Abandon Detroit, Abandon Black America

June 2nd, 2010 - By TheEditor

Dr. Dumi Lewisby R. L’Heureux Lewis

Detroit: The city that represents the prospects and failures of American industry.The city that is the punch line of a million jokes. The city that is Blacker than nearly any other in this country. Detroit is under intense scrutiny as of late and the flashing lights of attention may have served to take the life of seven year old Aiyana Jones as a TV crew filmed a home-raid by the Detroit SWAT.

With all the fascination with Detroit around the nation we get the problems of the city beamed into our homes via satellite, but it makes me wonder, is there more there than what we normally see? What responsibility do we bear to Detroit?  And what opportunities are there for us to contribute?

Detroit is a microcosm of Black America. I believe if you cannot love Detroit, you cannot fully love Black people. The Detroit Metropolitan area represents the best and the worst that Black folks in this country have to offer. The Black middle class was solidified in and around Detroit with steady unionized blue collar labor in the auto industry.

The middle class expanded as more Black folks with college educations occupied managerial positions. Detroiters experienced and vigilantly fought the racisms of housing redlining, riots, as well as White and Black flight. Detroit has benefited and suffered at the hands of White and Black leadership. If there is a city that tells us about the promise and perils of Blackness, it’s Detroit.  I’m so interested in what happens in Detroit because if we can turn it around, we can turn around the rest of our cities.

We will soon reach the one-year anniversary of Time Inc. buying a house and settling up a field office in Detroit to document the city. When Time dedicated dollars and staff to exploring the city, I felt both hope and concern.

As a representative of the news media, I knew that Time would have a huge audience, given that it owns over 100 media outlets. At the same time, I knew they would likely take a traditional perspective and try to document the “tragedy of Detroit.” You know, run stories about a crumbling governance structure, emotive pieces on poverty, and the city-suburb divide which has crippled collaboration and deepened racial tensions.

Along with those stories, however, are other stories. When I lived in Michigan, I  hung out in Detroit and fell in love with the rich activism taking place. The strength of Detroiters and their voices are often missing from the reality shows and headlines. I often dream that the media would capture the voices of strength and struggle that fill Detroit. Maybe if they did that, Detroit would be the punch line of one less joke or serve as an example of how communities respond to tragedy with strategy.

For over a week, I’ve been reading stories and hearing about the loss of 7-year-old Aiyanna Jones’ life. She was killed as the Detroit SWAT used a no-knock warrant and a flash bomb, and a gun discharged as they searched for the murderer of 17-year-old Je’Rean Blake. The police were accompanied by a camera crew, so we could watch them “catch the bad guy.” Instead, they captured a reel full of reality that our communities are faced with all too often.

Detroit communities are addressing the consequences of poverty – like violence – and more importantly, the roots of poverty  – like education. On the ground, Detroiters are fighting back by forming the vanguard that is rethinking education, the media, health and youth issues. During the close of June, Detroit will host the Allied Media Conference, the United States Social Forum and the National Hip Hop Congress Conference.

These gatherings center on re-visioning how we write, talk about and imagine our communities.  All three of these gatherings will bring a groundswell of folks to Detroit to do more than watch decay; instead they will grapple with the perils of poverty and work through blueprints for changing Detroit and other communities from spectacles to spectacular loci.

It’s about time that we stop looking at Detroit and begin doing something with and for Detroit. As legendary Detroit activist Grace Lee Boggs said, “you cannot change any society unless you take responsibility for it, unless you see yourself as belonging to it and responsible for changing it.” It is time that we demand more of media, more of ourselves and help turn around the sullied gem of Black America.

R. L’Heureux Lewis is an Assistant Professor of Sociology and Black Studies at the City College of New York – CUNY. His research concentrates on issues of educational inequality, the role of race in contemporary society, and mental health well-being.

Madame Noire Video

  • RideThisBlackCowboy

    Why SHOULD Detroit be rescued?(save,of course,the innocent children who must attend those disgusting un-
    defunded,under-equipped,looted wrecks called "schools" and the now mostly-frail elders who suffered through Detroit's white racist polticians,police and other agencies of three generations ago,as well as today's
    thuggish popinjays,excluding Mayor Bing).These a**-clowns would steal the money and distribute it amongst their boys,babes and the larcenous big-wigs I previouly mentioned.

  • RideThisBlackCowboy

    OH,B.S.!!!The crooked politicians-yeah,YOU,KWAME!!!-scumbag,theiving "ministers,"Black Nationalist crazies.
    school board looters and hip-hop/thug-life "keepin' it real"-IGNORANT,THAT IS!!!!-not to mention the fat,fugly,b***hy broads-are the reason for affluent African Americans' abandonment of Detroit.

  • Kerry

    I see you live in Atlanta? You should move to the D before you speak.

