worse than what Halperin has done because they set the tone for it, opened the door to it, and must take much of the blame for creating a climate that would make a white, professional journalist feel comfortable verbally and vulgarly attacking the first black president of the United States.”

Well this may come as a shocker to Joyner, but privileged white men have called black men much worse before, both in public and private.  Rarely have entitled members of the privileged class shrank from an opportunity to diminish people of color. Does the “N” word ring a bell? The idea that a privileged hack such as Halprin needed the door to be opened by two black men in order for him to feel comfortable insulting another black man is as moronic as it is incongruent. What’s next? Was tribal strife in Africa an invitation to slavery? Did the beef between Nas and Jay-Z spark police brutality?

Joyner thrashes on a bit more to make incompatible ends meet when he concludes that “a well respected journalist” like Halprin wouldn’t have insulted Obama were the stage not already set by West and Smiley. What I wonder is who told the “Fly Jock” that Halprin was ever a “well respected journalist”?  Halprin has always worshiped at the feet of right-wing bottom feeders like Karl Rove and Matt Drudge. He’s a thoughtless self-promoter who spit shines the shoes of the collective republican establishment.  Replace the word republican with democrat and Joyner should see his own reflection.

Truth is, Joyner’s been itching for an opportunity to get back at his homeboys for abandoning ship and curiously, he’s obtuse enough to admit it. In his belated Dear John letter to Smiley, he said he’d previously wrote a blog piece about Smiley but was wanting to pepper it with harsher language before publishing it,  and was waiting for the opportune moment to spring it on his former side-kick.    Hell hath no fury like a hustler scorned.

But Joyner completely eviscerates his own credibility and eliminates in our minds any possibility that he is capable of having an honest exchange when he accused Smiley of “selling books” as his chief goal. This is not to say that Smiley doesn’t have promoting books that he either writes or publishes as his goal. But if it is true that Smiley is a hustler who’s selling out his community, it is just as true that he learned it all at the feet of his mentor Tom Joyner.

On the homepage of Tom Joyner’s marketing company Reach Media, right beside Joyner’s broad watermelon smile, are statistics which boast that Joyner has the ear of 1 in 4 African Americans. Want to market some nonsense to the African American community? Joyner promises to promote it in a way that “drives results”. He’s got your back as long as he gets his cut.

Reach Media demonstrates that Tom Joyner is engaged in a barefaced lie when he pretends to be offended by those, such as Smiley, whose goal it is to profit off the African American community. To the contrary, Joyner was a trailblazer in this regard.

And Joyner’s offense at Smiley and West’s criticisms of the President is equally baseless since neither Smiley nor West have substantially changed their tones since 2008 or used offensive language to describe the President or his policies.

It comes as no surprise that Joyner’s painstakingly contrived outrage comes during the run-up to the 2012 election. Like Al Sharpton, Joyner is a pit bull for the President and an advocate for the administration, and that’s fine. But if Joyner wants to convince naysayers that Obama deserves a second term, he should focus on policy instead of personality. Rehashing beef from 2007 is a smoke screen which doesn’t go far to address the issues raised by Smiley and West. And unless Joyner can do that, he should just go back to selling cruise ship tickets because he’s not adding anything to the national debate that we should be having. I know the man likes to hear himself talk, but this time Joyner is clearly out of his league, and since Smiley isn’t there to spoon feed him political theory and explain it in a way that he can understand, it’s best that he just hush.

Yvette Carnell is a former Capitol Hill Staffer turned political blogger. She currently publishes two blogs, Spatterblog.com and BreakingBrown.com.

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • Loyal Cruiser

    Awe, someone didn't get invited on the cruise?

  • TeeGee

    This is just one person's opinion…seems biased…

  • what?

    That was a bad choice of articles and really you are not a good journalist. It appears you want to get some status by shuffling words such as the Tea Party and Fox news. Go back and get some a bit of integrity to your writing.

  • miles-scott

    WHY IS PRESIDENT OBAMA WALKING AROUND WITH MATCHES IN HIS POCKET? WHO KNEW THIS EX-SMOKING PRESIDENT WOULD BECOME ARSONIST TO DEMOCRATIC VALUES LIKE SOCIAL SECURITY, MEDICARE, AND MEDICAID. WHO KNEW HE WOULD BE SENDING UP TRIAL BALLOONS FILL WITH KEROSENE.WILL SOMEONE OR ANYONE PLEASE GIVE HIM HIS CIGARETTE BACK BEFORE THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY BECOMES ASHES UNDER HIS LEADERSHIP.

  • Adele

    Yvette Carnell, Do you ever have anything positive to say? Not one to be the life of the party huh? (don't worry I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and keep searching – but I have have one lifetime)

  • Bebops the Baker

    Wonder how long it'll take the "site admins" to allow a post to go through…

  • Lionel

    I like the way you write! And this time I agree with you.

  • Roderick

    Yvette, when I meet you I will kiss your hand and tip my hat to you. You articulated your points perfectly and all your facts were in order. Sure the Obamites are throwing a tantrum, but the truth is the truth. Smiley did leave Joyner's show on his own while Tom asked him to stay. They think that everyone black who doesn't kiss Obama's pinkey-ring is a hater which clearly speaks to their level of politcal sophistication and they can't stand that Smiley writes books cause most of them can barely read. Please don't let these clowns get in the way of you saying what needs to be said.

