Glenn Beck’s Re-Write Of The Black Experience

June 16th, 2010 - By TheEditor

"Yvette Carnell"When Glenn Beck made his debut on CNN’s Headline News, I quickly dismissed him as the rodeo clown of talk television; a loud and wrong swindler who impishly welled up with an eyeful of tears at the mention of any and all things American.  He was, at least in my mind, an annoying but benign media fabrication.

Now though, Beck has managed to encroach upon the sacred ground of African-American history with his inane ramblings and for that, he should garner the contempt of every African American who still holds dear the struggles of ancestors whose blood, sweat, and genius are the foundation upon which this country is built.

On a recent installment of his ‘Founders Friday’ series, Beck paraded a series of contrived stories before his audience in an effort to convince them that the founders of this country were both black and white. Who knew?!

“What you don’t see in this painting (Battle of Lexington) are the equal number of whites and blacks. They were white and black patriots,” said Beck. Fact:  African-Americans were captured, torn away from their families, and brought to America as slaves, not as founders.  Our ancestors were brought here as commodities to be used to build and grow the wealth of white people. There is no free will in this scenario. Our progenitors were robbed of the fundamental freedom bestowed upon all living creatures and all of their behaviors during this period extended from that point of insipid exploitation.

The trajectory of our collective experience still reflects the measure to which we were methodically reduced by every rape, every sale, every lynching, and every beating and twisted perversion of our henchmen. It is therefore a contemptuous allegation for anyone to place African Americans in a position of ownership during a period in which we were chattel.

But Glenn Beck’s attempt at re-writing history cannot be categorized alongside the usual bumbling and foolhardy nonsense we’ve grown accustomed to from him.  This current web he’s spinning for his mostly white audience has a much more nefarious plot than what you’d normally expect from the oafish Beck.

Beck would love nothing more than to blur the line which existed between master and slave during the revolutionary era as it would lay the foundation for a bogus retelling of history. In Beck’s account of the historical events of this period, blacks and whites were partners.

Such a lopsided view of history reduces the culpability of the white community and, if allowed to propagate, forces the collective African-American narrative to recede into the backdrop of other less divisive societal calamities.  If left in the hands of money grubbing charlatans of the Glenn Beck variety, our historical suffering will be diminished to the point of non-recognition.

The lineage of African-American history, a centerpiece of which is African-American slavery and oppression, belongs solely to its heirs.  Glenn Beck should keep his grubby little paws off a historical perspective which he doesn’t own and obviously doesn’t understand since he, and those like him, are so far removed from human suffering that they’re unable to spot the glaring hypocrisy in their own assertions.

It is now time for the African-American community to reclaim the African American narrative. It is our torment, our despair, our struggle, our overcoming and ultimately, our story to tell.  Glenn Beck may be successful at pulling the wool over the eyes of those who haven’t yet experienced the effects of living in a duplicitous society which schemes to camouflage all painful truths with complex ambiguities, but we have and we know better.

We know Glenn Beck’s agenda because of what we’ve lived, and it is our responsibility to take back our history because of the knowledge that our experience has bestowed upon us. Tell Glenn Beck that he’s free to toy around all he’d like with his white boards and dry erase pens, but African-American history is off limits.

Yvette Carnell is a former Capitol Hill Staffer turned political blogger. She currently publishes two blogs, Spatterblog.com and GoGirlGuide.com.

Madame Noire Video

  • Hawk

    wooow I'm starting to think almost every ethnicity that's in America is racist.

  • dutch302

    Ah, before i forget. You are very attractive.Cliff

  • ken

    Perhaps we should applaud Mr. Beck on his effort so rewrite a chapter in the American saga which most white Americans care not to engage in anyway. They encourage us to get over it; forget about that stuff; or why do you have to bring that up"! Well. Mr Beck wants to smear the truth again. Anytime you find conservatives attempting to engage this topic, they have another motive. This time…it wasn't so bad, look, we were fighting for our freedom; look, their are black people in the picture. We must never forget.. Never!

  • Brian P. Fussmucker

    It never ceases to amaze me how victimized individuals wishes to keep itself to remain victimized to be relevant. The History of all peoples has many twists and turns with some individuals oppressed to others defiant. But it is in the sad middle where people who are unwilling to accept anything anyone outside their group says about their precious history because they've already prejudged the 'outsiders' point of view.

