What Would Ida B. Wells Do About The Mysterious Case of Frederick Jermaine Carter?

March 31st, 2011 - By TheEditor

"Charing Ball"Our country’s national crime is lynching. It is not the creature of an hour, the sudden outburst of uncontrolled fury, or the unspeakable brutality of an insane mob.”

Those are the faithful words of Ida B. Wells (Barnett), a fearless black suffragist, journalist and anti-lynching crusader, who was most remembered for her tireless efforts to unearth and expose the fraudulent “reasons” behind the lynching of black men, a common occurrence in the years after Reconstruction.

A militant in her own right, Wells routinely traveled the U.S. and Britain to lecture about the inhumane treatment of blacks and organizing anti-lynching societies, which tried to rally political action around lynching in America.

One hundred plus years later, the spirit of Wells lives on in the blogosphere and newspaper articles from the black press, who all have been leading a crusade to uncover the truth behind the mysterious death of Frederick Jermaine Carter.  On December 3rd 2010, Carter, a 26-year old native of Sunflower, Mississippi, was found hanging from an oak tree in predominate white Greenwood County.

According to publish reports, many local blacks residents know to steer clear from the part of town where Carter’s body was found because of the history of racial hostility toward African Americans.  The black community in Greenwood has pretty much been on edge since the incident, and is mostly convinced that something more dubious transpired.

However, local authorities have maintained that there is no evidence that a crime was committed and chalked up Carter’s death to a history of “mental problems.”  The local coroner eventually ruled his death a suicide, and the matter was put to bed in the national media—for the most part. The lack of details, as well as the rush nature of the investigation by the local sheriff and the coroner’s office, has drawn the ire of black bloggers and journalists, who are not quite ready to accept the “official” findings.  Local black leadership—including state representative Willie Perkins, president of the Leflore County branch of the NAACP, and the mayor of Sunflower—also publicly issued their disbelief that Carter’s death was a suicide.

Family members of Carter, who refused to believe the findings, are demanding that another autopsy be performed. They are also requesting that the case be turned over to Dr. Adel Shaker, who is the state’s first medical examiner in 15 years.  Earlier last week, Shaker announced on a blog talk radio show that the death of Carter was by hanging but further investigation was needed to determine the cause.

While the family has yet to confirm the results publicly, if this new information is accurate, than this new finding would suggest that the state cannot rule out the possibility of foul play in Carter’s death, which would mean reopening the investigation. Given the history of Mississippi with its past of ruthless racial murders—such as Emmett Till who was executed only 12 miles north of where Carter’s was found—and where racial crimes against blacks are routinely aided by cover-ups from local authorities, it is quite conceivable that the public is being misled about the nature of Carter’s death.  Then again, it is also possible that local authorities were correct all along that Carter may have killed himself. However, with so much uncertainty in the air, it is only right that the Carter case be reopened and a thorough investigation be done – with the assistance of the US Justice Department. Until that day happens, it is my hope that the black press continue to channel the spirit of Wells and shine a light on this topic until justice is done.

Charing Ball is the author of the blog People, Places & Things.

More from StyleBlazer
More from MommyNoire

MadameNoire Video

Comment Disclaimer

Comments that contain profane or derogatory language, video links or exceed 200 words will require approval by a moderator before appearing in the comment section. XOXO-MN

  • thetruthis

    It happen, not only the family needs to try take care of the matter, but us as a people black people need to take care of the matter, and stop letting the blue eye devil, feel like its okay to harm or touch an african, thats why we no longer need to seat on our behinds and take a hit, we need to get up and start swinging, harder, knocking them out, sending them the warning, that why i think this gangs needs to get their priority straight, stop killing each other, and start gunning down the other man

  • Dustin

    I HIGHLY DOUBT that this was a result of racists. IDK what happened…But I don't think racists had anything to do with it.

  • Mays

    This article is very misleading. I live in Greenwood not far from where the man hung himself (yes, I believe he committed suicide) and this town is not predominantly white. The racial make up is about 70/30 with blacks being the majority. This man had a history of mental illness, he had attempted suicide twice before and had recently spent time in the state mental institution. The only DNA that was on the rope was his. There was no trauma to the body thar would indicate a struggle. There hasn't been any type of lynching in Greenwood in my lifetime ( I'm 42) The FBI has refused to get involved due to lack of evidence. How much more evidence do you need? Why are some people so sure that this poor man was lynched?

    • thoughts of mine

      No you are misleading. they arent saying that the town is predominantly white they are that the area is. The sheriff stated this fact as well. For you to live in greenwood then you should know that suicide has been ruled out. You should stop listening to half of the story. His suicide attempts have never been proven they are just hear say. You would probably say that there are has never been any unexplained deaths in Greenwood either. Shut Up stop covering up

  • Kayla

    I heard about this last year. So sad, but it sounds like he was murdered to me. The story the cops are trying to sell just doesn't fit.

    • Steve

      I Knew this old man that lived in that area, He used to tell me story's about his growing up years down south , he said if you were black you better not get caught in Greenwood after dark other wise come daylight you would be some strange fruit. His name was Tommas Hollis

  • Wendy

    My husband had informed me of this, I truly feel that the family should pursue the issue the scenario reaks of foul play……………………… My heart goes out to the family and young brother "RIP"……………..

  • Jenny

    I wonder what Ida B Wells would say about the fact that the biggest threat to a black man in America is another black man. For every one black man killed by someone of a different race, 20 are killed by each other. Wonder how that would fit into Ida's whole "Stop treating our men like animals" crusade.

    • BlackArt

      If she started a save an animal (dog & cat) crusade, you'd be the first dummy in line with a check. Considering every race other than white is a minority in the U.S., and the fact that high percentage of minority live in middle class- poverty neighborhoods, liquor stores every other corner ( owned by whites, Arab, Chinese),drug, gun distribution, poor quality education, & injustice. All of which is manufactured by whites, arab, & chinese. The street gangs which originated in the 50's-60's to originally protect the neighborhood against racist whites (knight riders etc.), today evolved into crime and drug purchasing from rich whites, I'd say she'd continue her cause.. Her cause against stupid AZZ people.

  • AND

    Mississipi Missippi people throughout history and black residing within that particular region still occupying foolishness from the white boys COME ON SERIOUSLY – Israel at the moment is practices kill one and three of yours die – Come on Mississipi black men/women…

    • thetruthis

      I totally agree, not giving up my gun for nobody

  • Sharon

    this is a shame. I try to tell people that stuff like this is still going on and here is the proof!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Loveme23

    So sad. Let justice be served.

Get the MadameNoire
Newsletter
The best stories sent right to your inbox!
close [x]