  • Truthseeker

    How about this. Let us all stop criticizing either party and do something! I'm so tired of Black people talking and NEVER doing anything about anything! I have no criticism towards any individual. My only comment is for us to do something. That is all. Say what you want, but every person mentioned in this article is actually doing something tangible for our community right now! I refuse to believe the hype of this situation and I also believe that even in their disagreements, all of these men are still great friends! Stop trying to make something out of nothing. People with maturity disagree, in love, all the time. :-/

  • blk bandit

    Wow! The Obama bots are in full effect here and their vitriol in this comment section is embarrassing

  • RIQ

    It's refreshing to see someone take one of the Obama Pitbulls to task.

  • alicia

    ******they would rather fight obama over nothing than to help him help us. i know people always say y do u have to use the race card but in this case i believe it to be true. they didn't want him in the whitehouse to begin with. they're doing everything they can to go against him but at our expense. they increased the debt ceiling several times when bush was in office. now all of a sudden u have a problem when u helped create this mess. also y aren't they willing to cut the gas tax and have the wealthy pay higher taxes? i'll tell u y, it's because those same oil companies and the wealthy r the ones who fund their campaigns/pockets and they don't wanna mess with their cash cow. they haven't done anything to try and help obama since he's been in office. all they do is bash him every 5 minutes. even their debate was about him. not about their suggestions or plans to make things better and still people support them. say what u want about obama but at least he's doing something!!!!!******

    • Sage

      Obamabots like you are hilarious to me because you talk about people playing the race card but no one has done that more that Black Obamabots and White racists.Black Obamabots think Blacks are supposed to support Obama based only on the fact that you see a half White man that comes in Black face as a Black man and you think Blacks owe him something because of what you see him as……..You are ignorant to his politics,you have just been brainwashed to see anyone who is not a democrat as the boogey-man but you are too stupid to see that Obama biggest inspirations in politics is Ronald Reagan.

      You're sitting up here talking about what Republicans have done but Obama has followed their path and you have nothing to say about that truth.Your entire rant is silly as is with most Obamabots.So what if Obama is blasted,it's up to his frail butt to defend himself but idiots like you act as if Blacks are to be his defenders.

      Obama isn't doing nothing but participating in wars and killing leaders and their people which include children in other countries.He is no different than the rest of the presidents except he's worst!

  • Mysterious Voice

    So………..Everyone that is Black and disapprove of Obama are now The Black Power Movement? What are you morons going to come up with next?

    You're not even from America so you have no say so whatsoever when it comes to Obama.Obama is a biracial president and his wife is Black .

    You say you "love" Obama and "we" are enthralled by him.Since when did you speak for all Black Canadians.Real people gives less than a damn about some distant inauguration or what Magic Johnson son said fool.

  • PJJ

    I don't give a hoot about cruises, "watermelon smiles", jealousies or personalities. The issue is whether President Obama deserves to be re-elected regardless of whether you consider him black, mulatto or what. That requires looking at his actions, leadership style–and the results. I agree with commentators here and the political and intellectual pundits who hold this President accountable just as they would for any other President. It is a very sad commentary that some people cannot have an intelligent, honest dialogue about Barack Obama's Presidency–and the "he's doing the best he can" dogma doesn't cut it. It further demonstrates the lack of critical thinking skills possessed by blacks–who are not exactly known for doing it (overall).

    Personally, I do not think Barack Obama is an effective leader. The "Stimulus" package was nothing but expensive b.s. which only stimulated the pockets of a select few…and temporarily at that. I have many other reasons but it will suffice to say that I will not be voting for him again. If you feel differently and have truly thought it through rather than going by emotions, then I respect that. However, if you are too lazy to think and are dictated by fat, self-serving preachers (or whomever leads the flock) then shame on you. And the irony is that you are the people who typically suffer the most in our economy. Hmm, maybe there's a connection here….

    Become accountable for your own actions and thought processes. When you do that you will find it is easier to hold others accountable as well.

  • Debbie Thurman

    When President Obama was sworn into office, he became president for all of America and not just Black America. From his first day in office, the president was responsible for managing two wars and a failing economy. He has to work with Congress and the Senate to make things better for all Americans. He was elected president, he was not elected DICTATOR. In a democracy, neither side of the isle will be able to achieve their total agenda. I have listened to both Tom Joyner and Tavis Smiley for many years and this situation is troubling to me. I have a great amount of respect for the work that both men have done to encourage our youth to educate themselves. What I can not understand is what Tavis and Dr. West realistically expect to gain by constantly criticizing and demeaning the president. In my opinion, their tactics only serve to diminish the enthusiasm of young black voters who are already reluctant to go to the polls. Mr. Smiley and Mr. West are both intelligent men. They must know that by disparaging Mr. Obama’s presidency, they are potentially setting the stage for a Republican victory in 2012. Do they think that Michelle Bachman will be more concerned about the “black agenda”? There was a time when Tavis Smiley had the collective ear of Black America. We waited to hear his opinions before formulating our own. It does seem to me that Tavis was overly critical of Mr. Obama even before he was elected. Is it possible that he resented having to share that “ear”? My hope is that Mr. Smiley and Mr. West will think carefully about their true motives before they speak. Allow the president a chance to work for the entire country without the two of them standing on the sidelines like attention seeking children screaming, “WHAT ABOUT ME? WHAT ABOUT ME?!”

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]