    The bottom line is, Yah, Beck is a bloviating buffoon but that's no reason not to explore what he said and find out of what he speaks. To say that Black History belongs to the Blacks is to say separate is equal. Oh my how far we've come.

  • kirk p

    What next? Blacks/Africans built and captained the slave ships?

  • shon

    Glenn Beck is a loose talking cornball.

  • Moore

    I am staggered, and I have to express a sense of pride in the few fellow Americans who have taken up a response to this article. To be honest, I checked these comments with trepidation as I have never really ventured an opinion on racial topics. The responses here give me hope that we can move forward in unity with a shared appreciation for America. I would be proud to be friends with any of you.

  • Karya

    As a person born and raised in East Africa, it never ceases to amaze me how Caucasians feel empowered to tell African Americans how to feel or think. Not one of them would ever dare even think to tell Jews the same thing. Bob Marley said, "Who feels it knows it Lord." Butt out and just listen.

  • dbzl

    How trifling that Beck would like to blur the lines of history. What next luring the lines of the lynchings, maybe blurring the lines of the facts of black families making much less than their white counterparts.

    Maybe he can blur to those who are stupid but to those of us who know, and have passed the history orally and from studies it is our job to fight him tooth and nail.

  • Obie

    Get over it!

  • Pingback: Glenn Beck’s Re-Write Of The Black Experience | Black Politics on the Web

  • Pips

    Strong points i share similar thoughts thanks

  • Yvette Carnell

    Dank,

    Although I disagree, I enjoyed your perspective. Feel free to Facebook me and we'll continue this discussion.

    Yvette Carnell

  • themisses

    Africa has not offered us as Black people any compensation<<??? We are not in an African country. We are in America….

    What would you want them to do, send us some money through moneygram??…lol

    did africa offer us citizenship in the african nation

    i see your point, but it is hard to make a strong argument out of this since african americans (or as u prefer "blacks") have no interest in returning to Africa. Most of us don't know where to start. you would have do long research in ancestry and discover what COUNTRY (africa is the CONTINENT) you came from, if you would so dare to take it that far.

    We do not live in an African country..we are not under the conditions of African people, we are in the U.S. and that is why we put that much emphasis on our experience in this country.

    Black Man an not an african<<<I don't think any of us consider ourselves as Africans, just African descendents….

    Whether you call your self Black OR African American is irrelevant because we and the rest of this country know where our roots lie. You can't distant yourself from your African ancestry…

  • Pips

    I did finish public school so i know what africa is, my point simply is this, no one owes me anything everyone involved were wrong. african or european and also what about Obama is he african or european and if he is both why do we call him black or african descent isnt he european descent or we use race logic but from an african point of vue I maintain my point if you get it fine if

  • Pips

    And the offer of citizenship would simply be symbolic and maybe even unify the decendants of the lost souls, also we speak of gettin a moneygram from europeans,also if i do look at myself as an african decendant everyone is from africa or out of africa

  • Pips

    for you africa is culture for me its where GOD placed man so you wear your kinte cloth i wear what I like, it doesnt matter how you see me its how I see and rep myself so you are right for your point im right for mine

  • Pips

    Please do not put all Blacks or Whites in one basket

  • blppanther

    Let me correct you, you're a Zionist and not a Jew. The original jews were people of color and not some fake Ashkenaze converts from the caucus muntains. You people are amazing how you have fooled some of the main stream into thinking that a bunch of European zionist are the original Jews, and not the people from the African Diaspora. You can't talk about victimization since the holocast was 70-65 years ago, and the trans atlantic slave trade lasted over 400 years with an additional 150 years of post emancipation jin crow.

    As a european jew, you can get over lots of things since all people notice first is your pink/white skin. The anglicanination of the traditional zionist names, blends in with the other europeans, masking you from the main-stream europeans. Religion is not shown outward on your skin, so no one would know what religion you are until you mention it if you're worried about being racialized. Let me also correct you on the meaning of the word semite, it meams people of color, which does not apply to the current zionist invaders of Palistine.

  • http://www.jppreyer.blogspot.com/ Jon Paul Preyer

    This article was brilliant, poignant, and truthful. All the responses herein pertaining are right in line with speaking the truth. It's amazing for people whose suffering brought the world to their defense, against the plots of Hitler to subjugate the whole, are chiming in with non-sense. To those Jews who find it inappropriate, or seemingly using our race card, a lot of black people died to free you from short-lived torment. Aside from the two freedom fighters who died in the 60's, where were your ancestors in liberating black people?