  • elenore

    20% of Detroit is in fact white and the whites in Detroit have even higher levels of unemployment and higher levels of high school drop outs and crime.It's a poverty thing and lack of Cops.The suburbs have almost 4 million people and the fact is there was never enough black people to fill up Detroit alone because Blacks in Michigan also live in other Michigan cities.Suburbs in Detroit are as old as fight between French and New Yorkers in early Detroit,than Whites started leaving in 40's,more because of Southern whites they insulted,lived 5 families to a house and had many children the City Detroiters couldn't stand,original Detroiters moved out and left Hillbillies and Blacks to fight and the Blacks won.Southern Detroit started following other whites.However this was long ago,the suburbs were pushed to expand by changes to State Constitution by Gov.Romney.For 2 reasons to spread out manufacturing because of fear of attacks to Detroit from foreign nations and so everyone could form a neighborhoods and expand housing.I am younger,we have a new Detroit around the old one almost 4 million people,blacks are coming to suburbs now have been since I was child,it no big deal,suburbs are broken up more by incomes,services,and taxes than by race.The reason why Detroit continue to die is simple taxes and the fact that the city is over 300 years old and dire need of repair and services but short on funds.So the poor will continue to be left behind of any race.I am glad people are blending racially,why is that a big deal or a problem.But the poverty we are leaving is a problem and we should take responsibility for our fellow Americans,and push to start employment opportunities but that will only happen after the crime is under control,the State of Michigan needs to step up and take over police department.Why are you trying to guilt Black Detroiters into staying in the OLD CITY instead of moving to the new Detroit.

  • Keshia

    Sigh, looking at the comments I think a lot of people missed the message in this article. I am not a Detroit native but I attend law school in the area and I deal first hand with the criminal system. Being from Chicago, I can't say the level of violence is any different in Detroit and we are not lacking any corrupt politicians. However, having been born and raised in Chicago and lived the DC area, I can't say I have the same love for any of these cities like I have for Detroit. I know it can be an eyesore in certain areas and you can get robbed if you caught sleeping BUT I have met some of the best people during my time here…that include felons! They are really great people that at one time had great jobs and benefits. Like any other American they are trying to survive. What happened here has happened all across the nation. When an industry leaves there is a tremendous financial loss i.e. steel mills and those areas can take a big hit. Hopefully, with the new mayor things will turn around and the city will get over the numerous scandals that it is dealing with and start to really rebuild.

    I truly appreciate this article because you are saying the same things that I tell my friends when they try to clown Detroit and I get in defense mode!

  • CHYNA BEHR

    I'm not shocked to hear all of the blissfully ignorant comments , for being a waiter I'm almost like a fly on the wall to most of my Caucasian clients , since I'm either irrelevant to their conversations or they plain just don't give a f@#k ! I am what you might call a casualty of the inner city and would like to know what I can do to be a part of the solution for our people and not the problem. I grew up in HP and graduated from a Detroit High School and now reside in Southfield ,I don't think there is anything that any one person of any race wants that the other doesn't .I would like to have a good job,house raise my children in a safe environment just like any white ,black ,Indian, Mexican or any race would, but are we so naive as a people that we don't realize that all of our worldly conveniences come at some kind of price? Can everyone be rich or do the rich need some poor people 2 change their sheets an scrub their toilets? I think a lot of us have some very short memories that need be refreshed, maybe we need drink out of a water fountain with a COLORED sign over it so we can come back to reality and know

    that we should have taken advantage of one of the most precious gifts( DETROIT), that we took for granted and let slip between our fingers and perish like we've done with our schools ,children ,men daughters ,sons ,homes and most of all our souls, I love Detroit and I love my people and I uplift you to the most high a pray for your safe return, not your destruction…… .

  • mary

    detroit is like all innercities where as a new generation of blacks have came about and said i do not give a dam about my self and know one else so in order for me to get something i will rob steal and kill for my material things i will not go and get a fast food job or an education for my self but i will continue to bring children into this world and not take care of them and i will have a child by every guy or girl i date and i will not raise or teach that child to love and respect themselves and others nor will i teach that child discipline for adults they will no nothing about jesus christ our lord and saviour and no nothing about how i can all upon him for all my problems nor will i teach them to want more out of life because every one is not going to be a rapper or basketball or foot ball player this is sad and unfortunately the new generation of blacks and i will also kill anyone who is doing better than me or trying to do better than me because no one ever told me i could be some body in my life time so i will die young and i will go to jail young what a sad eulogy for lot of the new twenty first generation of black men and women and the children who did not ask for this mess.

  • Jeema

    I don't think that cities in general are a good venue for Blacks. If you look around it becomes very evident that sucessfull cities are run by whites.

    If the city is taken over by Black leadership, experience shows that the looting begins. The natural criminal instinct of Blacks chases the White working taxpayers out. If the Black populations are not supressed by the police – Black or White – then decline begins almost immediatly. You will hear about abandoning the city. I suppose after that, the Blacks will move on to destroy the next city. I predict it will be Chicage, as soon as the Whites are gone!

  • http://www.negash83.com Rocklin

    No One Focuses on The Good Things that happen in the city of Detroit everyday, There is Plenty of Media to focus on the negative…Detroit is full of any Creative and Positive people who will all blossom along with the city once all the blessing blockers are out the way.

  • Former Detroiter

    I moved out a while ago and I'm glad did. I did not want to raise my children there nor attend the jacked up school system. It's definitely not the place that I grew up.

    Chances of a comeback…I don't see it happening anytime soon.